JPMorgan has assigned SanDisk a "Neutral" rating with a target price of $235. The firm argues that while SanDisk is currently experiencing peak profits driven by AI demand and cost advantages from its joint venture, this reflects cyclical industry conditions rather than structural improvements.
According to trading desk sources, JPMorgan analyst Harlan Sur noted in a December 8 initiation report that the company's long-term profitability faces dual constraints: first, its mere 2-3% market share in the rapidly growing AI storage sector positions it as a follower; second, the industry's historical "boom-bust" cycle is expected to re-emerge post-2027 as new capacity comes online, gradually eroding current supply shortages and pricing power.
The report highlights that SanDisk's stock has surged over 500% year-to-date, meaning current risk-reward dynamics appear balanced. Even with projected significant revenue growth and improved profitability in 2025-2026, these represent cyclical highs during an industry upswing rather than sustainable gains. Consequently, short-term excess profits are unlikely to justify long-term valuation expansion, potentially reverting to historical cyclical patterns.
**Relative Weakness in the AI Storage Supercycle** JPMorgan points out SanDisk's disadvantaged position in the fast-growing enterprise SSD market. While this sector is projected to grow at a 35% CAGR to reach $45 billion by 2027, SanDisk holds just 2-3% global share—far below its ~15% share in the broader NAND market.
Analysts acknowledge SanDisk's engagement with major hyperscalers has driven nearly triple-digit data center revenue growth for FY2025. However, compared to leaders like Samsung and SK Hynix, SanDisk remains a follower in high-performance PCIe 5.0 enterprise SSDs.
The report notes SanDisk's QLC technology provides differentiation in ultra-high-capacity storage (64TB-256TB roadmaps), but these products won't see broad availability until late 2026/early 2027, introducing execution and timing risks.
**Structural Cost Advantage: The Double-Edged Sword of Kioxia JV** JPMorgan identifies SanDisk's Flash Ventures joint venture with Kioxia as a core competitive strength. The arrangement allows SanDisk to secure 50% wafer output at equal cost, leveraging Kioxia's balance sheet, Japanese subsidies, and shared R&D to reduce capital intensity and improve ROIC.
This model provides resilience during NAND downturns and superior margins in upcycles compared to peers building fully owned fabs or purchasing commercial NAND. However, the JV structure also ties SanDisk's fortunes to Kioxia's health and strategic direction, limiting independent decision-making on capacity expansion and technology development.
**Cyclical Risks: Current Boom May Prove Temporary** The firm emphasizes that NAND's inherent cyclicality means today's tight supply and high prices represent an extended peak rather than structural change. Historically, shortages trigger aggressive capacity expansions—once high margins incentivize new investments, the cycle turns.
From 2027 onward, major suppliers are expected to resume large-scale capacity builds and advance 3D NAND layer counts, potentially outpacing demand growth. Meanwhile, traditional end markets show slowing growth: smartphone storage CAGR is projected at just 10% (2025-2027) versus 23% historically, while client SSD growth (11% CAGR) lags enterprise SSDs (35% CAGR).
These trends suggest new capacity and slowing demand will gradually erode current supply-driven premiums, restoring the market's cyclical nature.
**Strong Near-Term, Mean Reversion Long-Term** JPMorgan forecasts SanDisk will outperform the broader NAND market with 18%/38% revenue growth in 2025/2026, lifting its share to ~16% by end-2026 (up 300bps from ~13%). However, these results reflect cyclical highs rather than structural improvement.
Analysts advise investors to value the company across full cycles, treating current profitability as peak-cycle performance that will normalize as supply increases and competition intensifies.
Comments