Gold Prices Keep Sliding After a Brutal Year for the Metal

Deep News11-19 22:24

Gold has extended its painful run, with prices dropping below $3,700 an ounce on Thursday after a steep retreat from January's record high.

Rising Treasury yields and a firmer dollar have pushed up the opportunity cost of holding gold, which pays no interest.

Analysts are split on where prices go next in the near term, though many still see gold as a valuable long-term diversifier.

Precious metals investors have endured a wild ride over the past year. Gold was red hot, setting 53 record highs in 2025, and on January 28 COMEX gold hit an all-time peak of $5,589.38 an ounce before suffering an almost equally dramatic collapse. On Wednesday, bullion fell below $3,800 for the first time since September 2025, down roughly a third from its peak. Suki Cooper, global head of commodities research at London-based Standard Chartered, said a combination of forces drove gold to its record early this year, and now a different set of forces is dragging it down.

"Gold can behave as either a commodity or a currency," Cooper said. Which side dominates depends on what is driving markets and how investors feel. Right now, the currency logic is weighing on the metal. Cooper said the rally began with strong physical demand from 2022 onward, which built a floor under prices. In the second phase, investors reassessed gold's role in portfolios: with the opportunity cost of holding a non-yielding asset falling, they began allocating to gold with a long-term view, marking a turning point. Before early 2025, long-term investors, especially gold ETF holders, had been trimming positions, effectively adding supply to the market. But that trend reversed last year: ETF holdings, led by the SPDR Gold ETF (GLD), grew by about 800 tonnes, absorbing the market's excess supply. "Back then the market was overwhelmingly bullish, everyone wanted to buy and no one wanted to sell," Cooper said. With little selling in the secondary market, prices kept climbing. By late 2025, net gold ETF holdings topped 4,000 tonnes. World Gold Council data show global gold ETFs enjoyed their strongest year of inflows ever, with $89 billion of net inflows, mostly from North America, while total assets doubled to $559 billion. Cooper said a weaker dollar, falling bond yields and global debt worries set the stage for gold's surge in 2026. Investors who had been underweight gold kept adding.

Evan Mills, an advisor at Winston-Salem, North Carolina-based fee-only firm Scholar Financial Advising, said falling rates, expectations of further cuts and a softer dollar all pushed money toward gold. "If you were investing in gold and commodities, it was a fantastic environment," Mills said, adding that investors earned richly in a falling-rate world. "Cash did poorly in that environment, so many people looked for other places to park money and preserve purchasing power." But after January, the picture flipped. The rapid climb made some investors uneasy, and talk of the Fed tightening policy grew louder. Then conflict broke out in the Middle East, and gold's role changed: it was no longer a portfolio hedge but a source of liquidity. Cooper explained that because gold is liquid and easy to sell, investors sold it for cash, starting the first correction. Since then, the market has been pricing the Fed's policy path. Mills: "In 2026, the Fed overall leans toward higher rates." This week, Fed Governor Christopher Waller said steps may be needed to deliver "a shock to the market." "With Treasury yields rising and the dollar strengthening, the opportunity cost of holding this non-interest-bearing asset has jumped," Mills said. Mills argued that in the current environment cash offers decent returns, with money market funds yielding 4%–5%, and gold investors are effectively giving up that income. "Cash can preserve purchasing power, and you don't have to put it into illiquid assets or rely on others to agree on its value." From 2025 into 2026, gold's own scarcity did not change; it was the appeal of gold's alternatives that rose sharply. "Traditional portfolio holdings like stocks and bonds became far more attractive, and after weighing the opportunity cost, investors decided not to hold gold," Mills said. Other precious metals suffered the same fate in 2026, with silver also plunging from a record high.

Why investors still need to stay cautious on gold

After such an extreme rally, it is easy for the market to question gold. Mills cautioned that first, remember expectations had been very high. "When people expect to make 20% or 30% in a year, panic sets in as soon as returns fall short." Gold investors need not panic, but they must be cautious. "In the short term, with real yields rising and further Fed hikes likely to strengthen the dollar, I would stay cautious on gold within an overall portfolio," Mills said. The key for investors is to think clearly about why they allocated to gold in the first place. "If you are a short-term trader, gold may not belong in your portfolio at all," Mills said. If gold is used as a hedge, it still has allocation value, but the entry price determines whether the investment ultimately works out. "If you expect gold to be the growth engine of your portfolio, you will likely be disappointed. Gold is insurance, not a growth engine; buying that insurance after prices have already soared is itself a mistake." He added: for investors who bought at the January peak as a small, long-term hedge, this slump does not contradict their original purpose. "There is really no need to worry too much, because this is exactly why you allocate to gold." Mills said gold usually performs well when the dollar weakens and markets or geopolitics are turbulent; when those risks fade, other portfolio assets should carry the returns. "That is the point of insurance and diversification: gold strengthens when the rest of the portfolio is weak; the reverse is normal too, they rotate, and that is the value of diversification."

Other commodity experts: the long-term bullish case remains

Amy Gower, head of metals and mining strategy at Morgan Stanley, said that despite this year's pullback, investors still have ample reasons to keep holding gold. Philip Diehl, former director of the U.S. Mint and president of Austin, Texas-based U.S. Money Reserve, said the long-term support for gold has not disappeared, but abrupt shifts in U.S. trade policy and geopolitical alliances, combined with the Iran war, amount to a black swan event for precious metals. "The fundamentals driving this bull market are still there, they were just interrupted by a Category 5 hurricane in the form of this ill-advised war in the Persian Gulf," Diehl said. He expects a turn once voters made clear two weeks ago their preference to end the war. "I am confident that as oil prices normalize, refined fuel prices fall and rates stabilize, gold will return to an upward path in 2027."

Retail investors trapped, central bank buying diverges, gold tests new lows

World Gold Council data show central bank buying continues, with September purchases hitting a monthly record, though total purchases fell 7% year over year. Marc Chandler, managing partner and chief market strategist at Bannockburn Capital Markets, said surveys suggest the broad trend of central bank buying will not change. "But do not just focus on China or U.S. adversaries," he said, noting World Gold Council data show NATO member Poland is among the major buyers this year. "Retail investors are already trapped," Chandler said, adding that high rates have made all non-yielding assets less appealing, bitcoin included. He sees a gold target range of $3,500–$3,600. On Thursday morning gold hit a fresh low, falling below $3,700. "On the charts, there is no signal that a bottom has been established," Chandler said. "Investors rushing to buy the dip must be careful and wait patiently for a reversal pattern. So far this decline has been relatively orderly overall." "Compared with historical ranges outside the past two years, gold is still very expensive," he added, noting gold's 10-year moving average is about $2,127 and its 20-year average is about $1,666.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment