Yen Caught in Tug-of-War as Market Forces Collide: Goldman Bets on Rebound While Morgan Stanley Predicts Slide to 162

Stock News11-16 11:38

With the USD/JPY exchange rate once again approaching the critical 160 mark, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs have offered sharply contrasting views on the yen's trajectory. This underscores how increasingly difficult it has become to forecast the Japanese currency's path amid multiple competing forces.

Morgan Stanley strategists, including Serena Tang, argue that the yen will weaken to 162 against the dollar by the fourth quarter of 2027. They believe that strong global risk appetite, Japan's terms of trade, and the continued appeal of carry trades will ultimately outweigh the support that narrowing interest rate differentials provide to the yen.

However, Goldman Sachs strategists, including Kamakshya Trivedi, take the opposite view. They expect the yen to appreciate throughout 2027 as its "severely undervalued condition begins to fade." Goldman forecasts that the USD/JPY rate will reach 158, 155, and 150 in three months, six months, and one year respectively. The bank's preferred fair value measure indicates that the yen is undervalued by approximately 30% against the dollar.

These diametrically opposed views highlight multiple conflicting forces that have made the yen exceptionally difficult to trade this year. The Bank of Japan is raising interest rates at the fastest pace in decades, yet Japanese rates remain below those of the United States, and capital continues to flow overseas. Meanwhile, concerns about intervention and speculation that Japanese institutions may eventually repatriate more funds are making shorting the yen increasingly risky.

As of press time, the USD/JPY exchange rate stands at 159.70. Last week, the pair briefly breached this closely watched threshold and broke out of a narrow trading range that had persisted for several months. As markets increasingly bet that the Federal Reserve will accelerate monetary tightening to curb inflation, the dollar has strengthened, pressuring the yen.

Morgan Stanley ultimately expects the forces suppressing the yen to prevail. Although converging short-term interest rates between the US and Japan should provide some support for the yen, the bank believes global risk appetite, terms of trade, and carry trades will have a greater impact. It also notes that markets may continue to view the BOJ as "behind the curve," thereby limiting the boost that rising domestic rates provide to the yen.

Meanwhile, Goldman Sachs believes that the BOJ's adjustment to quarterly rate hikes has already eliminated some of the inflation premium that previously weighed on Japanese assets. The bank's economists expect the BOJ to raise rates three more times, by 25 basis points each, bringing the policy rate to 2% by June 2027. By contrast, current market pricing implies a rate of approximately 1.75%.

The prospect of Japanese capital potentially returning home also supports Goldman's bullish yen view, though the bank acknowledges that this shift remains "more of a possibility than a reality" at present. Goldman's preferred flow measure tracks capital flows from investors holding unhedged overseas asset exposure. This indicator shows that demand for overseas assets has generally strengthened this year, with no clear signs of rotation as of October.

Nevertheless, Goldman still considers the prospect that the Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF) may eventually adjust its investment allocation to be significant, as such a move could send a signal to other investors. Combined with potential further currency intervention and a more hawkish policy stance from the BOJ, these factors reinforce Goldman's assessment that downside risks exist for the USD/JPY exchange rate.

The yen is becoming increasingly difficult to trade

After a year of extreme volatility, what has surprised traders is that the yen has gradually stabilized within a narrow range of 158 per dollar in recent months. But last week, the yen broke out of this range once again, unexpectedly falling below the critical 160 threshold before rebounding on speculation that Japanese officials would step in to support the currency.

The yen's sudden swings underscore just how difficult Japan's currency has become to trade. Traditional indicators such as interest rate differentials are no longer reliable guides, while BOJ monetary tightening, persistent capital outflows, and unprecedented currency intervention are pulling the yen in conflicting directions.

The implications extend far beyond Japan itself. The yen is one of the world's most heavily traded currencies, with approximately $1.6 trillion in daily transactions. Its movements can determine the success or failure of global investors' positions, and its long-term trajectory affects everything from Japanese inflation to the flow of the nation's massive savings into overseas markets.

The correlation between the yen and US-Japan rate differentials has collapsed

Rajeev De Mello, global macro portfolio manager at Gama Asset Management SA, which manages approximately 600 million Swiss francs in assets, said: "The problem is that these competing forces make the timing and magnitude of yen moves much harder to predict. I have therefore reduced my yen positions to reflect greater uncertainty."

There are compelling reasons to buy the yen — the BOJ is raising rates at the fastest pace since 1990, domestic yields are near multi-decade highs, and officials in both Tokyo and Washington have shown willingness to intervene when the yen depreciates too rapidly.

But the case for selling the yen is equally strong. Japanese rates remain far below those of the US and other major economies, and some investors believe the BOJ is tightening too slowly to close the gap. This keeps carry trades attractive, while Japanese corporations, institutions, and households continue to allocate substantial capital overseas.

Views on the yen's long-term direction are clearly divided. James Athey of Marlborough Investment Management expects significant yen appreciation, while Lei Zhu of Fidelity International sees further depreciation as the greater risk. Some investors have chosen to stay out entirely. David Clewell of T. Rowe Price Group Inc. has long avoided holding yen positions, while Carol Lye of Brandywine Global Investment Management has avoided trading USD/JPY this year, opting instead to trade the yen against the euro.

The yen has proven equally challenging for policymakers to manage. Japanese Finance Minister Katayama Satsuki led an intervention effort in late July aimed at establishing a floor for the yen. US Treasury Secretary Bessent also offered support, committing a smaller amount of funds but staking a considerable portion of his personal credibility on backing the yen.

This year, Japan has spent a record 27.1 trillion yen (approximately $169.7 billion) buying yen, nearly three times the combined total of the country's trade deficit and direct investment outflows. The intervention helped the yen rebound from a 40-year low near 164 in July, but the currency has since given back most of those gains.

Japan's yen intervention scale has surged, while capital outflows continue

A persistently weak yen drives up import costs, squeezes household spending, and complicates Prime Minister Takaichi Sanae's efforts to promote economic recovery. This also helps explain why Tokyo has repeatedly stepped in to support the yen.

Masahiko Loo, chief fixed income strategist at State Street Investment Management, said markets should not underestimate authorities' ability to forcefully curb one-sided currency moves, but intervention has limitations. He stated: "Intervention can slow currency movements, but it rarely changes the fundamental direction of a currency on its own."

Decades ago, the yen was closely tied to Japan as an export powerhouse. At that time, Japanese manufacturers earned foreign exchange by selling cars and electronics globally. Subsequently, Japan entered an era of zero interest rates, and the nation's massive savings flowed overseas in pursuit of returns, making the yen the preferred funding currency for global carry trades.

In theory, Japan's exit from zero interest rate policy should favor yen appreciation, as it would reduce the incentive to borrow yen cheaply and invest overseas. But decades of cheap money have allowed Japan to accumulate 811 trillion yen in overseas securities assets, and long-established patterns of overseas investment may be difficult to reverse.

Fidelity's Lei Zhu believes that Japan's transition to a mature creditor economy has created structural headwinds for the yen. She noted that pension funds, insurance companies, and households continue to invest heavily in overseas assets; unless Japanese yields become clearly attractive, even if rising JGB yields prompt some repatriation, it is unlikely to offset these outflows.

Even record capital inflows have failed to strengthen the yen. From January to October this year, overseas investors purchased a cumulative 34.5 trillion yen worth of Japanese bonds and stocks, setting a historical record for the same period, yet the yen remained weak. Citigroup strategists believe one reason may be that foreign investors are hedging part of their Japanese equity exposure by selling yen.

Foreign investors are buying Japanese assets at a record pace

The biggest question facing the new era of the yen is whether Japanese capital will finally begin to stay at home. Some initial signs of change have already emerged. This year, Japanese investors have been net sellers of 689 billion yen in foreign stocks and bonds, reversing last year's net purchases of 12.5 trillion yen. Meanwhile, domestic JGB yields are near multi-decade highs, the Japanese stock market is performing strongly, and corporate reforms are improving the outlook for shareholder returns.

But these factors alone are not enough to trigger a large-scale return to domestic assets. Masayuki Nakajima, senior strategist at Mizuho Bank in London, said: "The issue is not valuation but uncertainty. Many institutions remain concerned that yields could rise further if inflation, market expectations for BOJ tightening, or fiscal concerns intensify."

Moreover, the reversal in securities investment flows does not mean Japan has stopped exporting capital. This year, Japanese companies invested 11.9 trillion yen overseas through direct investment, excluding reinvested earnings, as they continue to expand business operations beyond the domestic market.

The Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF) is a closely watched case, and although there is speculation that it may shift more funds toward domestic assets, its investment allocation remained largely unchanged in the most recent quarter.

For Tokyo, the yen issue is growing in importance. As Japan enters a new era of inflation and higher interest rates, the yen is becoming an increasingly significant variable. Persistent yen weakness could complicate the BOJ's monetary policy normalization process and add further pressure to an already volatile bond market.

James McAlevey, head of global aggregate and absolute return at BNP Paribas Asset Management, said: "If the yen strengthens somewhat, it would help control overall inflation and also help manage long-end bond yields."

Washington also has its own considerations. Japan is the largest foreign holder of US government debt, and if Japan intervenes further unilaterally in currency markets, Tokyo may need to sell some of its US Treasury holdings. Earlier this year, the US jointly intervened with Japan in currency markets, reducing the need for Japan to sell US Treasuries and limiting the risk of additional upward pressure on US Treasury yields.

Meanwhile, for investors, no clear trading opportunity is currently visible. Maxence Visseau, chief investment officer at Arkevium Capital in Dubai, said that after the joint US-Japan currency intervention in July, yen movements have become "almost unpredictable." He said: "I am happy to stay on the sidelines for now. I suspect I am not alone in thinking this way."

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment