Wall Street Pullback Fails to Cool Premiums: What Is the Real Cost of a Cross-Border ETF "Ticket"?

Deep News11-12

The high-premium "10:30 curse" refuses to break, and everything comes down to one thing: "just being able to buy it."

The Nasdaq has pulled back, yet the "tickets" in investors' hands have not come down in price along with it. As overseas markets swing and retreat, some cross-border ETFs continue to hold elevated premiums.

On November 12, the Nasdaq Technology ETF Invesco was suspended from trading again in the morning session due to a high premium, and its closing IOPV premium-discount rate reached 38.06%, keeping it firmly at the top of the cross-border ETF premium rankings. That day, every cross-border ETF with a premium above 12% was a Nasdaq product.

Premiums on a number of Nasdaq ETFs stayed stubbornly high, prompting fund companies to flood the market with premium risk warnings and to repeatedly trigger temporary trading halts and resumptions. Data shows that the 15 cross-border ETFs tied to the Nasdaq alone issued 461 premium risk announcements in the past month, with cumulative trading suspensions over the year numbering in the hundreds.

Even as fund companies warn of risks again and again and suspensions come in round after round, double-digit premiums remain commonplace. "The suspension is as punctual as an alarm clock, but the premium is like a spring, bouncing right back to where it was after trading resumes," one industry insider described it.

In the view of those interviewed, a high premium is essentially a "sentiment premium" paid upfront. Market history has repeatedly proven that high premiums on cross-border ETFs can never be sustained over the long run. Against the backdrop of lingering volatility in U.S. stocks themselves, chasing high-premium cross-border ETFs means simultaneously bearing the dual risks of market swings and premium convergence.

The high-premium "10:30 curse" proves hard to break

Wind data shows that as of November 11, the Nasdaq Index had fallen 6.94% over the past month, while the Nasdaq 100 and the Nasdaq Technology Market Cap Weighted Index fell even more over the same period, at -8.12% and -12.08% respectively. Even as the index pulled back, the premiums on related cross-border ETFs did not "recede" along with it.

In this round of premium trading, the Nasdaq Technology ETF Invesco, which focuses on the U.S. tech sector, stood out in particular. On the morning of November 12, the product was once again temporarily suspended for one hour due to a high premium. On the previous trading day, its secondary-market closing price was 2.942 yuan, while its reference net value per fund unit was only 2.0612 yuan, putting the IOPV premium-discount rate at about 42.73%, still firmly above the 40% mark.

This is no isolated case. Excluding products suspended for dividend distributions, as many as 16 cross-border ETFs were suspended for one hour on the 12th, 13 of which were Nasdaq-related products, all with premiums above 15% the previous day. Besides the Nasdaq Technology ETF Invesco, there were 12 ETFs tracking the Nasdaq 100 index from Harvest, Guotai, E Fund, GF and others, as well as products tied to the S&P 500 and the MSCI USA 50 Index.

After the cooling-off period of suspension, the premiums did not "calm down." Data shows that every ETF with an IOPV premium-discount rate above 12% that day was a Nasdaq-related product, with the Nasdaq Technology ETF Invesco's IOPV premium-discount rate reaching 38.06%, still topping the cross-border ETF premium rankings. The Nasdaq ETF Harvest, Nasdaq ETF Guotai and Nasdaq ETF E Fund all exceeded 16%.

High premiums are nothing new. Taking the Nasdaq Technology ETF Invesco as an example, Wind data shows that as of November 12, the fund had already been suspended and resumed 207 times during the year, almost settling into a daily routine. Counting other Nasdaq-related ETFs, the number of suspensions during the year reached 720. In the past month alone, more than 60 products issued over 900 risk-warning-related announcements, with the 15 Nasdaq-related products accounting for 461 of them, nearly half the total.

Fund companies repeatedly remind investors of the same thing: the secondary-market trading price is significantly higher than the reference net value per fund unit, and blindly chasing the rally could lead to major losses. But even with repeated risk warnings and even suspensions, the premiums have not been "talked down." As of November 12, the Nasdaq Technology ETF Invesco's single-day IOPV premium-discount rate over the past year had stayed in double digits, and had exceeded 33% for the past 15 trading days. Nasdaq ETFs under Harvest, Guotai, E Fund and other fund companies were much the same, maintaining double-digit IOPV premium-discount rates over the past 15 trading days and exceeding 20% on multiple occasions.

Beyond these products, several other cross-border ETFs have drawn market attention due to high premiums. On November 12, for instance, 28 cross-border ETFs had IOPV premium rates above 3%, including popular products such as the China-Korea Semiconductor ETF Huatai-PineBridge and the Nikkei 225 ETF Hua An.

Why risk warnings have become background noise

The premium rate of a cross-border ETF reflects the deviation of the on-exchange trading price from the product's net value. The fund's net value reflects the value of the assets corresponding to each fund unit, while the secondary-market price is determined by supply and demand between buyers and sellers. In the view of industry insiders, the premium phenomenon is a combined reflection of market supply and demand and investor sentiment.

An investment research professional at a large institution laid out the math plainly: assuming a product's premium rate is 30%, it means a fund unit actually worth only 100 yuan costs 130 yuan to buy, equivalent to "pre-paying" a 30% gain. In his view, this looks like a "price increase" but is actually an "inflated cost," essentially a surcharge paid for the three words "being able to buy it." Risk warnings and temporary suspensions are both active moves by fund companies to cool an overheated market mood.

An index fund manager told Yicai that under relevant operating practices, when an ETF's closing price is more than 5% above the reference net value per fund unit, the fund company needs to issue a premium risk warning announcement. If it exceeds 10%, it must also report for a suspension in advance, halting trading for one hour at the open of the next trading day. If the intraday premium rate does not effectively fall after trading resumes, the fund company may apply for another temporary suspension.

So why are cross-border ETFs drawing such attention? Yicai learned from multiple industry insiders that as investors' demand for overseas asset allocation rises, cross-border products have long been favored by the market. Especially as volatility in overseas markets intensifies markedly, related cross-border ETFs have become noticeably more sought after.

"QDII quotas are tight. When subscriptions are restricted and on-exchange buying is crowded, the trading price will deviate noticeably from the fund's net value," said a person at a fund company in South China. He also noted that some investors are using the market adjustment to buy at lows. In his view, demand exceeding supply, combined with the blind herd mentality of some investors, keeps pushing the premium rates of such products higher.

In fact, the narrowing of off-exchange channels is visible to the naked eye. Taking the Nasdaq direction as an example, subscriptions for related off-exchange products are shrinking sharply. As of November 12, Nasdaq 100 ETF feeder funds under China Merchants, GF, Hua An and others had suspended subscriptions, the daily large subscription limit for the Huatai-PineBridge Nasdaq 100 ETF feeder A was only 5 yuan, and several products such as the Baoying Nasdaq 100 Index A maintained daily purchase limits at the 10-yuan level.

"If you buy at a high premium, it means paying a certain extra cost right upon entry, and that portion could evaporate when the price later returns to net value," the person also warned. The extra money paid is essentially a bubble fueled by frenzied market sentiment. Historical data has repeatedly verified that high premiums on cross-border ETFs can never be sustained over the long term.

At the current juncture, some of those interviewed remain cautiously optimistic about U.S. stocks after the short-term adjustment. A QDII fund manager in North China said this round of market adjustment offers a relatively good opportunity to reposition into quality U.S. tech assets, and he will focus on mining alpha to add quality companies with prominent long-term competitive advantages, clear industry logic and certainty in earnings growth.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment