Guotai Haitong: Retail Sector Seasonality Concentrated in Second Half; Major Rallies Need Multiple Drivers

Stock News11-17 11:14

Guotai Haitong Securities Co., Ltd. has released a research note stating that the seasonality of the retail sector is concentrated in the second half of the year rather than evenly distributed: November is the only month with five consecutive years of positive returns and five consecutive years of outperforming the CSI 300 (general retail averaging +8.7%). A historical review shows that the fundamentals of the traditional retail sector remain under pressure, with share price movements priced by consumption-stimulus policies and marginal changes at the individual stock and sector level, while major rallies typically require multiple factors working together, such as "marginal changes at the company level plus favorable national policies." The main views of Guotai Haitong Securities Co., Ltd. are as follows.

Historical Review

The monthly win rate and excess returns of the General Retail (Shenwan) Index rise significantly in three windows: July, November, and December, while the first half of the year generally underperforms the CSI 300, with January and June being the weakest. November is the only month with positive returns for five consecutive years from 2021 to 2025 and excess returns over the CSI 300 for five consecutive years. On an average basis across sub-sectors, the General Retail (Shenwan) Index posted an average monthly gain of 8.7% in November from 2021 to 2025, with average excess returns of 7.8% over the CSI 300 Index. The Department Store (Shenwan) Index recorded positive returns for four consecutive years from 2022 to 2025 and outperformed the CSI 300 for five consecutive years from 2021 to 2025, with an average gain of 14.3% and average excess returns of 13.4%, showing strong elasticity.

Seasonality Driven by Marginal Change Expectations, Not Valuation or Fundamentals

This seasonality is not driven by valuation or fundamentals but by expectations of marginal changes. The fourth quarter, as the longest earnings vacuum period of the year, coincides with the traditional consumption peak season at year-end and New Year. The firm believes the market is focused on peak-season data performance, as well as the policy tone on consumption promotion (consumption vouchers, trade-ins, etc.) and possible incremental measures from the December Politburo meeting and the Central Economic Work Conference. Such policies typically boost sales earlier and more directly in formats such as department stores and supermarkets.

Traditional Retail Fundamentals Remain Under Pressure, Turning Point Not Yet in Sight

From January to September 2026, total retail sales of consumer goods grew only 1.1% year-on-year, with growth slowing, while department stores and specialty stores continued to face pressure. The Supermarket (Shenwan) sector saw revenue decline for three consecutive years from 2023 to 2025, with net profit attributable to parent and non-GAAP net profit negative for five consecutive years from 2021 to 2025. The Department Store (Shenwan) sector posted negative net profit attributable to parent and non-GAAP net profit for four consecutive years from 2022 to 2025. The divergence between fundamentals and share prices means that market movements are priced by marginal changes rather than earnings trends, but a single catalyst is often not enough. Yonghui Superstores announced its "Pang Donglai-style reform" in late May 2024, and from the opening of its first revamped store on June 19, its shares rose more than 20% in just over half a month. With the "924" policy package plus Miniso's equity investment, the rally peaked in mid-December with a gain of over 200%, while the financial statements had not yet reflected substantive performance improvement from the revamp. Zhongbai Group and Bubugao showed no share price reaction in the early stage of the "Pang Donglai-style reform." Zhongbai Group only surged 216% in a single month in December 2024, driven by the "924" policy, expectations of a same-industry competition restructuring with Wushang Group, and the debut economy, before falling 33.6% the following January. The most significant catalyst for Bubugao was its "cap removal" in April 2025 (up 56% that month). Chongqing Department Store and Dashang Group, which lacked major marginal catalysts, saw limited share price reactions after reform events.

Individual Stock Elasticity Concentrated in a Few "Shell-Attribute Plus Event-Catalyst" Names

Among the top 20 fourth-quarter gainers from 2016 to 2025, Sanjiang Shopping (Alibaba investment) in Q4 2016, Nanning Department Store (change of control) in Q4 2019, Zhongbai Group (expectations of a same-industry competition restructuring with Wushang Group) in Q4 2024, and Dongbai Group (Fujian cross-strait policy) in Q4 2025 each posted quarterly gains exceeding 100%. In terms of the number of appearances, Zhejiang Dongri topped the list with seven appearances, while Ningbo Zhongbai and Quanxinhao each appeared six times. The high recurrence of the top 20 names indicates that opportunities in this window depend more on regional state-owned background, small market capitalization, and restructuring expectations rather than sector prosperity.

Risk Warning

Declining consumer spending power, intensifying industry competition, and policy implementation falling short of expectations.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment