Gold Loses Its Appeal Among Investors

Deep News11-19 14:40

A growing number of investors are now questioning gold's traditional role as a safe-haven asset within investment portfolios: recent months have seen sharp declines in the gold price, even as risk assets such as equities have also suffered heavy sell-offs.

After hitting an all-time high of $5,595 per troy ounce in January this year, gold's market value has shrunk by one-third; on Wednesday the price briefly fell to $3,742 an ounce, the lowest since September 2025.

Since US equity indices peaked in early October, gold has fallen roughly 10% in cumulative terms, while technology stocks have also plunged persistently in recent weeks.

Many bulls have long argued that gold can serve as a safe harbor during broad market turmoil, rising inflation, and mounting sovereign debt risks. But investors who pinned their hopes on this have now been sorely disappointed.

George Cheveley, a fund manager at asset manager Ninety One, said: "Gold is now behaving more like a risk asset than a risk hedge." He added, "This is the exact opposite of what everyone expected—logically, when conditions deteriorate, gold should be a safe-haven asset."

In earlier years gold staged an epic bull run: from around $2,000 an ounce in early 2024 it soared to this year's high. The drivers included sustained central bank buying, as well as a growing wave of speculative money flowing into the gold market through ETFs.

Analysts at investment bank Peel Hunt said this week's drop in the gold price to a new low had "no clear trigger," noting that falling oil prices and lower bond yields should have supported gold. The analysts also mentioned that gold breaking below $3,800 an ounce could mean investors are beginning panic selling (capitulation), which has also raised concerns: market sentiment is collapsing, and more and more investors believe they must close positions and move to the sidelines until the new year.

John Reade, a strategist for the Asia and Europe markets at the World Gold Council, believes that gold's weakness this year is "mainly caused by leveraged speculators and short-term traders in the West"—money that entered when the gold price was rising rapidly and exits quickly once the economic environment shifts.

Helen Amos, a managing director and commodity analyst at BMO, said some investors have argued that gold can no longer serve as a diversifying asset within an equity portfolio. She said a fund manager told her last week that gold "no longer plays a risk-diversification role because it is now positively correlated with risk assets; and given the violent swings in the gold price over the past 12 months, it cannot be considered a safe-haven asset either."

Investors hoping for a return of the "debasement trade" have also been disappointed. The so-called debasement trade refers to traders selling sovereign currencies such as the US dollar and instead allocating to physical assets like gold to protect against inflation eroding wealth. Although inflation remains stubbornly high in major economies, gold has been under pressure since the outbreak of the Iran conflict in February and the start of a new rate-hiking cycle. Gold itself generates no interest, and rising US Treasury yields and interest rates are typically bearish for gold; since gold is priced in dollars, a stronger dollar is also unfavorable for gold. In addition, oil prices—a key driver of inflation this year—have moved inversely to gold.

Reade of the World Gold Council said the debasement trade and de-dollarization logic that supported gold last year "have not disappeared." "It's just that the impact of the Iran conflict has overshadowed these logics: the conflict pushed up energy prices, lifted inflation, and in turn pushed up interest rates and market rate-hike expectations. That drained the momentum for gold to rise."

But recently the linkage between gold and rate expectations appears to have broken down as well: even as market expectations for rate cuts heat up, the gold price remains weak, leaving gold bulls struggling to explain the current market action. One hedge fund investor described the recent gold price movement as "puzzling." Some analysts believe the recent weakness in AI technology stocks has forced some investors to sell gold to top up margin on equity positions.

Suki Cooper, global head of commodity research at Standard Chartered, said gold currently has two characteristics: first, it is a liquidity-provision tool, a feature that is especially evident during periods of tech-stock panic and equity market pullbacks; second, the gold price still moves with real and nominal yields, which in the short term raises the opportunity cost of holding gold.

Even so, some long-term investors remain bullish on gold. Cheveley of Ninety One noted that central bank demand for gold remains strong. Amos said the debasement trade is now "temporarily dormant," "but it will definitely make a comeback, because government debt levels across countries continue to rise." Cooper believes gold "will only regain upward momentum once it sheds its role as a liquidity-provision tool," and she remains optimistic about gold's long-term outlook. Cheveley said a recovery in the gold price "may still take some time." But he said: "Looking at the geopolitical situation, US fiscal debt, central bank gold buying, and the willingness of various countries to increase gold reserves, these forces supporting buying are all still there."

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment