Four Major Catalysts All Delivered, Yet US Stocks Refuse to Rally — Nomura Warns: Someone Wants Out

Deep News37 minutes ago

NVIDIA's blowout earnings, Anthropic's record-breaking IPO, a smooth VIX expiration, and an approaching massive options settlement — four catalysts landed in unison, yet none could stop the S&P 500 from breaking below its 200-day moving average. Nomura strategist Charlie McElligott issued a stark warning: when all the mechanical buying is already in place and the market still cannot rise, the problem is no longer about positioning — it is that someone wants out.

On Thursday, Nasdaq futures climbed as much as 2% intraday, but the entire gain was erased before midday, and the S&P 500 once again fell below its 200-day moving average. In his latest Nomura research note, McElligott characterized this phenomenon as a core risk: the bullish thesis has been fully priced in, everyone is waiting for the same trade, and that in itself has become the biggest headwind.

Meanwhile, according to the latest Goldman Sachs Prime data, hedge fund fundamental long-short net leverage has dropped to a five-year low, with tech stock selling occurring at the fastest pace in a decade — professional money has already fled en masse, but retail investors and the 401(k) crowd have yet to follow.

McElligott offered a key judgment: if stocks still cannot stabilize and recover early next week despite all mechanical buying conditions being in place, it would mean deeper forces are driving the market — the "growth scare" may be real, rather than mere position compression.

The "Quad-Fecta" Delivered, but the Rally Lasted Only One Hour

McElligott had previously defined this week as a "Risk Quad-fecta": NVIDIA earnings, VIX expiration, the Anthropic IPO, and Friday's massive options settlement, viewing them as a potential volatility inflection point.

By all accounts, the scorecard came back nearly perfect. NVIDIA's earnings were "extremely strong with raised guidance"; Anthropic's IPO priced at $83, above its offering range, with secondary market opening indications around $110 — a premium of over 30% above the IPO price — pushing its market cap past $2 trillion, while the IPO syndicate confirmed severely undersubscribed demand and extremely low allocation rates; and VIX expiration was "completely clean with no gamma squeeze whatsoever."

Yet as each of these positives materialized one by one, the 2% gain in Nasdaq futures vanished before Thursday midday, and the S&P 500 slid below its 200-day moving average. This price action aligns closely with McElligott's concern: the bullish thesis is "too obvious," and that is precisely its greatest obstacle.

Notably, the gamma rolling off after Friday's massive options settlement is predominantly dealer long gamma, meaning the market will actually lose some stabilizing flow. McElligott noted that next week will still maintain a significant "short gamma" market regime, potentially amplifying two-way volatility in whichever direction the market is already moving.

Mechanical Buying in Place, CTA and Vol Control Funds Poised to Act

Although the market failed to strengthen immediately, McElligott mapped out multiple potential mechanical upside trigger paths.

On the options vanna effect: if volatility declines modestly in the coming days, dealers will be forced to buy futures — because the delta on their short put positions will shrink as volatility falls, compelling them to cover their short hedges and creating "emotionless" systematic futures buying.

On CTA trend-following funds: Nomura models show that trend signals for the S&P 500, Russell, Nasdaq, Nikkei, TOPIX, and FTSE 100 have all dropped to -8, compared with an average of +66 a month ago, while the Hang Seng Index signal sits at maximum bearish -100. Once trigger conditions are met, a 2% rally would generate approximately $7.9 billion in global equity futures buying, while a 4% rally would trigger roughly $21.1 billion in buying, with the S&P 500 alone contributing about $9.3 billion.

On volatility-target funds (Vol Control): current 1-month realized volatility stands at 23.2%, in the 99.8th historical percentile, far above the 3-month realized volatility of 15.4%.

Nomura estimates that if daily volatility approaches zero in the coming days, this cohort of funds would add approximately $62.9 billion in equity exposure over the next month; but if a single-day 5% decline occurs, the same group would sell roughly $23.2 billion, resetting the clock.

Professional Money Has Already Fled, Retail Has Not Yet Followed

The latest Goldman Sachs Prime monthly report shows that hedge fund deleveraging has been far more aggressive than the market broadly expected.

Fundamental long-short fund net leverage fell another 7.6 percentage points this month to 41.6%, a five-year low; gross leverage dropped 4.4 percentage points to 206.3%. Goldman Sachs data shows that since November, hedge funds have been aggressively net selling global equities, with the ratio of long sales to short sales at approximately 3:1. Over the past four weeks, global equity deleveraging has been the largest since February 2023 and ranks among the largest in the past decade.

On individual stocks: seven of the past eight weeks saw net selling, with the pace accelerating this month; ETF short flow volatility has risen, which Goldman Sachs analysis suggests "indicates investors are actively using macro products to hedge and manage exposure."

The technology sector is the epicenter of this selloff. Over the past six weeks, global information technology selling pace hit an extreme level of -4.4 standard deviations, "far exceeding the pace of the past decade," with the sector long-short ratio plunging from a year-to-date peak of 2.9 to 1.79, approaching a 10-year low. Within US tech, shorting is concentrated in semiconductors, with semiconductor and equipment sector net exposure now below that of the software sector — the first time this has occurred since early 2026.

On the factor dimension, intermediate momentum exposure is declining for a sixth consecutive month and is expected to fall to its lowest since December 2022; value factor exposure has risen to a five-year high, which Goldman Sachs attributes to "rising stagflation concerns."

On performance: global fundamental long-short funds fell 0.2% in November (still up 8.9% year-to-date); TMT funds dropped another 4.5% this month, leaving only 0.6% year-to-date gains.

Goldman Sachs concludes that after "sustained deleveraging and massive net selling," the market "may be brewing a tactical rebound in the near term," with seasonal factors and technicals also turning more favorable. But Goldman Sachs simultaneously flags a key warning: neither its sentiment indicator nor its risk appetite gauge shows "capitulation" behavior among broader market participants. In other words, professional money has capitulated, but retail investors and mass asset allocators have not yet followed.

Nomura Warns: If It Still Cannot Rally, "Someone Wants Out"

McElligott acknowledged that what worries him most currently is precisely that this bullish thesis has been "over-socialized" by the market — everyone has solved the same equation, meaning the trade may have already been pre-positioned. At the same time, macro-level signals remain persistently unsettling.

The Bloomberg Commodity Index has fallen 8.5% this month, energy is down 13.4%, industrial metals are down 8%; Treasuries are strengthening, defensive sectors are in favor, real rates are rising, credit spreads are widening, and equity realized volatility has surged — financial conditions are "tightening rapidly."

McElligott concedes that some of these moves may simply be mechanical deleveraging of crowded long-short positions rather than a "genuine growth signal." But he points to a deeper structural shift: the market's characterization of NVIDIA has reversed — a company once viewed as the AI ecosystem's "long put" is now seen as "the market's short put," and a stellar quarterly report has not changed this perception.

Furthermore, with equities having become the single largest asset in household wealth, McElligott worries that the retail crowd, long accustomed to "buying every dip without thinking," may begin rebalancing toward real yields, with bonds regaining their risk-hedging function.

He set a clear test for early next week: if, with all the aforementioned mechanical buying conditions already in place, the stock market still cannot stabilize and move higher, it would mean larger forces are driving the trend — "someone wants out," the growth scare is real, leveraged funds remain constrained by VaR (Value at Risk) due to year-end performance, capital, or survival pressures, and the 401(k) crowd and real-money allocators are reallocating toward fixed income, breaking the roughly 15-year reflexive behavior of "buy stocks on dips, sell volatility on rallies."

Combining Goldman Sachs and Nomura analysis: when professional money has completed its exit at five-year-low leverage, tech stocks have suffered their fastest selloff in a decade, and the market still cannot hold its 200-day moving average in the face of the most ideal catalyst combination, the root of the problem may lie beyond positioning. Early next week's market direction will be the key answer.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment