Nvidia Hits 14-Year Valuation Low as Tom Lee Calls Bottom, Retail Buys the Dip, but Wall Street Splits

Deep News11-13

Nvidia shares have suffered a sharp selloff, with its forward price-to-earnings ratio dropping to about 12 times, the lowest level since 2012.

Yet the plunge to a historic valuation low has not produced a unified bullish stance on Wall Street.

With founder and CEO Jensen Huang departing, market confidence in the AI chip giant is clearly diverging.

On Thursday, NVIDIA (NVDA) shares plunged more than 14% in early trading before gradually recovering ground on emergency public relations efforts and bargain hunting, eventually closing down 4.34% at $166.19.

Compared with the interim high of $243.37 set on October 6, the stock has now fallen more than 30% in cumulative terms.

As the stock tumbled, retail investors rushed to buy the dip.

Data from Vanda Research showed that in the first half hour after Thursday's open, retail net buying of Nvidia reached $111 million, a record for that time window.

Well-known bulls including Tom Lee of Fundstrat Global Advisors and Paul Meeks of Freedom Capital Markets also publicly called for buying, arguing that the current valuation is already attractive.

On the other side, some Wall Street institutions are retreating.

Bernstein downgraded Nvidia from Buy to Market Perform and slashed its target price from $400 to $200; Goldman Sachs maintained its Buy rating but cut its target price from $300 to $220.

Prominent bear Michael Burry went further, warning that Nvidia bulls may want to use the next earnings window to exit as soon as possible.

The focus of this bull-bear battle is no longer merely whether demand for AI chips can continue, but whether Nvidia can maintain its technological leadership, organizational efficiency and the AI industry financing ecosystem it built after Huang's departure.

Record retail dip-buying as prominent bulls such as Tom Lee publicly call for purchases

On Thursday, NVIDIA (NVDA) shares initially fell to $148.80, down more than 14% from the previous close and below the 52-week low of $164.27.

The stock then gradually rebounded, ending down 4.34% at $166.19.

Although the decline narrowed, the stock is still about 32% below the record high of $243.37 set on October 6.

The sharp drop instead ignited retail dip-buying enthusiasm.

According to Vanda Research data, in the first half hour after Thursday's open, retail net buying of Nvidia reached $111 million, the highest ever for that time window.

Data from Fidelity Investments showed that as of noon Eastern Time on Thursday, clients had submitted a cumulative 394,818 buy orders for Nvidia, while sell orders totaled only 80,088.

The number of buy orders was even more than twice the combined buy orders for the stocks ranked second through tenth by trading volume on the platform that day.

Well-known investors also expressed bullish positions at this time.

Tom Lee of Fundstrat Global Advisors and Paul Meeks, head of technology research at Freedom Capital Markets, both publicly favored Nvidia.

Meeks argued that the current valuation is unreasonably low and said he would buy heavily.

Mark Hackett, chief market strategist at Nationwide Financial, believes repeated dip-buying by investors has become habitual, and each success further reinforces this behavior.

He also noted that the long-term outlook for AI remains good.

Valuation falls to 14-year low as orders stretch to 2028 provide support

The core logic supporting the current dip-buying view is that Nvidia's order visibility, product roadmap and profitability have not changed materially along with the share price decline.

Piper Sandler analyst David O'Connor maintained an Overweight rating and a $300 target price.

He noted that Nvidia's 2027 orders are already sold out, and 2028 is basically the same, with customer discussions now focused on 2029 and beyond.

Wolfe analyst Chris Caso similarly believes that at least through 2028, Nvidia's fundamentals and profitability will not be materially affected.

RBC estimates that current chip demand exceeds supply by about 50%; JPMorgan pointed out that the mass production ramp paths for follow-up products such as Vera Rubin, Rubin Ultra and Feynman are already clear.

The latest quarterly results also support this judgment: Nvidia revenue reached $96.2 billion, up 106% year over year; data center revenue rose 117% to $89 billion, and the company expects next-quarter revenue of about $108 billion.

What investors are paying even more attention to is valuation.

As the stock continued to pull back, Nvidia's forward price-to-earnings ratio has fallen to about 12 times, the lowest since 2012.

Based on different institutions' earnings forecast standards, its expected P/E for fiscal 2027 is about 10 times, and the P/E corresponding to 2028 consensus earnings is even only about 7 times.

Raymond James maintained a Strong Buy rating and a $515 target price, arguing that Nvidia's fundamentals have barely changed and the stock has entered oversold territory.

However, the market is not uniformly bullish on Nvidia.

According to TipRanks data, 10 of 27 analysts still maintain Hold ratings, with an overall rating of Moderate Buy and an average target price of about $257.

The average target price from 14 investment banks is about $260.

Wall Street begins repricing: downgrades and target price cuts appear one after another

In contrast to some investors actively buying the dip, more and more Wall Street institutions are beginning to factor the uncertainty brought by Huang's departure into Nvidia's valuation.

Bernstein analyst Stacy Rasgon sharply cut his target price from $400 to $200.

He believes Nvidia's problems may go beyond what has already been exposed, using the metaphor of finding two ants in the kitchen to suggest more issues may surface later.

Goldman Sachs analyst James Schneider maintained a Buy rating but also lowered his target price from $300 to $220.

Notably, Goldman did not cut its earnings-per-share forecast, but instead compressed the valuation multiple from 30 times to 22 times to reflect the uncertainty brought by the management transition period.

Prominent bear Michael Burry was even more pessimistic.

He acknowledged that mechanical buying from index funds and retirement accounts helped Nvidia absorb some selling pressure, but argued that the real impact of Huang's departure on the business may take longer to appear.

He warned that Nvidia bulls may get another better exit opportunity, saying bluntly: "Nvidia bulls will have another great opportunity to flee. Flee."

Burry also questioned the company's succession arrangements: about 60 executives report directly to Huang, yet there is hardly any obvious internal successor.

Institutions also disagree on where the stock price bottom may be.

Cantor, Piper, KeyBanc and Citi all view around $150 as a reasonable support range, equivalent to about 9 to 11 times expected 2027 earnings per share.

RBC's downside scenario is as low as $100, equivalent to about 6 times expected 2027 earnings per share, below Nvidia's valuation low over the past five years.

Huang leaves two major problems: management structure and financing ecosystem

Compared with short-term orders and earnings, the impact of Huang's departure on Nvidia's long-term competitiveness is harder to quantify, mainly reflected in organizational management and industrial financing.

The first is organizational structure.

Seaport analyst Jay Goldberg said bluntly: "Simply put, no one can fill Jensen Huang's leather jacket."

Wells Fargo also noted that about 60 executives report directly to Huang, and this flat structure is unsustainable and difficult to replicate, potentially affecting internal coordination efficiency and product launch pace.

JPMorgan believes the interim management team may be able to maintain the existing product roadmap in the short term, but two to three years later the real test will be whether the new leadership can identify the next technological inflection point in accelerated computing and continue building platforms and ecosystems beyond chips.

The second is the financing ecosystem.

Over the past few years, Huang used Nvidia's free cash flow of about $50 billion to $60 billion per quarter to provide funding support to companies such as OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI and CoreWeave through equity investments, asset backing and supplier prepayments.

UBS analyst Tim Arcuri believes this is one of the biggest potential impacts of Huang's departure.

Even if the new leadership decides to continue a similar strategy, there may be a pause period.

If as much as $50 billion per quarter no longer flows into the AI supply chain, the financing environment for related companies could deteriorate rapidly.

This risk comes just as interest rates rise and liquidity in credit markets tightens.

On the day the news was announced, CoreWeave shares fell more than 11% in premarket trading, while the company was marketing an investment-grade loan of more than $4 billion.

Seaport also pointed out that a financing platform plan previously announced by Huang involving six private equity funds and worth $500 billion has not yet been finalized in contract terms.

Without Huang's push, whether the plan can continue to advance is also in question.

Regulatory pressure plus intensifying competition test Nvidia's moat

Huang's departure has not eliminated the regulatory pressure facing Nvidia.

An independent board investigation led by Wachtell's Joon Kim is still underway, and the U.S. Department of Justice's Megaspeed investigation has not ended.

The House of Representatives has requested a closed-door briefing on November 18, while Senators Warren and Coons have asked Nvidia to submit relevant records.

Export controls are also a market focus.

Goldman Sachs estimates that Nvidia's sales exposure outside the United States is about 11%; UBS believes stricter export rules could affect shipments to places such as Singapore and Malaysia, putting about 10% of revenue at risk.

However, Wolfe believes market concerns about export controls may be exaggerated.

At the same time, competitors may benefit from the uncertainty facing Nvidia.

BNP Paribas, Seaport and William Blair all listed AMD and Broadcom as potential beneficiaries, arguing that hyperscale cloud providers and AI labs may more actively diversify chip supply sources.

BNP Paribas expects that by 2030 custom chips could account for nearly three-quarters of AI accelerator shipments.

William Blair also noted that the competitive barrier of the CUDA ecosystem largely comes from code migration costs, but AI programming assistants are lowering this threshold.

In its IPO roadshow materials, Anthropic disclosed that its Claude Mythos Preview model adapted prompt processing on AMD's MI355X chip in reportedly only about three days, whereas similar work previously usually took six to 12 months.

Counterpoint Research believes Huang previously brought the entire AI supply chain into an annual product iteration cycle.

As this unified rhythm may change, the AI hardware industry may enter an era of multiple speeds in parallel, and supply chain partners will also need to readjust product planning and investment pace.

Successor undecided as earnings become the next test

At present, there is still no clear answer to Nvidia's CEO succession question.

According to an analysis published by prediction market analysis firm The Action Network on November 12, internal executive Ian Buck leads with an implied probability of 35.5%, interim CEO Colette Kress ranks second at 25.5%, Arm CEO René Haas is third at 9.1%, and AMD CEO Lisa Su has a 2.4% probability. (The above estimates combine Kalshi and Polymarket prediction market pricing and are weighted by each platform's historical forecast accuracy.)

Ian Buck has been at Nvidia for 22 years, oversees hyperscale computing and high-performance computing businesses, and is regarded as a core architect of the CUDA architecture.

Among external candidates, Arm CEO René Haas, AMD CEO Lisa Su and Micron Technology CEO Sanjay Mehrotra have also been mentioned by media.

Nvidia is scheduled to report third-quarter earnings on November 17.

The market will not only focus on revenue, orders and next-quarter guidance, but will also closely observe how interim management explains the strategic arrangements after Huang's departure.

Mark Hackett pointed out that with new management just taking office, it is difficult to gain the market's full trust from just one earnings call.

In addition, Anthropic is expected to launch its IPO late next week, which will also be an important window for observing investment sentiment in the AI industry.

For Nvidia, orders stretching to 2028 and continued earnings growth may be enough to support some investors' current dip-buying logic.

But what the market really needs to reprice is whether, after Huang's departure, this AI chip giant can continue to maintain the technological, organizational and industrial ecosystem advantages it built in the past.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment