US equities are entering the strongest seasonal window of the year, but Goldman Sachs warns that historical patterns show this rally is far from smooth — the real gains are mostly concentrated after December 15, which is when the actual "Santa Rally" takes center stage.
According to the latest report from Goldman Sachs' Gail Hafif team titled "GS Flow of Funds: Chopsgiving," the market has now entered the traditionally strong November-to-December period, but institutional investors continue to reduce technology holdings while systematic strategies are selling heavily, leaving retail investors as the main source of support.
The report notes that the S&P 500's historical median maximum drawdown during this window is 3%, with most of the gains concentrated between December 15 and year-end, averaging about +1.22%.
The Goldman Sachs team characterizes this rally as a "choppy climb" and named the report "Chopsgiving" (a play on choppy and Thanksgiving), hinting that in an environment where holiday cheer coexists with market volatility, year-end returns will not be easily realized.
Against the backdrop of Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang's departure from the company and high expectations for a Federal Reserve rate hike in December, market digestion pressure is significant, and the sustainability of current buying faces a test.
Seasonal Patterns: A Dip First, Then a Rise, With the Weight in the Second Half of December
Goldman Sachs reviewed historical data going back to 1928, examining the average trajectory of the S&P 500 between November 16 and December 31.
The results show that the market sees a brief rally around Thanksgiving, then stalls in early December, comes under pressure again in mid-December, and only enters its main upward wave toward month-end.
Specifically, the S&P rises about 1.1% from the starting point in early December, then gives back about two-thirds of those gains in mid-December, ultimately finishing the year with cumulative gains of about 2.4%. By this calculation, roughly 80% of the average gains are concentrated after December 14.
Since 1985, the Nasdaq 100 has shown even more dramatic moves: a pullback of about 1% before Thanksgiving, a rebound of about 4.5 percentage points in early December, another decline of about 1.5 percentage points in mid-December, and a final year-end return of about 4.3%.
Hafif further conducted conditional screening based on starting VIX levels: among the 17 years since 1990 when the VIX was at 18 or above in mid-November, the VIX declined by year-end in 14 of those years, with an average drop of 3.25 points; however, the S&P 500's average gain over the same period was only about 1.34%, with fewer than 60% of those years recording positive returns and a median maximum drawdown of 3.0%.
Goldman Sachs concludes that when the market enters year-end carrying "fear," volatility tends to converge, index gains are therefore quite limited, and a round of adjustment is usually needed first.
Retail Investors Alone Support Buying, Institutions Keep Shorting the Rally
The current buying structure is heavily dependent on retail investors.
According to Goldman Sachs data, retail investors net bought $6.2 billion in US equities last week, the highest single-week figure in the 11 weeks since September 1, compared with net buying of just $120 million the prior week. Retail trading as a share of notional volume rose to 9.01%, briefly reaching a peak of 10.0% on November 12 (the day after Jensen Huang's departure).
Fund purchases were highly concentrated in semiconductors and large-cap technology stocks, with Nvidia receiving $1.75 billion in net buying, AMD seeing $672 million in net buying, and Micron and Tesla also recording inflows of $526 million and $523 million respectively, ranking among the top in the market; by contrast, the highest net selling for any single stock did not exceed $49 million.
Meanwhile, US-listed equity ETFs attracted $59.3 billion last week, a scale that exceeded the inflow levels of 91% of the 46 weeks that have passed this year.
However, institutions hold the opposite view. In Goldman Sachs' prime brokerage book, the information technology sector has been the largest global net-sold sector for multiple consecutive weeks, with the US technology long-short ratio falling to 1.5, the lowest level since records began in 2016, compared with a peak of 2.14 in early June. Goldman Sachs says the "conviction in the market's most core trade has begun to waver."
Institutional fund operations show a clear divergent strategy: on one hand, they have substantially closed out short positions in US equity ETFs, with short positions decreasing by 8.6%, the largest short covering in seven months, indicating that institutions are no longer bearish on the overall market direction; on the other hand, they continue to increase short positions in individual stocks, driving significant net selling in single names.
As Goldman Sachs points out, this "buy back the index, short individual stocks" strategy essentially hedges against overall market upside risk while precisely targeting and shorting "loser" stocks with deteriorating fundamentals, reflecting institutions' anticipation of internal market divergence.
Systematic Funds Significantly Reduce Positions, Shifting Toward Instability
Over the past week, CTA strategies (trend-following funds) net sold more than $22 billion in S&P futures alone, plus nearly $2.5 billion in Nasdaq futures, bringing overall US equity positioning down to a net short of about $10 billion, the lowest level since April. Volatility-control strategies and risk-parity strategies combined sold another approximately $30 billion.
Goldman Sachs notes that as volatility retreats from elevated levels, CTAs have turned into net buyers in a "flat scenario" and "for the first time in weeks are showing an asymmetric upward bias." Goldman Sachs forecasts that over the coming week, CTAs will net buy approximately $22.97 billion in a flat scenario, net buy $30.78 billion in an up scenario, and net sell only $6.07 billion in a down scenario.
However, this asymmetry rapidly reverses over a one-month horizon: if the market declines, CTAs' potential selling over one month could reach as much as $122.97 billion, far exceeding the $89.1 billion in net buying under the up scenario. Goldman Sachs admits:
In the current environment, all of this could reverse quickly.
Additionally, corporate buybacks constitute another stabilizing source of buying: buyback desk volume was 1.3 times the average daily volume for the same period in 2024 and 2025, with about 94% of S&P constituents in an open buyback window, but that window is expected to close around December 13, a timing that closely coincides with the second seasonal low.
Goldman Sachs Conclusion: The Rally Is Coming, but Choppiness Lies Ahead
Based on the above analysis, Goldman Sachs' baseline judgment is that "stocks will grind modestly higher from current levels, but the path will not be smooth." The report explicitly states that the next two weeks still face turbulence, but systematic fund flows are biased upward for the first time in weeks, with retail investors and corporate buybacks maintaining buying support.
The report also flags multiple risks: the first earnings report from Nvidia's new acting CEO Colette Kress constitutes the largest near-term uncertainty, with retail investors already showing a wait-and-see attitude ahead of the event; the Federal Reserve's December meeting carries high expectations already priced in, and year-end liquidity tends to tighten, both of which weigh on the market.
Goldman Sachs describes current market sentiment with a "GS Fear Index" of 6.3/10, believing that volatility "has not yet lifted its alarm." With institutional net leverage at the 4th percentile historically and CTAs net short, Goldman Sachs believes the market will struggle to sustain further declines before moving higher. But the true Santa Rally may only make its entrance after December 15.
Comments