Logitech Accused Again of Insulting Users with "Dog" Reference, Same Product Line Offends Twice in Half a Year, Copyright Holder Threatens Legal Action

Deep News11-02

Logitech has once again stirred public outrage. Recently, an advertisement posted by the official account of the Logitech G audio and video flagship store sparked heated discussion. In the ad, a cartoon dog, upon seeing the GPW4 mouse discounted by one hundred, looked disgusted and said "Not interested, thanks," but when it saw the post-coupon 40% off price starting with a 3, the dog immediately lit up and said "You really know people!"

Topics such as "Logitech is picking a fight with users" and "Logitech ad accused again of insulting users" quickly trended on social media. Netizens' comments were sharp: "Can their promotions ever stop obsessing over dogs?" and "Their marketing strategy never strays from implying male users are dogs who come running when there's a discount."

On November 2, Logitech's major flagship stores were still livestreaming on social platforms. On the official Douyin account of the Logitech G audio and video flagship store, the advertisement had already disappeared. Some consumers left comments under other product promotion videos on that account, saying, "Post-coupon? Only dogs would buy that."

In response, staff at the flagship store said, "We have launched an investigation. Thank you for your supervision and understanding. Logitech China always respects every player."

Another baffling issue is that the dog IP image used in the advertisement was not authorized. The copyright holder told the BUG column that the company's legal department is handling the matter and preparing to defend its rights in accordance with the law.

Insulting users? Logitech is a repeat offender

This is already the second time Logitech has had a similar incident, and both involved products from the GPW series. On March 26 this year, the Douyin account "Logitech G Official Flagship Store" posted a promotional video for the Logitech GPW3 mouse. The video opened with the subtitle "When you say 'I won't spend another penny,'" followed by a red mouse with the caption: "Really, the moment I drop the price, don't you come running like a dog."

The video content was accused of belittling and insulting consumers, triggering widespread anger and condemnation from netizens. Under public pressure, Logitech China issued a statement that evening apologizing for the inappropriate content posted by the "Logitech G Official Flagship Store." The statement said that Logitech China was sincerely shocked and pained by the extremely inappropriate content, fully understood and empathized with every player's disappointment and anger, and offered its most sincere apologies to users.

Regarding the cause of the incident, Logitech China said that an investigation found the inappropriate content was published by an individual employee of Shanghai Best Electronic Co., Ltd., who bypassed Logitech China's marketing material review process without authorization, seriously violating Logitech China's brand guidelines. Logitech China said it would deeply review its management of authorized stores' marketing activities and resolutely prevent such incidents from happening again.

At the time, the "Logitech G Official Flagship Store" was operated by Shanghai Best Electronic Co., Ltd. under authorization from Logitech China, responsible for Logitech product sales on the Douyin channel. A BUG column inquiry found that Shanghai Best Electronic Co., Ltd. is a small business established in 2001, mainly engaged in wholesale, with two natural persons as shareholders. Due to the incident, Best Electronic was fined 200,000 yuan by the Shanghai Jing'an District Market Supervision Administration in July this year.

Unexpectedly, just over seven months later, Logitech made the same mistake in the same place again. It is unclear whether it was again the supplier's fault this time.

"I can call myself cheap, but Logitech can't," one consumer said, analyzing their reaction to the advertisement. "I spend money on your product. You can understand my preferences, study my purchasing habits, and even know when I'm most easily swayed by price. But that understanding doesn't give you the right to define me. I can say I'm someone who can't resist ordering when there's a discount. You can't stand beside me and laugh at me just because you've figured out my consumer psychology."

The consumer drew a comparison: "A friend laughing at me for buying another mouse is not the same as the person selling the mouse laughing at me for falling for it again."

The IP image in the ad also infringes copyright

In fact, besides the advertisement content being accused of insulting consumers, Logitech has run into another problem. The dog meme used in the Logitech G audio and video flagship store's advertisement video is called "Beagle Dongdong," a popular character from the Chinese original IP "Siam Lipo." The IP originated in 2022, starting with memes and later expanding into comics and short videos.

The BUG column contacted Xiamen Qizhongji Culture Media Co., Ltd., the copyright holder of the IP. Company staff said the company had not authorized Logitech or its affiliates to use Beagle Dongdong in related product promotion videos, and the company's legal department is currently defending its rights on the matter.

Beijing lawyer Liu Yabo said that Beagle Dongdong is an artistic work protected by the Copyright Law, explicitly listed as a protected work under Article 3, Item 4 of the Copyright Law. Clipping, uploading, and disseminating the image in a product promotion video involves the right of reproduction, the right of information network dissemination, and the right of integrity of the work under Article 10 of the Copyright Law. The exercise of these rights requires explicit permission from the copyright owner. Since the rights holder has clearly not authorized Logitech and its related entities to use it, the use may constitute infringement.

If the advertisement was produced and published by an agency operator, who bears responsibility? Lawyer Liu Yabo pointed out that advertisement videos are usually jointly completed by the brand, production company, and agency operator. Unauthorized use of another's work constitutes joint infringement, and under Article 1168 of the Civil Code, they bear joint liability. If the brand has review authority over the advertisement script and materials, instructed their production, participated in unified marketing arrangements, or obtained corresponding revenue from the promotion, it may be found jointly liable.

Lawyer Liu Yabo said that under Article 54 of the Copyright Law, anyone who infringes copyright or rights related to copyright shall compensate based on the actual loss suffered by the rights holder or the illegal gains of the infringer. If the actual loss or illegal gains are difficult to calculate, compensation may be given by reference to the royalty for use of the right. He noted that such IP licensing has market quotations that can serve as a reference base for licensing fees, but whether infringement is ultimately established still requires comprehensive determination based on complete evidence, authorization documents, and usage details.

Latest financial report: operating cash flow down 6.6% year-on-year

On the financial side, Logitech recently released its report for the first half of fiscal year 2027 (April 1, 2026 to September 30, 2026). The report showed that in the first half of fiscal year 2027, Logitech's total operating revenue was 2.446 billion US dollars (approximately 16.349 billion yuan), up 5% year-on-year; gross profit was 1.155 billion US dollars (approximately 7.72 billion yuan), up 16.26% year-on-year, with a gross margin of 47.2%; net profit attributable to shareholders was 416 million US dollars (approximately 2.779 billion yuan), up 31.28% year-on-year; but operating cash flow was 330 million US dollars (approximately 2.207 billion yuan), down 6.67% year-on-year.

However, the financial report also released a supply chain warning signal. Affected by an accident at a semiconductor supplier's factory, Logitech expects net sales in the third fiscal quarter to be negatively impacted by approximately 70 million to 80 million US dollars, with the impact expected to be largely eliminated by the fourth fiscal quarter. Logitech's CEO previously said publicly that AI infrastructure demand is squeezing chip production capacity, and the company is actively seeking alternative suppliers.

Industry commentator Zhang Shule believes that this incident, in a sense, reflects Logitech being caught in its own "dog chasing mouse" mouse anxiety and marketing frenzy. "In the mobile internet era, the frequency and duration of mouse use have been greatly diluted. Coupled with the relatively small consumer base for gaming mice, even a mouse giant like Logitech covering high, mid, and low ends finds it hard to reverse the consumption decline. At the same time, as a very mature category, mice can hardly offer ordinary consumers a differentiated experience, so some quality issues get further amplified."

Zhang Shule believes that choosing outrageous marketing to break out of the circle may be a self-selected move by Logitech China to alleviate its "mouse anxiety." He pointed out that this marketing failure is even highly consistent in wording with the March incident, both describing users as "dogs" and framing the appeal of "price cuts" and "discounts" as discriminatory "dog won't even look at it" memes. In a sense, this shows the "arrogance and prejudice" of this international big brand toward Chinese consumers, and also shows that it has not deeply reflected on its past behavior in terms of public opinion, sentiment, and crisis public relations.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment