Dull Is Beautiful? BTIG Warns Defensive Sector Strength Echoes Dot-Com Bust Prelude

Deep News11-16

Toothpaste, crackers, cigarettes and bourbon are outperforming the artificial intelligence trade.

Over the past 30 days, the S&P 500 consumer staples sector has outperformed the technology sector by 33 percentage points, the widest single-month gap in roughly 25 years. Jonathan Krinsky, chief technical strategist at BTIG, noted that the last time a similar move occurred was from April 2000 to October 2001 — the opening act of the internet bubble's collapse. Meanwhile, the technology ETF QQQ has fallen below its densest volume zone of the past two years, meaning any rebound could run into heavy selling pressure from trapped positions.

In his latest weekly note titled "Dull Is Beautiful," Krinsky made clear he is turning "bullish" on consumer staples. The consumer staples ETF (XLP) has broken out of a multi-month consolidation range, with both its absolute price and its ratio against the S&P 500 breaking out in tandem. He characterized this combination of "negative sentiment plus strong price action" as a "powerful long signal." At the same time, the U.S. dollar index is breaking above the top of a two-year range, which Krinsky called "one of the most bullish charts in the market right now," while a strong dollar has historically been unfavorable for risk assets.

This unusual strength in defensive sectors is fueling deeper doubts about the durability of the AI trade. If the historical path of 2000 repeats, the technology correction may only just be beginning, and the "boring stocks" shunned by the market could be in the early stages of a lasting rotation.

Consumer Staples Beat Tech by 33%, First Time in 25 Years

The data is striking.

According to Krinsky's calculations, over the past 30 days the consumer staples sector has outperformed the technology sector by 33 percentage points, the largest single-month gap in nearly 25 years. Two weeks ago, consumer staples had just posted their strongest monthly performance since October 2000.

At the time, market consensus, including at Bank of America, held that defensive sectors had rallied into bubble-like territory reminiscent of 1999, with even "safe assets" looking overheated. But Krinsky's view shifted. His core logic: if a stock deemed "expensive" and lacking growth keeps rising, the market itself is sending a signal.

"Investors tend to want to buy cheap and sell expensive… the consensus on consumer staples is that they are 'expensive' with limited growth. That may be true, but the same was said a month ago, and they have risen 10% since. Sometimes the market is wrong, but sometimes it is telling a story worth listening to," Krinsky wrote in his report.

XLP has broken out of a multi-month consolidation range, with the XLP/SPX ratio breaking out in tandem. Krinsky characterized this "negative sentiment plus strong price action" combination as a "powerful long signal," noting the sector is not yet notably overbought and still has room to run.

The 2000 Mirror: Tech Collapsed, Defensives Soared

Krinsky has repeatedly flagged "echoes of the internet bubble" before, and this time he once again invoked that history as a reference point.

The Nasdaq peaked on March 10, 2000, but the bear market did not immediately sweep the entire market. According to BTIG data, from March 10, 2000 to March 10, 2001, consumer staples rose 50.3%, utilities rose 44.0%, and financials rose 36.4%; meanwhile, technology plunged 56.9%, while the S&P 500 "only" fell 11.6%. In other words, the index decline was modest, but the average investor's holdings were nearly halved.

Compare that with today: since around the peak of the AI trade on June 22, healthcare has risen 25.0%, energy has gained 19.7%, consumer staples have added 12.6%, while technology has fallen 7.3% — yet the S&P 500 is up 0.6%. The pattern of sector divergence closely mirrors 2000.

Krinsky also pointed to differences: in 2000, many sectors had already fallen 20% to 30% before peaking on March 10, whereas today's market is less extreme. Still, he stressed that "the leadership of defensive sectors is hard to ignore." Overlaying the relative strength ratio chart of consumer staples versus technology, the 2000 and current trajectories look almost identical.

What is more unsettling for AI bulls: after that initial rotation in 2000, consumer staples went on to outperform technology by nearly 1,000 basis points over the following two years. The first rotation was violent; what followed was a long grind.

Tech Stocks: Trapped Positions Overhead, Semiconductors Could Fall Another 17% to 25%

The technical pressures facing technology stocks are equally grim. Krinsky's QQQ volume profile shows that prices have fallen below the densest volume zone of the past two years, meaning any rebound will face heavy selling from trapped positions — a judgment confirmed by last Thursday's bounce.

The semiconductor sector is in an even tougher spot. SOXX is being capped below its supply zone, and Krinsky maintains his prior view that the sector needs to retrace to its April breakout point, implying "roughly 17% to 25% downside from current levels."

Meanwhile, Apple (AAPL), viewed as a "safe-haven alternative" within technology, has also flashed a warning signal. The stock is up 31% year to date, but after touching 52-week highs last Thursday and Friday, it closed each day down more than 1%; the same pattern appeared on November 4 and 5.

Krinsky looked back over 20 years of data and found only nine similar cases — two consecutive days touching a 52-week high with each day closing down more than 1%. The results showed that over the following 20 trading sessions, returns were negative 89% of the time, with an average decline of 12.57% and a median decline of 8.97%. The sample is small, but the signal points consistently in one direction. "Apple has been the market's safe harbor, but after a 31% year-to-date gain and recent signs of exhaustion, we think it is quite vulnerable to a downside reversion in coming weeks."

Dollar Breaks Two-Year Range, Tightening Liquidity Pressures the AI Trade

What ties this sector rotation together is a macro variable: the dollar.

The Bloomberg dollar index is breaking above the top of a two-year range. Krinsky called it "one of the most bullish charts in the market right now, and potentially unfavorable for a risk-on environment." GBP/USD, AUD/USD, CAD/USD and NZD/USD have all pulled back from multi-month highs, with the New Zealand dollar already breaking support first.

Bank of America strategist Michael Hartnett expressed similar concerns this week, saying that if the dollar "keeps surging like this, it will become a destructive force." According to reports, Goldman Sachs' FX team expects another leg higher in the dollar before a turn in 2027.

A strong dollar means tighter global liquidity, and tighter liquidity has historically been most damaging to the market's most crowded, most leveraged trades — which, at this point, is the AI trade.

Notably, consumer staples, a classic bond proxy, has still broken out strongly even as the 10-year Treasury yield closed at 5.15% and the market prices three more Fed rate hikes. Krinsky believes this shows that flows into consumer staples are driven more by a search for a safe haven from unwinding AI trades, with dividend yield a secondary consideration.

Rotation or Trap? The Debate Continues

Not everyone agrees. In his latest "Flow Show" report, Bank of America's Hartnett listed "large-cap consumer stocks" among the assets most vulnerable if dollar and liquidity pressures intensify, while naming consumer discretionary as the asset most likely to beat expectations over the next eight weeks — the exact opposite of the ratio direction Krinsky is watching closely. One of them must be wrong.

Krinsky himself remains cautious. He expects correlations between sectors to rise during a broad market decline, and says consumer staples "will not be completely immune to a sell-off." On the equal-weighted ratio of consumer staples to consumer discretionary (RSPS/RSPD), he also said "it is too early to call this a new uptrend," but that a break above 0.58 "would be significant" — it closed at 0.569 on Friday, about 2% from the breakout point.

At the heart of this debate is a classic market question: is the strength in defensive sectors the start of a lasting rotation, or a crowded defensive trade about to be flattened by correlation? If 2000 is the reference, the technology bear market may prove far longer than bulls expect; and even if consumer staples fall 5%, if semiconductors drop another 20%, the former would still outperform the latter by 15 to 20 percentage points. As market watchers put it: when investors cannot make sense of the tech bubble, they go buy "soap bubbles."

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment