The recent collective decline in wireless carrier stock prices is a clear indicator that competition in the telecom services market is intensifying, according to Brendan Carr, Chairman of the US Federal Communications Commission (FCC), who also cited the policies of the previous administration as a significant contributing factor.
In a recent interview, Carr pointed to several developments fueling the competitive landscape: large-scale spectrum auctions, competition from satellite companies, and the gradual exit of EchoStar Corp. (ECHO.US) from the wireless network business. "Mobile carrier stocks are taking a real hit," Carr stated. "There was a prediction years ago that the market needed to maintain four major carriers of the same type, or else companies would become complacent and stock prices would soar. The reality we see today completely contradicts that prediction."
Appointed as FCC Chairman during the previous administration, Carr last year strongly encouraged EchoStar to sell a significant portion of its spectrum assets to SpaceX (SPCX.US) and AT&T Inc. (T.US). He had previously expressed the view that EchoStar's progress in building a fourth nationwide wireless network was too slow. "Given the various competitive pressures already in the market, we did not subscribe to the argument that a fourth nationwide carrier needed to be artificially created," Carr said. "And the facts are bearing out our view: network speeds continue to increase, and service prices continue to fall."
In 2020, the merger of T-Mobile US Inc. (TMUS.US) and Sprint Corp. was approved with conditions, one of which required EchoStar to acquire the Boost Mobile brand and commit to building its own independent 5G wireless network. Last year, Carr initiated an investigation into EchoStar's project progress, which was terminated after the spectrum sale plan was announced. The FCC formally approved the related license transfers this May.
Carr expressed satisfaction with the current competitive dynamics in the wireless service sector, particularly highlighting the injection of new vitality from emerging satellite operators like SpaceX and Amazon.com Inc. (AMZN.US). Recently, stocks of AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon Communications Inc. (VZ.US) have faced sustained pressure. This followed SpaceX's successful initial public offering, which raised market concerns about its potential to launch wireless services directly competing with the major carriers.
A report from June 26 indicated that SpaceX is in discussions with internet service provider Charter Communications Inc. (CHTR.US) regarding launching a wireless phone service. Carr expressed optimism about how SpaceX might use its newly acquired spectrum to enhance its Starlink direct-to-cell service, an emerging area that promises communication in areas without terrestrial network coverage. SpaceX is already collaborating with T-Mobile to provide such coverage services.
Carr also stated his willingness to consider transactions that would allow SpaceX to offer wireless services more directly to consumers. He noted that while there haven't been "substantive discussions" on this matter with SpaceX yet, he is "open to any potential transaction."
Additionally, the FCC is still reviewing Amazon's plan to acquire satellite operator Globalstar Inc. (GSAT.US), which is working to bring its low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellite network into operation. "Clearly, they still need to continue launching satellites and building out the network, but FCC approval of this acquisition and granting it the corresponding spectrum usage rights would be a key breakthrough," Carr said.
Carr noted that under his leadership, the FCC has generally been transaction-friendly, and activity in the connectivity sector is experiencing a boom. Since his appointment as Chairman, the FCC has processed transactions with a total estimated value between $140 billion and $160 billion. "We've seen major deals in cable with Charter, in spectrum with AT&T, and in media with the CBS merger," Carr stated. "Currently, we maintain an open and receptive attitude towards all types of transactions."
At the same time, Carr emphasized that efforts to promote continued growth in the wireless industry through policy will not stop. On July 22, the FCC will vote on two proposals: one to auction more high-value wireless spectrum to commercial operators, and another to streamline the licensing process for satellite communications to further unleash industry vitality.
Comments