Throughout this year, the tight correlation between oil prices and government borrowing costs had been a defining feature of global bond markets.
However, that link has now weakened as traders shift their focus to how central banks will respond to energy-driven inflation that has already spread throughout various sectors of the economy.
After the outbreak of the Iran war in late February, rising oil prices pushed sovereign bond yields higher, with traders positioning for an inflation shock and a series of rate hikes.
Yet even though global crude benchmark prices have fallen sharply in recent weeks, partly due to hopes for US-Iran peace talks, bond yields and market rate expectations remain elevated, continuing to weigh on government and household finances.
The US 10-year Treasury yield is still above 5%, not far from last month's high, which was the highest since 2002.
Meanwhile, the US crude benchmark West Texas Intermediate (WTI) has dropped from an intraday peak of $110 per barrel in October to below $90.
"Government bonds have decoupled from oil prices and returned to their normal characteristics," said Ales Koutny, head of international rates at asset manager Vanguard.
In September, the rolling correlation coefficient between oil prices and bond yields rose to 65%, the highest level in decades.
One bond fund manager remarked that during the Iran war, "we had basically become oil traders."
But according to analysis by derivatives exchange group Cboe, that correlation has since fallen below 20%.
John Stopford, head of multi-asset income at another fund manager, Ninety One, said the bond market is weakening, "which is a response to hawkish comments from central banks that reflect their frustration with persistently high inflation."
The US Federal Reserve raised its policy rate in September, the first increase since 2023.
Traders expect the Fed to raise rates by at least another 25 basis points at next month's meeting.
Last week, US Treasuries suffered their worst week in more than 18 months.
That followed stronger-than-expected inflation data and comments from Fed Governor Chris Waller that a 50 basis point hike "should be considered" in December, prompting traders to bet on more aggressive Fed tightening.
When bond prices fall, yields rise.
Although most Fed officials favor gradual rate adjustments rather than aggressive moves, making a 25 basis point hike more likely in the eyes of Fed watchers, the resilience shown by US economic growth is still fueling hawkish market bets.
Another Fed decision-maker, Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack, said earlier this month that inflationary pressures "appear to be fairly broad-based, reflecting both supply and demand factors."
Hammack has consistently supported rate hikes at two consecutive policy meetings.
Some investors warn that inflation pressures are becoming entrenched after multiple supply shocks.
"Inflation is often like a virus... once it enters the economic system, it is very hard to eliminate," Greg Peters, co-chief investment officer of PGIM Credit, said on a podcast last week.
Similar situations have emerged in other major economies.
Although Brent crude has retreated from near $120 per barrel in October and briefly fell below $90 this month, UK two-year gilt yields recently rose above 5% for the first time in more than three years.
Compared with long-term bonds, two-year yields are more sensitive to rate expectations.
Traders believe the Bank of England is likely to deliver its second rate hike of the year at next month's meeting.
Interest rate swap contracts indicate about a 75% probability, and the market also expects further BoE rate increases next year.
BoE policymakers have warned that resilient UK economic growth, combined with the aftereffects of higher energy prices, could mean a series of consecutive rate hikes may be needed.
Matt Amis, investment director at Aberdeen Investments, said that for the BoE to feel more "comfortable" about the inflation outlook, there would need to be "a substantive resolution to the Iran war, or oil prices remaining low for a prolonged period."
As the direct pass-through effect of oil prices on bond yields weakens, Vanguard's Koutny said the "stocks down, bonds up" relationship appears to be re-establishing itself, meaning bonds can serve as a hedge when stock prices fall.
In recent weeks, whenever stocks fell sharply, US Treasuries and other safe-haven government bonds saw bouts of buying.
Comments