Democrats Vow to Cut Living Costs, but Soaring Deficits and Rate-Hike Risks Leave Narrow Room to Maneuver

Stock News11-12

For the incoming Democratic majority in Congress, choosing affordability and the cost of living as the centerpiece of its campaign was the straightforward part. The hard part starts now: turning those campaign promises into reality.

Democrats say they will move quickly to restore health insurance subsidies under the Affordable Care Act and to roll back cuts to Medicaid and food assistance pushed through by the Trump administration and congressional Republicans. Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, who is expected to become House speaker, has also said the chamber will vote to repeal some government tariffs, which have raised costs for businesses and consumers.

Yet the party will be hemmed in on multiple fronts: President Trump still controls the executive branch and holds a veto pen, the fiscal outlook is grim, and the Federal Reserve may raise interest rates further. Then there is the stubborn policy challenge that costs such as housing and fuel have no easy fix.

Democrats Vow to Cut Living Costs

Maya MacGuineas, president of the nonpartisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, warned of the risk of "political pandering," noting that the U.S. deficit is running at roughly 6% of gross domestic product, so more spending could make matters worse in the near term.

"Democrats' affordability agenda depends heavily on whether we are fiscally responsible. Once people understand that when the deficit is this large, you cannot lower interest rates, cannot lower prices, and cannot raise wages," MacGuineas said in an interview. She added that curbing the rising debt would require both spending cuts and tax increases.

The question of how to reward voters for trusting the party on economic matters has already exposed divisions within Democratic ranks, including among those who delivered the party its most dramatic wins this month.

Senator-elect Annie Andrews of South Carolina said she would rather work with Trump to advance the party's goals on the cost of living than devote energy to a "revenge tour."

"I am willing to work with President Trump to secure the border, stop these Medicaid cuts, and find a way to end this war," Andrews said in an interview after her victory. "Fighting the administration will not lower gasoline prices or grocery prices, and it will not solve the problems I heard about over the past 18 months."

But that instinct is unacceptable to many in the party, who see a nationwide rejection of Republicans as a mandate for bold policy action, including on economic issues.

"When we hold power, we have to do something with it," said Rebecca Katz, a Democratic strategist and co-founder of the Fight Agency. She worked on several of the party's winning campaigns, including that of Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and last year's campaign of New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Katz spoke on Tuesday at a forum organized by the progressive economic think tank Groundwork Collaborative, where party advisers and lawmakers, including Senators Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, discussed how to show voters they are acting on their economic concerns.

Since Trump first signaled a willingness to work with Democrats, Warren has urged her party to "call his bluff" and send a batch of new legislation to the president, covering everything from drug pricing to the war with Iran.

But party strategists also say that using the bully pulpit to win better prices and treatment for consumers may be just as important, and perhaps more effective, than trying to move hard-to-control economic forces.

"This incoming class of Democrats is in a delicate position: they have a mandate at the federal, state, and local levels, but at the federal level they do not control the executive branch," said Alvaro Bedoya, a former commissioner of the Federal Trade Commission. He previously served as legal counsel to Democratic Senator Al Franken of Minnesota. Bedoya cited the example of Instacart: within days of receiving a public letter from Democratic senators, the company abandoned a test of floating grocery pricing. He said in an interview that this is a tactic the party can replicate.

"If you send an oversight letter to a public company, the response tends to come much faster, because that company has to answer to consumers and has to answer to a media uproar," Bedoya said.

During the Biden administration, congressional Democrats and the administration publicly named drugmakers over patent practices, prompting companies including Boehringer Ingelheim, AstraZeneca, and GSK to voluntarily cap inhaler prices at $35. According to Alex Jacquez, senior vice president for policy, advocacy, and research at Groundwork Collaborative, Democrats in the next Congress can apply similar pressure on utilities, health care, and rental companies over price increases or potential collusion. The group has been working with congressional Democrats to shape economic strategy.

"You can imagine looking at algorithmic rent collusion or tenant service fees in the housing market, and then on health care costs," Jacquez said, referring to pharmaceutical companies and pharmacy benefit managers.

Ben Harris, director of economic studies at the Brookings Institution and a former assistant secretary at the Treasury during Janet Yellen's tenure, said Democrats can also use leverage in negotiations over the annual budget and raising the U.S. government's borrowing limit to force rollbacks of cuts to SNAP, Medicare, and Medicaid. The U.S. is expected to hit the congressionally authorized debt ceiling next year.

Harris also expects the tension between moderate and progressive Democrats over affordability to keep playing out: voices on the left advocate "tougher measures," such as rent control, while centrist Democrats focus more on housing, health care, and education.

Party organizers say the biggest risk for the new majority is not being bold enough.

"It will be hard for us to deliver on our promises," said Amanda Litman, founder of the nonprofit Run For Something, which recruits candidates for public office. "We are seeing this with Trump right now: voters notice. Do not write checks you cannot cash, do not make promises you cannot keep. I worry that this is a real concern."

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment