According to Woofun AI, Bitmine Immersion Technologies INC (BMNR.US), led by Tom Lee, is facing a severe dual crisis of finances and credibility, with unrealized losses on its ETH holdings approaching the $10 billion mark.
This massive loss not only reflects Ethereum's weak performance during a prolonged bear market, but has also pushed the one-time Wall Street "hype king" into the center of public scrutiny, as the widening gulf between his bullish logic and market reality becomes impossible to ignore.
Over the past year and more, ETH's price has trended downward from its all-time high in volatile trading. As the world's largest ETH treasury company, Bitmine's shrinking holdings value has directly eroded Tom Lee's influence among institutional investors, with market confidence in his subsequent actions and views falling to a freezing point.
The core data behind the crisis
Bitmine's current holdings lay bare the core data of this crisis. As of November 8, the company held 6,070,092 ETH at an average cost of about $3,353. As ETH repeatedly fell below the $2,000 mark and even dropped to around $1,600 in June, Bitmine's paper losses at one point reached nearly $10 billion.
Despite such enormous paper losses, Tom Lee and his team at Fundstrat have maintained a firmly bullish stance. In late October this year, he publicly stated that ETH could reach a high of about $62,000 in the next cycle. Looking back at his bullish track record, his tone had not changed as early as August 2025, when ETH peaked and rolled over; at Binance Blockchain Week in early December 2025, he still insisted that ETH at $3,000 was severely undervalued and predicted that BTC and ETH would hit new highs in January 2026.
This attitude of staying bullish no matter how the market moves has gradually been interpreted by the market as inflexible "mindless bullishness," and his credibility has come under serious question.
The flashpoint of the trust crisis
The flashpoint of the trust crisis stemmed from the stark contrast between an internal report and public remarks. On December 20, 2025, Sean Farrell, head of digital asset strategy at Fundstrat, in a 2026 outlook for paying subscribers, took a clear pullback in the first half of the year as the base case, giving an ETH target range of only $1,800 to $2,000, while the BTC target range was $60,000 to $65,000.
This internal bearishness stood in sharp contrast to Tom Lee's front-stage bullishness, sparking speculation about the team's true intentions. Sean Farrell later clarified that the report emphasized risk management rather than bearishness; Tom Lee explained that the two stemmed from different methodologies and time horizons.
However, subsequent market action largely confirmed the judgment of that internal report: in January 2026, neither BTC nor ETH hit new highs, ETH later fell below $2,000 multiple times, and in June it even dropped below $1,600.
Since September 2025, he had repeatedly suggested ETH could reach about $62,000. His calculation logic was that if Ethereum replaces payment and banking infrastructure, the ETH/BTC ratio could rise to about 0.25; with BTC at $250,000, ETH would be about $62,000. He added that Ethereum had risen 50 to 200 times in previous cycles, and even a conservative 25-fold estimate would reach that price level.
Facing ETH's decline, in his November 16 Bitmine weekly report he described ETH's 28% drop over two weeks as a waterfall decline inconsistent with fundamentals, attributing it to external factors such as Nvidia dynamics and investors raising cash for Anthropic's listing, whereas a year earlier he had blamed damaged market-maker balance sheets.
Bitmine's own business model dilemma
Bitmine's own business model dilemma has further weakened Tom Lee's influence. The share-issuance-to-buy-coins model that supported its expansion last year is now difficult to sustain. As ETH fell, the company's stock price stayed below the value of its holdings for a long time, and continued issuance would only dilute shareholder equity, so Bitmine turned to share buybacks.
According to Bitmine's disclosures, from 2026 through late October, the company had repurchased about 22.9 million shares for about $400 million. On ETH accumulation, Bitmine bought 9,587 and 7,653 ETH in the past two weeks respectively, with the latter worth about $14 million at current prices, a clear contraction in accumulation scale. The company has now completed 99% of its 5% holding target and said it will stop buying once the target is met, with no further ETH accumulation afterward.
More importantly, Bitmine's scarcity as a bridge between Wall Street and ETH is disappearing. In January this year, Grayscale completed the first spot ETH ETF staking yield distribution in the United States; in March, BlackRock (BLK.US) launched a staking ETH ETF, allowing institutions to gain ETH exposure and staking yields directly through ETFs.
Bitmine currently has essentially no debt, about 86% of its ETH is staked, and annualized staking income is about $245 million. In the short term there is no pressure forcing liquidation, but its influence on the market is no longer what it used to be.
Deep reasons for the valuation trap
Woofun AI's compiled data shows that the deterioration of ETH's fundamentals is the deep reason for the valuation trap, with tokenization prosperity coexisting with the failure of the deflationary logic. One of the cores of Tom Lee's bullish logic is the tokenization supercycle; he believes tokenization is making steady progress and that most of it is happening on Ethereum.
However, according to a Binance Research report, Ethereum network usage grew about 50% in the first half of 2026, but because gas fees continued to fall, full-year network revenue is expected to decline 53%. The chain is busier and busier, yet value is not returning to ETH. Since the switch to proof of stake, ETH has fallen more than 60% relative to BTC.
The burn logic that previously supported ETH's valuation has also failed. With L2 scaling advancing and mainnet fees falling sharply, burn volume is far behind new issuance. Based on the most recent 30 days, ETH's annualized burn is about 35,000 coins, annualized issuance is about 1.09 million coins, and annual supply growth is about 0.86%. Since the Merge, ETH supply has increased by a net 1.7 million coins, and deflation expectations have completely failed.
On November 8, Vitalik posted again emphasizing ETH's store-of-value positioning and proposed no longer treating fee burning as a core valuation logic, arguing that past burning mainly came from speculative demand within the crypto circle and that pursuing high burn volumes would conflict with the goals of decentralization and anti-capture.
Valuation disputes from multiple perspectives
Valuation disputes from multiple perspectives highlight institutional doubts and uncertainty over the technical roadmap. Tom Lee listed Vitalik's confirmation that ETH is a store of value as a bullish reason, but institutional investors see it very differently.
According to calculations by Arca chief investment officer Jeff Dorman, Ethereum's roughly $6 million in monthly revenue, plus ETH in wallets used to pay gas, can only explain $45 billion to $50 billion of its roughly $246 billion market value, with the rest coming more from social value and market imagination.
Crypto KOL Lanhu believes it is too early to talk about store of value. Ethereum should first collect a reasonable 10% to 20% fee from L2s and block builders to solve the value-capture problem at the mechanism level. Store of value can only form naturally and cannot be achieved by slogans.
Vitalik mentioned that Ethereum's roadmap is relatively mature and most major changes can be anticipated in advance, but he also listed a long string of protocol features expected to change, including the possibility that the consensus algorithm could be substantially adjusted in the next two years.
Crypto KOL Chen Mo said the impact of the technical roadmap on price takes a long time to appear, and what truly deserves attention is whether Ethereum can continue to win over developers; burn data is secondary. Ethereum may be very successful, but why ETH must be very expensive still lacks a convincing answer.
Turmoil inside the foundation
Turmoil inside the foundation has intensified market unease, with lawsuits, layoffs and suspected ETH selling occurring frequently. The foundation's mission document released in March this year listed censorship resistance and anti-capture as core principles. At the same time, the foundation is undergoing severe internal upheaval.
Two co-executive directors, Tomasz Stańczak and Hsiao-Wei Wang, left in February and June respectively, and board member Bastian Aue is currently in temporary charge. In June, the foundation announced 54 layoffs, about 20% of staff, and cut about 40% of its annual budget.
Recently, former foundation protocol support lead Kayleen Fulton sued in a U.S. federal court, saying she and Trent Van Epps led a public letter signed by 53 people opposing controversial provisions in the mission document, and that the two were subsequently fired in April; the foundation has not yet filed a response.
In addition, claims that the foundation is selling ETH have frequently appeared in the market, with multiple wallets tagged as foundation-related addresses successively selling ETH. Since October 26, foundation-related addresses have sold about 7,785 ETH in total.
On-chain analyst Specter cautioned that the ownership tags for some wallets lack sufficient evidence, and early funding connections with the foundation do not mean they are still controlled by the foundation. In terms of scale, these sales have limited direct impact on price. The foundation holds about 0.16% of total supply and has staked about 70,000 ETH this year, using yields to replace part of coin sales.
But in the eyes of retail investors, Vitalik positions ETH as a store of value while news of the foundation selling coins keeps coming, and this contrast is shaking market confidence.
It is worth noting that the publicly confirmed buyers of the foundation's sales were all Bitmine. According to foundation announcements, from March to May the foundation sold a total of 25,000 ETH to Bitmine through three over-the-counter transactions, at an average price between $2,043 and $2,387.
In June this year, five former senior foundation researchers founded the nonprofit research and development organization Ethlabs, with funders including Bitmine, SharpLink (SBET.US) and Ethereum co-founder Joe Lubin. In July, the same group of funders also supported the establishment of Ethereum Institutional, focused on institutional outreach and ETH marketing.
Bitmine and the foundation's coordination dilemma and future outlook
The coordination dilemma between Bitmine and the foundation and the future outlook have become a focus of market attention. At present, the relationship between the two remains mostly at the level of buying, selling and funding. After Vitalik revived the store-of-value narrative, for this story to be accepted by Wall Street it still needs to be translated into a valuation logic institutions can understand.
For ETH investors, there are few parties left to count on. The foundation has no intention of speaking up for the coin price, and spot ETF funds have recently seen continued outflows. Bitmine, which holds about 5% of ETH's circulating supply, is still considered the party with both the strongest incentive and the greatest ability to hold up the ETH narrative.
However, Bitmine's interests do not fully align with those of retail investors. Its revenue mainly comes from staking, its stock price depends on asset premiums, and after its holdings approached the 5% target, the scale of accumulation clearly shrank. Tom Lee's calls can no longer move the market easily. Rather than his next target price, whether Bitmine can form more direct coordination with the foundation and find a valuation anchor for ETH that Wall Street recognizes may be more worth watching.
This is a critical moment when the market once again faces a reconstruction of valuation logic since Ethereum's Merge. If a new consensus cannot be established, ETH's long-term store-of-value positioning will face sustained challenges.
Comments