At this point, nearly everyone seems to agree: mortgage rates above 7% have settled in as the new "normal." That phrase has been showing up again and again in recent public remarks by several housing economists, including the chief economist at the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and the chief economist at the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB). Forecast reports from the major housing institutions increasingly reflect that view as well, with mainstream housing organizations projecting that mortgage rates will stay above 7% for a long stretch through 2027. Fannie Mae has issued forecasts for where rates will go in 2027, while the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) expects rates to remain above 7%. That means the 3%-4% mortgage rates borrowers grew used to over the past few years are unlikely to return any time soon. Jenna Stauffer, a broker and market analyst at Sotheby's International Realty, said rates will certainly move up and down in response to economic data, but the broader economic backdrop we are in now is different from the 2010s or the pandemic era.
Why rates are likely to stay high for a long time
Mortgage rates generally track the yield on the 10-year U.S. Treasury note. That benchmark is used because most 30-year mortgages are paid off or refinanced before they mature. A number of forces are keeping long-term borrowing costs elevated. The first is stubborn inflation. When inflation runs hot, investors demand higher yields on long-term bonds to make up for the loss of purchasing power on their future repayments. Inflation as measured by the personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, the Federal Reserve's preferred gauge, has persistently failed to reach the central bank's 2% target. But inflation is not the only cause. Selma Hepp, chief economist at the real estate data firm Cotality, points out that the federal government is running a huge fiscal deficit, while at the same time the artificial intelligence boom is driving massive capital investment in data centers, power generation facilities, and other infrastructure. Those two forces together are pushing up overall demand for capital, which in turn puts upward pressure on long-term borrowing costs. Comparing today with the 2010s, Hepp said the past was a time of abundant capital and limited investment opportunities, whereas now there is fierce competition for capital in the market. It was the combination of low inflation, ample savings, and weak capital demand that held mortgage rates down back then. Demand for mortgage-backed bonds has also shrunk, adding further upward pressure on home loan rates. Tom Graff, chief investment officer at the wealth management firm Facet, said that when rates spiked in 2022-2023, banks suffered huge losses on their bond portfolios, and since then banks have become increasingly reluctant to hold mortgage-backed securities. That is because bond prices generally fall when rates rise. The failures of Silicon Valley Bank and First Republic Bank also prompted regulators to scrutinize banks' bond holdings more closely. During the pandemic, the Fed's policy went in the opposite direction: at the time it bought large amounts of U.S. Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities to push down long-term borrowing costs and drive mortgage rates to historic lows. Steve Kaminski, head of housing credit at TD Bank, said the Fed is no longer actively buying mortgage-backed securities. Kaminski said the low-rate environment is gone, and mortgage rates are likely to stay high for at least the next year.
What would bring mortgage rates back down
Hepp believes that pulling mortgage rates back toward 6% would require cooler inflation, slower economic growth, or less government borrowing pressure, which would push the 10-year Treasury yield lower. Kaminski holds a similar view, saying a drop below 7% would require inflation to ease and Treasury yields to fall. If the economy weakens, investors would flock to the relative safety of Treasuries, which would also push yields down and drag mortgage rates lower. Whether any of those scenarios will materialize is still uncertain. That is why Hepp does not agree with simply calling 7% the "new normal," since the number 7% itself is not a permanently fixed level. Even so, the mix of conditions that produced ultra-low 3%-4% mortgage rates, namely low inflation, excess capital, and an accommodative Fed, no longer exists. For prospective homebuyers, simply waiting for mortgage rates to fall sharply is a gamble in itself. Hepp said we should not expect to return to the kind of financial environment where 3% or 4% mortgage rates were a regular occurrence.
Comments