The private credit management industry is facing a stark reality as it heads into the second half of 2026: the wave of redemptions sweeping through the $1.8 trillion market shows no signs of quickly receding.
Direct lenders are now feeling the full, relentless pressure of this trend, with second-quarter redemption requests often exceeding those from the first quarter.
According to data from Robert A. Stanger & Co., the latest redemption cycle has left over $14.5 billion of investor capital trapped across more than a dozen funds, while shareholders actually received only $8.6 billion.
This effectively means that for every dollar investors sought to withdraw, approximately $1.70 remains locked in.
The industry widely views this latest batch of requests as reflecting, in part, pent-up demand from the previous quarter when many funds imposed 5% withdrawal caps, blocking many investors' exit attempts.
Insiders indicate this cycle is primarily driven by market concerns over asset quality, particularly anxiety about exposure to the software sector, which is being impacted by artificial intelligence.
This pressure is expected to remain elevated until the backlog is cleared.
Michael Covello, a managing director at Robert A. Stanger, stated, "We did anticipate that second-quarter redemptions would rise as investors rotate out of private credit and into tangible assets like real estate and infrastructure."
"We expect it could take up to eight quarters to work through the redemption queue while new fund inflows continue to be subdued."
Blue Owl Capital Inc.'s experience reported Thursday illustrates the significant challenge of quickly reversing this pressure once a large backlog of redemption requests builds up.
The private credit giant reported that investors sought to redeem 18.8% of its roughly $34 billion Blue Owl Credit Income Corp. fund in Q2, while requests hit 38.1% for the smaller Blue Owl Technology Income Corp. fund.
Although these figures are slightly lower than the previous quarter, they remain extremely high compared to major competitors.
According to people familiar with the situation, this is the case despite Blue Owl executives intensifying client communications over the past three months, even flying around the world to meet with investors.
Analysts at Barclays led by Peter Troise echoed concerns about the backlog in a report last week, writing that among the funds they analyzed, new share redemption requests in Q2 actually decreased, likely because unmet investor demand from Q1 was rolled over.
Among the many fund managers witnessing rising redemption demand, Ares Management Corp. last month capped withdrawals from its Strategic Income Fund for a second consecutive quarter after redemption requests rose to 14.4%, up from 11.6% the prior quarter.
Morgan Stanley's $7 billion private credit fund also limited redemptions to 5%, after investors sought to withdraw 11.6% of shares, exceeding the Q1 request level.
Apollo Global Management Inc. capped redemptions on its largest non-traded private credit fund for retail investors after shareholders sought to pull 16.8%, also above the prior quarter's level.
Some institutions were forced to limit redemptions for the first time: Blackstone Inc. capped withdrawals at 5% for its flagship $79 billion private credit fund, BCRED, after investors requested to redeem 10%.
In the prior quarter, the fund took extraordinary measures to meet investor demand to cash out 7.9%, even utilizing cash from its own senior managers to facilitate the redemptions.
There are, of course, exceptions.
Goldman Sachs Group Inc. fulfilled all redemption requests across both quarters and reported that demand decreased in the most recent three-month period.
Redemption requests for a private credit fund at Oaktree Capital Management fell by nearly half in the second quarter.
International Demand Dynamics
Against the backdrop of persistently high redemptions, some fund managers point to another trend: a portion of the incremental demand is coming from outside the United States.
For example, Ares reported that nearly half of the Q2 redemption requests for its Strategic Income Fund came from smaller institutions and family offices primarily based outside the US—a group representing less than 1% of the fund's shareholders.
Apollo detailed a similar geographic disparity in its Apollo Debt Solutions vehicle: domestic redemption requests were stable at 4.3%, while offshore demand climbed to 12.5%.
Meanwhile, Blackstone reported that while overall repurchase requests increased in Q2, the pace of increase slowed towards the end of the offer period, and domestic demand was lower than the prior quarter's level.
Some suggest this could be a strategy of "asking for more than you need."
Eric Kratz, Chief Investment Officer at Arena Private Wealth, explained, "A common tactic for exiting these funds is to request more shares than you actually want when you expect not to get the full amount."
He recalled a former client who transferred a private real estate investment trust to him when a publicly-traded REIT ran into trouble due to interest rate adjustments.
That fund had limited investor withdrawals the previous quarter.
"I wanted to reduce my position by 50%, but I requested 100% for two consecutive quarters and actually reached my goal faster," he said.
Comments