Crowded Treasury Shorts Collide With Haven Buying, BofA Flags Rising "Pain Trade" Risk

Deep News07:46

Bond traders who rebuilt short positions in Treasuries are now facing potential squeeze risk: concerns surrounding artificial intelligence (AI) have reignited, and combined with a string of technical system failures, haven flows are rushing back into Treasuries, leaving crowded short positions exposed to the threat of a rapid reversal.

Over the past week, a hawkish shift in the outlook for Federal Reserve policy temporarily suppressed the just-emerging haven bid — earlier this month, the 10-year Treasury yield had fallen to a low of 4.81% on safe-haven demand, and that shift left long-standing Treasury shorts essentially intact. Strategists at Bank of America Corp (BAC.US) warned that this setup is rapidly turning into the market's "pain trade."

"After last week's selloff, shorts got a breather as market momentum tilted back in their favor," BofA strategists wrote in a report published Monday. The report also noted that some momentum-driven accounts had recently re-entered short positions, though the size was "relatively small."

Strategists said short positions are prone to reversing quickly when haven sentiment runs high. "If rates rise, short positions remain the most crowded and possibly the most painful trade, but given recent price action, the trigger threshold has been raised," they said.

That risk already showed signs of materializing on Tuesday. That day, U.S. October retail sales came in better than expected, which should have weighed on Treasuries; but reports then emerged that a highly classified network used by the National Security Agency for internal communications had gone down, and Treasuries quickly recovered their losses. It was the latest in a series of outages since last week affecting Microsoft Corp (MSFT.US) and systems at several banks, heightening market worries about widespread system paralysis.

Cash bonds duly rallied, with yields across maturities touching intraday lows, while futures volume surged to the highest level of the day. Before that volatility, hedging demand had already picked up noticeably. After U.S. October inflation data came in above expectations, and comments from Fed Governor Christopher Waller put the possibility of a large rate hike in view, traders stepped up hedges against the tail risk of a 50 basis point increase at the Dec. 9 policy meeting.

Traders turned to options to bet on where the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) would go after next month's Fed rate decision. December SOFR options have become a popular hedging tool, expiring just two days after the Fed's final meeting of the year. In the cash market, there were signs that crowded short positioning may have begun to loosen. In the week through Nov. 16, JPMorgan's Treasury client survey showed net shorts held at roughly a three-month low, while investors shifted from neutral to long, with net longs rising.

Here is how other positioning indicators in the rates market changed over the past week: SOFR options positioning among SOFR options expiring Dec. 26, March 27 and June 27, call risk expiring March 27 rose significantly due to a large addition of new positions in the SFRH7 95.25/95.50/96.00 call spread over the past week. These call spreads were bought through the SFRH7 96.00/96.25 call spread. The SFRH7 95.50/95.75/96.00 call spread for the same tenor has also been popular recently. In addition, outright buying recently appeared in the SOFR Dec. 26 expiry 95.75 put, boosting open interest at that strike. Last week, the put at that strike traded at 7.25, and on Monday buyers continued to purchase the put at that strike at 6.75. Among SOFR options expiring Dec. 26, March 27 and June 27, open interest at the 96.50 strike remains the most crowded. Recent trades around that strike include buying the SFRM7 96.50/97.25 2x3 call spread while selling the March 2027 96.25/97.00 2x3 call spread; in addition, recent activity around that strike has focused on the June 27 expiry 96.50/97.00/97.50/98.00 call condor.

Treasury option skew although the premium for hedging Treasury options has trended toward neutral in recent sessions, put premiums remain elevated at the long end of futures contracts. With the 10-year Treasury yield back above 5%, Treasury option activity around the December expiry has been mixed. Notable trades include the December 105.00/105.50 1x2 put spread and the December 106.00/107.00 call spread, both aimed at hedging Treasury yields.

JPMorgan Treasury client survey in the week through Nov. 16, investors shifted from neutral to long, while short holdings were unchanged. The share of net longs rose 3 percentage points, while neutral positioning fell by the same amount. The survey continues to show net shorts at their lowest level since Aug. 17.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment