Guotai Haitong has released a research report noting that over the past month, oil shipping freight rates have fallen significantly from their highs, driven by partial improvement in disruptions and fluctuations in geopolitical expectations. Considering that geopolitical expectations are gradually returning to rationality, and that an oil price rebound alongside falling freight rates could help trade recover, the report suggests paying attention to opportunities for positioning as freight rates stabilize and rebound.
The report notes that geopolitical expectations gradually returning to rationality may reduce short-term impacts, and that oil shipping holds investment value regardless of whether geopolitical tensions ease. The main views of Guotai Haitong (601211) are as follows.
Declining geopolitical risk premium drags oil shipping rates down, stabilization and rebound expected after supply-demand rebalancing
Hormuz Strait dark fleet navigation being unlocked and tanker efficiency losses drove rates upward from September, compounded by Middle East capacity diversion causing localized disruptions in the US Gulf and other regions, sending freight rates on an epic surge. In early October, VLCC TCE on major routes outside the Gulf peaked at US$640,000-910,000. Over the past month, rates have fallen significantly from their record highs, stabilizing at US$500,000-600,000 in late October, then rapidly falling again to US$200,000-300,000 per day after the US midterm elections in early November.
The report notes that the reasons and sustainability of the two-stage decline may differ significantly.
Stage one: Partial improvement in disruptions. 1) Iran has intensified attacks on ships since mid-October, affecting Middle East dark fleet cargo volumes, while ultra-high freight rates have suppressed US Gulf shipments. 2) Transshipment efficiency losses have marginally improved. Large-scale transshipment by the Middle East dark fleet caused significant tanker efficiency losses, particularly as bottlenecks in organizational capacity led to notably prolonged transshipment times. As organizational capabilities gradually improved, the single-voyage time for shuttle tankers within the Gulf has been shortened from 25 days in August to 14 days in November, with overall tanker operational efficiency improving marginally.
Stage two: Geopolitical expectation fluctuations. Since the US midterm elections concluded on November 4, expectations for easing US-Iran geopolitical tensions have risen, risk premium expectations have declined, and sharp drops in forward FFA contracts have affected spot market sentiment. Meanwhile, falling crude oil prices may also cause charterers to adopt a wait-and-see approach, affecting trade节奏.
Considering that geopolitical expectations are gradually returning to rationality, and that an oil price rebound alongside falling freight rates could help trade recover, the report suggests paying attention to opportunities for positioning as freight rates stabilize and rebound.
Geopolitical conflicts strengthen the medium-to-long-term logic of oil shipping, which holds investment value whether tensions ease or not
The geopolitical situation remains complex and difficult to assess, but the report notes that regardless of how geopolitics evolves, oil shipping possesses investment logic and value. 1) If geopolitical conflicts persist, market expectations will be corrected and short-term impacts will diminish. Oil shipping will continue to follow the logic of sustained dark fleet navigation plus efficiency losses plus geopolitical premium, and the freight rate center is still expected to remain at high levels. 2) If the US and Iran reach an agreement and the Hormuz Strait returns to normal navigation, tanker efficiency will recover. Meanwhile, global crude oil supply will return to the production increase cycle that began in 2025, and global inventory restocking will further guarantee oil shipping demand growth over the next two years. Capacity utilization rates remaining at high levels, combined with Longship's controlling position, mean the freight rate center is still expected to be higher than before the conflict.
Current market value is near replacement value, and high dividend yields support the valuation floor
The current secondhand sale price of 15-year-old VLCCs is basically on par with newbuilding prices. Taking China Merchants Energy Shipping as an example, the report estimates that the replacement cost of the company's tanker, dry bulk, ro-ro, and container fleets exceeds RMB 120 billion. Even without considering the company's high profitability in 2026-2027, the current valuation is already approaching replacement value. At the same time, the dividend yields of COSCO Shipping Energy Transportation A-shares and China Merchants Energy Shipping have reached 9-10%, with COSCO Shipping Energy Transportation H-shares exceeding 12%, with high dividends supporting the valuation floor.
Oil shipping also carries demand surprise optionality, highlighting value positioning opportunities
If the US lifts sanctions on Iran, the report estimates that compliant VLCC demand would increase by more than 10%, potentially providing another rare demand surprise for the oil shipping market. Accelerating fleet aging is expected to continue ensuring relative rigidity in effective compliant market tanker capacity for years to come, and demand surprises could help the compliant oil shipping market achieve ultra-high prosperity that is sustainable. The report notes that oil shipping companies' Q4 profits will set historical records. Geopolitical expectation fluctuations have led to short-term freight rate pullbacks, but industry participants remain optimistic about the freight rate center staying at high levels. It is recommended to seize the value bottom and actively take contrarian positions. Top picks include China Merchants Energy Shipping, COSCO Shipping Energy Transportation A/H, China Merchants Nanjing Tanker, and China Shipbuilding Leasing.
Risk warnings: Geopolitical situations and strait blockades, economic fluctuations and end-user demand, safety accidents.
Comments