Memory Chip Market Splits: DRAM Holds Firm While NAND Quietly Shifts, According to BofA

Deep News11-15 16:34

The memory chip sector is transitioning from a uniform rally to a more divergent pattern.

Bank of America (BofA) believes the upward pricing logic for DRAM remains intact, while NAND spot prices have visibly loosened, making NAND the first product category in this memory upcycle that needs to be repriced.

A BofA report dated November 13 showed that NAND spot prices declined significantly, with 512Gb wafers falling more than 10% and 1Tb dropping nearly mid-single digits, while 16Gb DDR5 spot prices held flat. Since mid-to-late October, NAND spot prices have cumulatively retreated by approximately 20%.

Based on this, BofA maintained a cautious assumption for NAND average selling prices in the first quarter of 2027: IT NAND prices declining 5% to 10% quarter-on-quarter, enterprise applications roughly flat or slightly higher, and overall low-single-digit declines. This view stands in clear contrast to the market's continued expectation of NAND price increases of more than 10%. Meanwhile, BofA still assumes DRAM price increases extend through the fourth quarter of 2026 (up 8% quarter-on-quarter) and the first quarter of 2027 (up 5%).

BofA stated that after conversations with investors this week, sentiment on memory stocks has improved compared to last week, with companies more heavily weighted in DRAM seen as having limited downside. Most DRAM names currently trade at only 3 to 5 times forward earnings for 2026 to 2027, well below AI semiconductor peers.

Three Signals of NAND Spot Weakness

BofA attributed its NAND concerns to three points: spot prices have retreated about 20% since mid-to-late October; order weakness from PC and smartphone OEMs as well as Chinese hyperscale cloud providers; and the possibility that first-quarter 2027 contract price negotiations could be delayed, with no rush orders appearing in the market.

The divergence in spot data is quite clear. According to DRAMeXchange, 512Gb wafer spot prices stood at $14.3, down 12% week-on-week and 32% quarter-on-quarter, but still up 121% year-on-year; 1Tb stood at $24.9, down 4% week-on-week and 19% quarter-on-quarter, but up 194% year-on-year. By comparison, 16Gb DDR5 stood at $60.2, flat week-on-week but up 150% year-on-year.

Chipmakers continue to emphasize strong enterprise SSD demand on their end, which can partially offset weakness in IT NAND. However, BofA cautioned that legacy production lines account for 20% to 30% of total global wafer capacity and are not suitable for producing high-end NAND and eSSDs, meaning they must continue to be used for IT NAND, creating structural pressure on prices. Per-bit prices for high-capacity NAND (above 2Tb) and eSSDs (above 30TB) saw slight downward adjustments, but BofA views this more as proactive promotional activity by manufacturers to drive adoption of the new QLC generation, noting that NAND prices for most eSSDs still show a slight upward trend.

The Divergence: Contract Prices Still Elevated, but Negotiations May Be Delayed

NAND contract prices and spot prices are currently moving in opposite directions.

According to TrendForce, 1Tb TLC wafer contract prices in October were basically flat month-on-month, extending the sideways pattern from the second and third quarters; 512Gb contract prices were around $27, close to historical highs and roughly ten times the low of $2.5 seen in February 2025.

BofA's concern lies in timing: if downstream customers continue to withhold urgent orders, first-quarter 2027 contract price negotiations could be pushed back, weakening manufacturers' bargaining power in the next round of talks. This view directly corresponds to its divergence from market expectations, as sell-side analysts generally assume NAND prices will still rise by around 10%, while BofA projects low-single-digit declines.

DRAM presents a different picture. According to TrendForce, 16Gb DDR5 contract prices rose another 5% month-on-month in October, with year-on-year gains exceeding 500%; server-side 64GB DDR5 and DDR4 module contract prices rose about 15% month-on-month in October, with module prices breaking above $1,000 to reach $1,600 and $1,500 respectively. Based on this, BofA maintained its assumption of DRAM price increases of 8% in the fourth quarter of 2026 and 5% in the first quarter of 2027.

Samsung: Optimistic on HBM but Not Aggressive

BofA hosted an investor call with Samsung Electronics on November 12, yielding three key takeaways: demand for AI data center chips in the U.S. remains strong, with no order cuts seen despite concerns; Samsung's position in the HBM market has improved markedly from its weakness a year ago; and long-term agreement (LTA) prices for the DRAM business are rising strongly, with high selling prices and high margins sustainable over a longer cycle.

However, management's tone was not aggressive, which was also one of the focal points for investors. Samsung set its HBM share target at around 30% to 40%, rather than above 50%; even by the end of 2027, LPDDR5 profitability will still exceed HBM, making overly aggressive HBM capacity expansion unlikely in order to avoid eroding traditional DRAM market share. On the technology roadmap, HBM4e will share the same 1c node and 4nm logic chip as HBM4. BofA also noted that 2027 contract price increases are unlikely to reach the levels expected by TrendForce, since prices already rose earlier in 2026.

Notably, Samsung's guidance for IT NAND is less optimistic than for eSSDs, consistent with BofA's price assessment.

Sentiment Improving, Valuation Remains a Key Support

Memory stocks rebounded this week, with year-to-date gains generally exceeding 100%, while SanDisk and Kioxia have delivered year-to-date returns of more than 250%. BofA said investors it spoke with this week generally cited limited downside, reasoning that AIDC chip orders have remained resilient after the U.S. midterm elections, DRAM prices continue to rise (in contrast to NAND), and valuation multiples are low.

The valuation table shows SK Hynix trading at 3.6 times 2026 earnings, Samsung at 4.7 times, Micron at 10.7 times, and Nanya at 5.1 times; within the NAND camp, Sandisk trades at 4.3 times 2027 earnings, Western Digital at 13.2 times, SIMO at 16.4 times, and Phison at 7.7 times. BofA believes the memory sector remains modestly priced relative to AI semiconductor peers.

BofA concluded that DRAM supply-demand and pricing trends remain supported by AI data centers and HBM crowding out capacity, while pricing power in NAND is tilting toward buyers. The valuation gap and earnings elasticity between the two will depend on whether first-quarter 2027 contract price negotiations can proceed on schedule.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment