Largest Drop in Six Months! Overseas U.S. Debt Holdings Plunge in September as Japan, China, and the U.K. All Trim Positions Together; China's Holdings Hit a Fresh Low Since 2008

Deep News07:22

Overseas investors' holdings of U.S. Treasury securities saw their biggest single-month decline since March of this year in September, with Japan, mainland China, and the United Kingdom—the three largest overseas creditors—rarely reducing their holdings in unison. Among them, mainland China posted the largest reduction, pushing its holdings further down to an eighteen-year low.

On Wednesday, November 18, U.S. Eastern Time, the Treasury Department released its International Capital Flow Report (TIC), showing that the total size of U.S. Treasuries held by overseas investors fell by $75.5 billion month-over-month in September to $9.2412 trillion, marking the largest single-month decline since March. Net long-term capital inflows into the United States totaled $155.3 billion in September, shrinking by more than 45% from August.

Within the September changes in overseas U.S. debt holdings, reductions by major holder countries became the market's focal point. Among them, top creditor Japan's holdings hit a 21-month low in September, the United Kingdom's holdings fell from a record high, and mainland China's decline ranked second only to France among the ten largest creditors.

However, a decline in holdings balances does not mean overseas investors are comprehensively selling off U.S. Treasuries. Based on transaction flow statistics, overseas investors still net purchased $80.8 billion in U.S. Treasuries in September, down nearly 26% from the upwardly revised $108.6 billion in August. This means overseas demand for U.S. debt still has support, but the market value of holdings was affected by other factors, resulting in a larger decline.

Japan's Holdings Fall for Five Consecutive Months, FX Intervention Impact Still in Focus

U.S. Treasury Department data shows that Japan's holdings of U.S. Treasuries fell by $5.2 billion month-over-month in September to $1.0631 trillion, still firmly holding the position of the largest overseas creditor of the United States.

Japan's U.S. debt holdings have now declined for five consecutive months. Previously, holdings hit new lows since January 2025 in June and July, and then set new lows since December 2024 for two consecutive months in August and September.

Japan's continued reduction of U.S. debt coincides with multiple interventions by the Japanese government in the foreign exchange market this year to support the yen, leading the market to continuously watch whether FX intervention affects Japan's dollar asset allocation.

Data released by Japan's Ministry of Finance on May 29 showed that total foreign exchange market intervention by Japan during the period from April 28 to May 27 reached 11.73 trillion yen. Analysts believe that Japan's purchases of yen and sales of dollars may have involved a certain scale of U.S. Treasury sales.

Subsequently, Japan and the United States also rarely intervened in the foreign exchange market jointly. Japan's Ministry of Finance confirmed on August 3 that the Japanese government and the U.S. Treasury Department coordinated on July 31 to implement yen-buying intervention to curb recent violent fluctuations in the yen exchange rate. This was the first coordinated FX intervention between Japan and the United States since the Great East Japan Earthquake in 2011, and an extremely rare joint action outside special periods such as financial crises.

Data subsequently released by Japan's Ministry of Finance showed that during the period from July 30 to August 26, the Japanese government invested approximately 15.4 trillion yen in total to intervene in the foreign exchange market, setting a new high for monthly intervention.

Intervening in the FX market typically requires selling foreign exchange and buying yen. Since Japan's foreign exchange reserves hold a large amount of U.S. Treasuries, the market is watching whether Japan will sell U.S. debt and other dollar assets to fund its intervention operations.

However, TIC holdings data cannot directly prove how much U.S. debt Japan sold for FX intervention. Changes in holdings balances are also affected by factors such as bond valuation changes, and the $5.2 billion decline in Japan's September holdings cannot be entirely attributed to FX intervention.

China Reduces Holdings by $26.8 Billion, Down More Than $130 Billion Over the Past Year

Mainland China's holdings of U.S. Treasuries fell by $26.8 billion month-over-month in September to $563.9 billion, continuing to rank as the third-largest overseas creditor of the United States.

Mainland China's U.S. debt holdings have now declined for four consecutive months, with month-over-month declines in 10 of the past 12 months. September marked the third consecutive month that holdings hit an eighteen-year low not seen since August 2008.

Over the past year, mainland China's U.S. debt holdings have cumulatively decreased by $135.3 billion, indicating that official holdings continue to show a clear contraction trend.

From a longer cycle perspective, the scale of U.S. Treasuries held by mainland China has declined significantly compared with the past. Around 2016, mainland China's holdings once exceeded $1 trillion, and now they have fallen to about $560 billion.

It is worth noting that the market has previously seen discussion about China potentially holding some U.S. bonds through third-location custodial institutions. In October, there were reports that some Wall Street investors and analysts suspected China might hold some U.S. bonds through financial institutions in places such as Canada.

However, this speculation still lacks conclusive evidence. The U.S. Treasury Department also explicitly reminds that TIC data is mainly compiled based on reports from custodians and dealers. If foreign investors hold U.S. securities through third-country custodial accounts, the related assets may be recorded under the name of the custodial location rather than the country of the ultimate owner.

Therefore, the continued decline in mainland China's official holdings is a fact that TIC data can confirm, but public data alone cannot be used to assert that the entire scale of U.S. bonds actually held by China has declined in tandem.

U.K. Holdings Turn to Reduction After Two Consecutive Record Months, France Posts Largest Decline

The United Kingdom, the second-largest overseas creditor of the United States, also joined the reduction camp in September.

Data shows that the U.K.'s holdings of U.S. Treasuries fell by $8.7 billion month-over-month to $985.8 billion, retreating after increasing for two consecutive months and repeatedly setting all-time record highs.

Last month's TIC report showed that in August, the U.K.'s U.S. debt holdings exceeded $1 trillion for the first time in history. In the September report, the U.K.'s August holdings were revised down to about $994.5 billion. After the September reduction, the U.K. still firmly remained the second-largest overseas creditor of the United States.

Among the ten largest overseas holders of U.S. Treasuries, only Belgium, the Cayman Islands, and Canada increased their holdings in September.

Among them, the Cayman Islands posted the largest increase, adding $23.8 billion month-over-month to $486.8 billion, ranking sixth; Belgium added $17.4 billion to $507.9 billion, ranking fifth; and Canada added $3.1 billion to $467.7 billion, ranking seventh.

The remaining major holders generally reduced their holdings. France's holdings fell by $31.4 billion in September to $332 billion, the largest decline among the ten largest overseas holding regions, ranking ninth overall; mainland China's decline ranked second.

Overall, among the ten largest overseas holders of U.S. Treasuries in September, seven reduced their holdings, while only Belgium, the Cayman Islands, and Canada increased them. The synchronized reduction by the three largest overseas creditors became the most noteworthy change in that month's holdings data.

Long-Term Capital Inflows Slow Sharply; Why Did the Decline in U.S. Debt Holdings Exceed Net Sales?

From the perspective of overall capital flows, net long-term capital inflows into the United States slowed markedly in September, but overall net international capital inflows into the United States actually increased.

TIC data shows that net long-term capital inflows into the United States were $155.3 billion in September, lower than the upwardly revised $285 billion in August, a decline of more than 45%. The previous TIC report had reported net inflows of $279.2 billion in August.

However, overall net international capital inflows into the United States reached $261 billion in September, higher than the revised $203 billion in August. Among them, net inflows of foreign private capital were $267 billion, while foreign official capital saw net outflows of $6 billion.

Specifically, overseas investors net purchased $186.7 billion in long-term U.S. securities in September, of which private investors net purchased $148.3 billion and foreign official institutions net purchased $38.4 billion. After deducting funds used by U.S. residents to purchase foreign long-term securities and incorporating adjustments such as stock swaps, net long-term capital inflows were $155.3 billion.

In terms of U.S. Treasuries, overseas investors net purchased $80.8 billion in U.S. Treasuries in September, lower than $108.6 billion in August. At the same time, the total size of U.S. Treasuries held by overseas investors fell by $75.5 billion month-over-month to $9.2412 trillion.

The two sets of data are not contradictory: the former reflects actual transaction flows, while the latter reflects end-of-period holdings balances, which are also affected by valuation factors such as changes in bond prices. In other words, even if overseas investors still net purchased U.S. Treasuries during the month, if the prices of previously held bonds fell, the final market value of holdings could still shrink.

The largest single-month decline in overseas U.S. debt holdings since March in September reflects that allocation changes among major overseas holders deserve attention. Combined with the marked slowdown in net long-term capital inflows, the support from overseas funds for the U.S. bond market is being examined more closely.

For the U.S. Treasury market, what is worth watching going forward, on the one hand, is whether overseas investors' net purchases can continue; on the other hand, it is whether Japan's FX intervention continues to affect its dollar asset allocation, and whether the decline in mainland China's official holdings continues. Overseas investors are still buying U.S. Treasuries, but continued reductions by major holder countries and a sharp overall decline in holdings mean that the situation of the United States attracting global capital is far more complex than what a single net inflow figure suggests.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment