Oil's War Premium Vanishes: Goldman Sachs Says Now Is the Time to Buy Commodity Hedges

Deep News16:08

The sudden disappearance of the geopolitical premium in crude oil has not pushed Goldman Sachs toward a bearish stance; instead, the bank views it as the best window to build commodity hedge positions on the dip.

In its newly released 2027 outlook report, the Goldman Sachs commodities team noted that the geopolitical risk premium embedded in Brent crude has collapsed from US$27 per barrel on the eve of the midterm elections to just a few dollars. Team head Daan Struyven argued that the main driver of November's decline in energy and copper prices was a shift in market sentiment and short-term escalation risk in the Middle East, rather than a deterioration in physical supply-demand fundamentals. Goldman Sachs therefore concluded that the contraction of the risk premium actually enhances the value of commodities as a portfolio hedge, making the current moment a more attractive entry point.

Premium wiped out, but fundamentals barely changed

This round of selling in Brent crude occurred after the midterm elections and coincided with news of Qatari diplomatic mediation, producing the largest weekly drop since 2020. Goldman Sachs calculates that the premium compressed from US$27 to just a few dollars, mainly reflecting a correction in sentiment and short-term escalation expectations rather than any substantive improvement on the supply side.

In fact, the recovery in physical markets has been far from uniform. Goldman Sachs pointed out that Persian Gulf crude exports (including the "dark barrels" the bank has tracked since September) had already recovered to near-2025 levels by September, and the global crude market may have returned to oversupply in October. Goldman Sachs expects Middle East oil production in 2027 to average 1.1 million barrels per day higher than in 2025.

However, the "adaptability" seen in crude oil has not been replicated in other categories. Refined products and liquefied natural gas (LNG) cannot be flexibly rerouted via ship-to-ship transfers at sea the way crude can, and damaged refineries, aluminum smelters and liquefaction units have yet to be fully repaired. Goldman Sachs data shows that exports of refined products, LNG, aluminum feedstock and fertilizer from the Persian Gulf remain far below pre-war levels.

On freight, Goldman Sachs estimates that rerouting arrangements in the tanker market accounted for about three-quarters of the roughly US$20 per barrel year-on-year increase in average global crude freight costs, with most of that cost ultimately passed through to end-user oil prices.

Three reasons supporting the current hedge logic

At the tactical level, Goldman Sachs laid out three reasons for holding long commodity positions as a portfolio hedge.

First, there is upside tail risk in energy prices. Although diplomatic headlines have turned more conciliatory, Goldman Sachs still noted that tanker attacks near the Strait of Hormuz have increased recently and expects this risk to rise further over the coming quarters.

Its scenario analysis shows that if tensions escalate again to the point of a 3.5 million barrel per day supply gap in the Gulf region, average Brent crude prices could reach US$130 per barrel in 2027. The asymmetry in European natural gas is particularly striking: Goldman Sachs forecasts 2027 TTF average prices at 45 euros per megawatt-hour, 34% below the forward curve, but the Q1 scenario range could reach as high as 147 euros, and Goldman Sachs currently assigns a 30% probability to a low-supply winter scenario.

Second, equities and bonds have become deeply tied to oil price moves. Since the outbreak of the Iran war, the six-month rolling correlation between Brent crude and 10-year U.S. Treasury yields has risen to about 0.5, while its correlation with the S&P 500 index has fallen to about -0.45.

Goldman Sachs warned that if a supply shock repeats, stocks and bonds could fall in tandem, which is precisely the moment when a third leg is needed. Citing data from the past six decades, Goldman Sachs noted that in all 12-month periods when both stocks and bonds posted negative real returns, gold or commodities delivered positive real returns.

Third, agricultural products face upside risk. Goldman Sachs data shows that the BCOM agriculture sub-index has risen 10% year-to-date, and it still faces multiple upward pressures from Hormuz-related fertilizer trade (about one-third of global fertilizer exports), Black Sea grain (15%-20% of global grain trade), biofuel substitution, and a record-strong El Nino phenomenon.

Two hedge trades Goldman Sachs favors

On specific strategy, Goldman Sachs avoids a direct long crude position and instead recommends two "asymmetric" energy trades.

Long RBOB gasoline (first half of 2027): refining capacity has been damaged and refinery losses have not been fully repaired, while elevated freight costs continue to pass through to downstream markets, making gasoline supply more fragile than crude itself.

Long European natural gas front-month contracts (TTF Winter 2027): European inventories are low, and if a cold snap coincides with disruptions to LNG supply, the upside for prices is enormous. Goldman Sachs emphasized that the recent sharp digestion of the premium has significantly lowered the current cost of entry.

In addition, Goldman Sachs is medium-to-long-term bearish on TTF Summer 2029, reasoning that the wave of LNG final investment decisions (FIDs) in 2025-26 will bring substantial capacity online after 2027, shifting the market from tight to loose.

Bullish copper, bearish aluminum, gold target cut again

In the metals sector, Goldman Sachs expects the LME copper price to reach US$15,600 per tonne by December 2027, about 13% above current spot levels. The main drivers include persistent U.S. tariff uncertainty pushing metal into American inventories, and tightening Chinese scrap copper invoicing regulation forcing processors to switch to refined cathode copper, driving inventories outside the United States to seasonal lows.

Aluminum points in the opposite direction. Goldman Sachs believes that ample bauxite supply combined with the accelerated expansion of Chinese-backed smelting capacity in Indonesia (expected to account for about 4% of global output by the end of 2027, up from 1% at the end of 2025) will push the market into surplus, with an aluminum price target of US$2,600 per tonne. Goldman Sachs therefore recommends a paired trade of long December copper and short December aluminum, noting that this strategy is less sensitive to an AI cycle turn and further Federal Reserve rate hikes than a outright long position.

On gold, Goldman Sachs cut its target price once again. After lowering its December 2027 target from US$5,400 to US$4,800 last week, Goldman Sachs this week further "slightly reduced" the target to US$4,650 per ounce, because its economists now expect the Federal Reserve to raise rates by another 25 basis points in March 2027 on top of a December hike. Even so, US$4,650 still implies about 16% upside from current spot levels, with sustained central bank gold buying above pre-2022 levels seen as the fundamental support for prices.

Disagreement remains

Not all institutions agree with this logic. According to Reuters, Morgan Stanley pointed out that Dated Brent has fallen below near-month futures contracts, indicating a soft physical market, while JPMorgan estimated that the global crude market was oversupplied by about 1.4 million barrels per day in October. If those judgments prove correct, the little remaining risk premium in Brent will no longer be the main factor weighing on oil prices, and the weakness of the physical market itself will be the core contradiction.

Goldman Sachs' response is that oversupply is already an inherent assumption of its base case, which is precisely the logic behind its forecast of an US$88 average Brent price and near-zero BCOM index returns. The value of hedging lies in tail risk, not in the level of the base case. In Goldman Sachs' view, when insurance becomes cheap, that is often exactly when it ultimately pays off.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment