When Kevin Warsh was sworn in at a White House ceremony in May, President Donald Trump lauded his chosen Federal Reserve chairman and urged him to act with full autonomy.
"Just do your own thing," Trump said.
That freedom is set to be tested this week as the Fed faces mounting pressure to raise borrowing costs in order to curb persistently high inflation. Friday's consumer price report showed core inflation accelerating faster than anticipated in August, pushing futures market odds of a rate increase at the Fed's Sept. 15-16 meeting above 85%.
That trajectory puts Warsh on a path of direct conflict with a president who has repeatedly called for lower rates. Trump has recently threatened to intensify trade disputes if policy isn't loosened, and on Sunday he reiterated his stance that U.S. borrowing costs should be the lowest globally.
When asked if he anticipated a rate hike at the upcoming meeting, Trump responded, "I don't know."
The clamor for easier policy is amplified by political anxiety within the White House. With midterm elections approaching, polls indicate growing voter frustration over the rising cost of living. Lower rates, even if their impact on mortgage or credit card payments takes months to materialize, could offer Trump a chance to suggest economic relief is imminent, deflecting blame from his administration.
This dynamic places Warsh in an institutional bind just weeks before voters go to the polls.
"They really are in a no-win situation where they incur the president's wrath or diminish their credibility in the markets, with consequences for inflation that are probably more severe down the road," said Maurice Obstfeld, senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics and former chief economist at the International Monetary Fund. "I don't think Warsh wants to go down as the Fed chairman who buckled to administration pressure when the Fed's mandate was at stake."
In the wake of the latest inflation report, a White House official has offered mixed signals about how the president might respond to a rate increase.
On Friday, National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett told Bloomberg TV that Trump still desired rate cuts, and if the Fed hiked, "The president will have something to say about it."
On Sunday, Hassett tempered those remarks.
"If it's a rate hike, then the president — I'm sure he's not going to be super happy about it, but he will defend the independence of Kevin Warsh above all," he said on Fox News Sunday.
Echoes of Powell's Struggles
If Warsh's predecessor is any indication, trouble may lie ahead. Trump's initial Fed chair, Jerome Powell, was sworn in during early February 2018, and by July of that year, the president was openly chastising him over rate increases. Years of unprecedented attacks followed.
Powell, however, kept a distant, formal relationship with the White House. Warsh, in contrast, has engaged in informal conversations with Trump on multiple occasions since assuming office. Some Fed observers believe that even if the central bank proceeds with new rate hikes, Warsh might placate Trump by leaning on his personal rapport with the president.
"He can flatter the president on the phone and listen to him and hear him out," said Michael Redmond, U.S. economist at consulting firm Energy Aspects. "Maybe there isn't such a squeeze on Warsh."
Nevertheless, Warsh is navigating a delicate path with an administration that has exerted significant pressure on the central bank, extending beyond verbal criticism.
Trump has attempted, in a move so far blocked by the Supreme Court, to dismiss Fed Governor Lisa Cook. His Justice Department also pursued a criminal inquiry into Powell over allegations of fraud tied to the Fed's headquarters reconstruction, a probe that was abandoned after bipartisan objections from lawmakers and a federal judge's characterization of it as an overreach.
"Warsh can't win politically right now," said Heather Long, chief economist at Navy Federal Credit Union. "If he hikes, he's going to get a tweet, and if he holds steady, he's going to get backlash" from markets.
Major Wall Street institutions, including TD Bank and JPMorgan Chase & Co., swiftly revised their projections after Friday's inflation data, anticipating a rate increase this week.
"The unfiltered market signal is clear: Investors want and expect the FOMC to hike. If the Fed does not hike, Warsh will be boxed in by markets under pressure to raise rates by 25 bps in the eyes of market participants." - Anna Wong, economist, and Andrew Sacher, economist
Patrick Harker, a former president of the Philadelphia Fed currently at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, suggested that a rate hike might, paradoxically, support the administration's broader economic objectives by alleviating inflation concerns. Elevated inflation expectations can push up yields on longer-dated Treasuries, raising mortgage and corporate borrowing costs.
"By raising rates, that signals that the Fed's on the job," Harker said. "That might help with what the administration is trying to do, not hurt it."
Notably, the yield on the 30-year U.S. Treasury bond climbed on July 29 when the Fed held rates steady and Warsh failed to adequately explain the decision to investors.
Navigating Internal Tensions
Meanwhile, Warsh must maintain another equilibrium within the Fed itself. The policy committee he took over in May is committed to safeguarding the central bank's independence. That protective instinct was underscored in May when Powell broke with precedent by remaining as a governor after his term as chair ended, preventing Trump from appointing a replacement.
Against this backdrop, Fed officials have grown increasingly concerned about persistent inflation. At their July meeting, three policymakers dissented in favor of a rate hike. Following the latest data, any attempt by Warsh to delay a rate increase could undermine his credibility with the colleagues he aims to lead.
Ironically, this is a scenario Trump himself predicted while interviewing candidates for the Fed's top role.
"They're saying everything I want to hear, and then they get the job," Trump said in January, days before selecting Warsh. "They get the job, and all of a sudden, 'Let's raise rates a little bit.'"
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
Comments