Analysts Clash with Market: SanDisk Faces Sell-Off Despite Bullish Price Target Hike Ahead of August Earnings

Stock News07-13 15:05

Goldman Sachs has raised its price target for SanDisk Corp. (SNDK.US) from $1,200 to $2,200, reaffirming its "Buy" rating.

This aggressive adjustment reflects not only the firm's confidence in SanDisk's fundamentals but also signals strong optimism for the company's upcoming fiscal 2026 fourth-quarter results, scheduled for release in August.

Analyst James Schneider's adjusted earnings per share forecast for SanDisk's 2026 calendar year is nearly 30% above the Wall Street consensus, driven primarily by tight NAND flash supply and an improving product mix for enterprise solid-state drives (SSDs) with hyperscale customers.

August Earnings Preview: A Strong Quarter Expected

The firm's research report explicitly predicts that SanDisk's fiscal Q4 results will represent an "exceptionally strong quarter."

This outlook is based on several favorable factors, starting with the persistently tight supply and demand for NAND flash memory.

Goldman Sachs believes the global shortage of NAND flash chips will continue into 2026, with demand recovering across mobile, PC, and data center segments while production capacity is constrained by the high-end AI storage market, keeping market prices on an upward trend.

SanDisk's management indicated at a Mizuho technology conference in early June that even at the lower end of the pricing range under its new business model agreements, "we like these margins," and they will "be consistent with the margin guidance for the fourth quarter."

Secondly, the company's product mix is continuously improving.

Goldman specifically noted that SanDisk's enterprise SSD portfolio with hyperscale customers is strengthening.

In the fiscal 2026 third quarter, the company's enterprise SSD revenue surged 233% sequentially, while data center revenue skyrocketed 645% year-over-year.

Management confirmed that the fiscal fourth quarter will be the first period to recognize revenue from the Stargate high-capacity enterprise SSD product line, a solution built for AI storage workloads, marking the official launch of SanDisk's second major growth engine.

Third, the financial guidance already hints at strong performance.

SanDisk's management provided an optimistic outlook for the fourth quarter during the Q3 earnings report, forecasting revenue between $7.75 billion and $8.25 billion, non-GAAP gross margins of 79% to 81%, and non-GAAP EPS of $30 to $33.

Goldman Sachs believes actual results could exceed this guidance.

Upgrades Amid a Market Sell-Off

Goldman Sachs is not alone in its bullish stance on SanDisk.

In late June, Bernstein raised its price target from $1,700 to $3,000, and in early July, Bank of America also increased its target to $2,500.

Despite this clear trend of upward revisions, the stock's performance has not followed suit.

On the day Goldman released its report, SanDisk shares rose only about 3% to 5% before continuing to decline amid a broader sell-off across the memory sector.

Against the backdrop of a general market pullback, this rating upgrade had almost no positive impact on the share price.

This disconnect lies at the heart of the current debate: analysts are pricing in sustainable, structurally higher earnings, while the market is pricing the stock as if it's at a cyclical peak.

The sell-off did not originate with SanDisk but from thousands of miles away.

Samsung Electronics reported record preliminary second-quarter operating profit of approximately 89 trillion won, a surge of about 19 times year-over-year, yet memory stocks were still sold off.

This market reaction signaled to investors that the good news was already fully priced in.

Subsequently, market concerns shifted to capacity, as Samsung and SK Hynix announced expansion plans just as the AI-related capital expenditure cycle is expected to peak, potentially leading to softer NAND flash prices.

For SanDisk, the concern is more specific.

A significant portion of its output is still sold on the open market.

Reports regarding the company's supply for fiscal 2027 indicate that multi-year agreements cover over one-third of its bit supply, meaning the majority of the remainder remains exposed to spot price volatility.

If NAND prices decline, this uncommitted production would be the first to feel the impact, putting pressure on the company's trailing 12-month gross margin of 56.0%.

This is the core of the bearish argument, and it is not without merit.

Cyclical Peak or Structural Shift?

From a valuation perspective, however, following the significant July correction, SanDisk's forward price-to-earnings ratio has dropped to around 9, well below its historical highs.

The company is in a net cash position with net debt of negative $3.53 billion and has announced a $6 billion stock buyback program—actions not typically taken by a company on the brink of collapse.

Goldman's $2,200 price target implies an upside potential of approximately 21% from current levels.

If the August earnings report proves to be as "exceptionally strong" as Goldman anticipates, this standoff between analysts and the market may reach a turning point.

For investors, however, the true test lies in determining whether the AI-driven surge in storage demand represents a one-off capital expenditure spike or a multi-year structural transformation.

Goldman Sachs is clearly betting on the latter.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment