Copper futures markets are showing a clear divergence: financial investors are accelerating their exit, while companies actually engaged in copper production, processing and trading are buying against the trend.
Goldman Sachs' latest positioning analysis shows that since September 22, speculative funds have sold off approximately $10.8 billion worth of copper futures. In contrast, producers, processors, traders and users have continued to increase their long positions, with commercial traders' long holdings as a proportion of open interest rising to about 20%, the highest level in several years. This means the current decline in copper prices is not entirely driven by deteriorating physical demand; financial market position adjustments and rising funding costs have also played an important role. Compared with the all-time high set at the end of October, copper prices have fallen by more than $2,000 per tonne. Despite the recent sharp correction, Goldman Sachs commodity strategists still expect copper prices to rise to $15,600 per tonne by December 2027. The bank's long-term bullish case for copper is mainly based on tight physical inventories and demand growth from electrification and AI infrastructure construction.
Speculative funds retreat, physical buyers increase holdings against the trend
According to positioning data released by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) for November 3 to 10, asset management-type speculative traders, other reportable traders and non-reportable traders collectively net sold about $1.3 billion worth of COMEX copper futures. Among them, other reportable traders accounted for a relatively large share of the recent increase in short positions. Since September, most of the net long positions previously accumulated by speculative funds have been closed out, and some investors have even turned net short. Goldman Sachs commodity strategist Robert Quinn pointed out that this round of selling coincided with tightening financial conditions and deteriorating price momentum in industrial commodities, indicating that pressure on copper prices is not only a matter of physical supply and demand but also related to concentrated position adjustments by financial investors. In sharp contrast to speculative funds, commercial traders are buying on dips. Quinn said that during the latest statistical period, commercial traders net bought about $1.1 billion worth of copper futures. About half of that came from newly added long positions rather than simply buying to close existing short trades. Manufacturers buy copper futures usually to lock in future procurement costs; producers can use futures to adjust future output and inventory risk. Therefore, changes in commercial traders' positions often better reflect actual production and copper usage demand. At present, commercial traders' long positions as a share of open interest have reached about 20%. This level shows that as speculative funds exit one after another, physical industry participants are taking on an increasingly important absorbing role. However, commercial buying does not mean copper prices have already bottomed. As long as financial conditions continue to tighten, speculative funds and quantitative trading strategies may still bring greater selling pressure.
Financial conditions tighten, quantitative models turn more bearish
Goldman Sachs believes one of the important factors recently suppressing copper prices is tighter financial conditions. From November 10 to 17, copper prices fell about 4.1%. During the same period, U.S. inflation data came in stronger than expected, and Federal Reserve officials sent hawkish signals, raising market expectations for further rate hikes. The U.S. Financial Conditions Index (FCI) also shows that financing conditions are tightening. At the same time, data center-related stocks fell about 3.2% over the same period, further undermining market optimism about AI infrastructure investment. Goldman Sachs' futures trading team also observed large-scale selling in base metals markets, with Shanghai copper prices falling more than 3%. The team believes this decline was affected both by a hawkish shift in Fed policy expectations and by the restoration of energy supply in the Middle East, and did not simply reflect deteriorating industrial demand. From the perspective of capital flows, the team observed that selling volume was about four times buying volume. Well-known macro investor Stanley Druckenmiller also disclosed that he currently holds short positions in copper while maintaining a neutral view on the stock market. What concerns Goldman Sachs even more is that quantitative trading models have also begun to turn bearish. At present, both the short-term and medium-term momentum signals of Goldman Sachs' copper futures strategy model have turned negative, with only the long-term momentum indicator still in positive territory, but it is also falling rapidly. This could trigger a new round of programmatic selling. Trend-following funds (CTAs) usually adjust positions based on price momentum, and once indicators break below key thresholds, they may mechanically sell futures without considering whether physical market inventories are tight. Goldman Sachs model estimates show that copper futures could face about $9 billion in potential CTA selling over the next week. If price declines further worsen momentum indicators and trigger more quantitative selling, the market could form a self-reinforcing downward cycle. Similar signals have also appeared in the options market. Goldman Sachs data shows that the one-year standardized 25 Delta put/call skew for copper has risen to about the 99th percentile of its distribution range over the past year. The current change means that market enthusiasm for long-term copper price gains has clearly weakened, and investors' demand for protection against downside risk has relatively increased.
Physical supply remains tight, U.S. tariff policy becomes a key variable
While financial markets continue to sell off, copper's physical supply has not improved significantly. Goldman Sachs data shows that on November 18, China's imported refined copper premium had risen to about $360 per tonne, exceeding the previous record level of nearly $200 per tonne. Goldman Sachs metals trader James McGeoch also pointed out that despite continued declines in futures prices, the Shanghai spot market remains very tight, and the scale of outstanding futures contract exposure relative to deliverable copper is enormous. This is consistent with Goldman Sachs' assessment of global inventories: visible copper inventories outside the United States are at abnormally low levels. But elevated prices have also begun to curb actual purchasing. Goldman Sachs' China materials research team found that some end users have already become resistant to high prices, and customer order books have begun to show signs of demand being suppressed, the first time this has happened in months. Another important variable is the future U.S. copper tariff policy. At present, refined cathode copper entering the United States is not subject to Section 232 tariffs that apply to some other copper products. But the policy statement announced by the United States in July 2025 leaves room for phased tariff increases, including a possible 15% tariff in 2027 and a possible increase to 30% in 2028. Previously, market expectations for tariffs drove large amounts of copper into U.S. warehouses. In July 2025, after the United States excluded refined copper from the initially proposed 50% tariff, speculative funds quickly reversed positions, and related trades saw concentrated liquidation. Quinn believes that whether the future U.S. government advances tariff policy as planned will directly affect commercial traders' willingness to hold positions. If the phased tariff increase plan continues, traders may continue shipping copper to the United States, supporting local inventories and price premiums. Conversely, if tariffs are delayed or canceled, the incentive to move inventories to the United States may weaken, and some commercial buying may also withdraw.
The core contradiction facing the copper market is exactly this: global physical inventories remain tight, and China's spot premium continues to rise, but speculative funds, quantitative trading strategies and some long-term investors are collectively retreating. Goldman Sachs remains optimistic in its forecast for copper prices by the end of 2027, but whether the short-term market can stabilize increasingly depends on whether commercial traders can continue to absorb financial funds' selling. Copper's long-term supply gap has not disappeared, but physical demand is not infinite either. If financial conditions tighten further, CTA selling is released in concentrated fashion, or U.S. tariff expectations reverse, commercial buyers may also gradually reduce their absorption capacity. For now, the question the market truly needs to answer has become: with speculative funds continuing to retreat, how much longer can physical buyers support copper prices?
Comments