Fed's October FOMC minutes provide multiple reasons for holding rates steady while offering strong guidance for at least a 25 basis point hike in December

Deep News11-19 14:07

The minutes from the Federal Reserve's October FOMC meeting released contradictory signals: on one hand, they offered a wide variety of justifications for the rate pause at the previous gathering, while on the other, they gave the market unusually forceful guidance that the December meeting will most likely deliver at least a 25 basis point increase. On November 18, according to a trading desk report, JPMorgan characterized the minutes as saying "Lord, make me hawkish, but not yet."

The minutes were clear and direct in their forward guidance. "Almost all participants" judged that under a baseline scenario, further tightening of policy in the coming months would be appropriate. Among them, "a few" participants indicated that the December hike might need to exceed 25 basis points — JPMorgan analyst Michael Feroli assessed that this group could include Governor Waller and one other committee member; and "a few" others believed policy might need to move to a "more restrictive" stance, implying possibly more than two additional 25 basis point hikes.

The minutes showed that although the forward-looking stance was clearly hawkish, the reasons Fed officials cited for the October pause were quite diverse. Combining the language of the minutes with JPMorgan's interpretation, the market's current expectation of a 25 basis point hike in December has now received explicit endorsement from the minutes.

Why rates stayed put in October: officials gave multiple reasons

The minutes detailed the various arguments supporting the October pause. "Many" participants discussed the benefits of gathering more information, although hawkish members later in the minutes questioned just how much substantive new information the market could actually obtain over the following six weeks. "A few" members believed that slowing the pace of hikes could give businesses and households more time to adapt; "several" members argued that what truly matters is the overall path of the federal funds rate, not the specific action at any single meeting. By contrast, members who advocated for a hike in October had more direct reasoning: inflation remains too high, and current policy is not yet sufficiently restrictive.

December rate path: unusually clear guidance from the minutes

Despite the numerous reasons for the October pause, the minutes were exceptionally explicit in their forward guidance for December. "Almost all participants" supported further tightening under the baseline scenario, a statement that already constitutes a relatively strong policy pre-signal. Feroli noted in his report that regardless of the reasons for the October pause, the meeting minutes clearly point to a 25 basis point hike in December. Some hawkish members even expressed doubt about whether enough new information could be obtained after the pause, further reinforcing the necessity of action in December.

Economic and financial stability risks: disappointing AI returns called out

The minutes were broadly in line with expectations regarding the economic outlook and committee discussions. Notably, during the discussion of financial stability risks, "almost all participants" specifically mentioned a potential risk scenario — if AI investment returns disappoint investors, it could trigger market turmoil.

"When discussing financial stability, almost all participants spoke about the related risk: if the returns on AI investment disappoint investors, it could trigger a series of problems. Many participants explored what consequences might arise if an AI-related asset price repricing were to occur. Most participants noted that AI-related debt is growing rapidly, and a large portion of it is formed through complex and opaque financing structures. A few participants mentioned that AI-related risk exposure is increasingly concentrated in a small number of companies."

Strangely, however, the minutes did not record any discussion of changes to the 2027 FOMC meeting schedule. Previously, Fed Chairman Warsh had announced that the Fed would adjust its meeting system starting in 2027: one of the eight annual meetings would be dedicated to strategic discussion of macroeconomic monetary policy, without a rate vote; by 2028, such strategy meetings would increase to two.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment