Conflict Premium Gradually Unwinds, Focus Shifts to Downside Support for Oil Prices

Deep News14:31

This week, oil prices continued to trade in a relatively low range, with the market's pricing of geopolitical de-escalation clearly weighing on crude, pushing prices lower for a third consecutive week. SC, along with WTI and Brent, all touched price lows not seen since the end of August.

Looking at the current market situation, although the geopolitical risk premium has clearly been given back, it remains the single most dominant factor affecting oil prices. On the U.S. side, following the release of the midterm election results, the market's expectations for a resumption of military action have dropped significantly, which has fundamentally reduced the support that geopolitical factors provide to oil prices. That said, while the U.S. has not yet made a clear assessment of the ceasefire terms proposed by Iran, and Trump and Vance had previously stated that Iran's conditions would not be accepted, the market's reaction has clearly become desensitized, and oil prices no longer rebound in response to U.S. statements on the international situation. It is not difficult to see from this that the market's pricing inclination toward the Middle East geopolitical situation has gradually shifted away from the U.S. attitude, which differs from the earlier standoff between the two sides.

Meanwhile, this week Trump visited China, joining China and Russia in expressing support for a peace vision, and publicly stated that he would not consider military action against Iran before January 1. This may mean that, from the U.S. perspective, the geopolitical dispute with Iran is gradually drawing to a close, which could lead to further unwinding of the geopolitical risk premium going forward.

On the Iranian side, Iran continues to maintain its previously proposed demands regarding the ceasefire agreement, namely that until the U.S. ensures its international rights are guaranteed, the issues of strait passage and nuclear resource handling remain deferred discussion items. In the current situation, Iran's stance has shown no effective softening, and oil tankers have periodically struck mines and come under attack in the strait. These developments have indirectly caused oil prices to see small rebounds in the near term. It is evident from this that Iran's blockade of the strait is currently becoming a strong source of support beneath oil prices.

It is also worth noting that Iran explicitly mentioned in the earlier ceasefire agreement its intention to establish a systematic toll system for the Strait of Hormuz, and had previously indicated that two coastal states had reached transit agreements with Iran. This may mean that future passage through the strait is highly unlikely to simply return to the free-transit conditions that existed before the conflict erupted. More likely, it will become a situation where Iran collects tolls, which could cause the center of gravity for oil prices to rise to some extent even if the geopolitical situation does indeed de-escalate as expected.

At the same time, in other parts of the Middle East, with the results of Israel's parliamentary elections now out, although Netanyahu will most likely not remain in power, his successor Eisenkot also maintains a hardline diplomatic and military stance, and there is currently no sign of reconciliation with neighboring Islamic countries. This may mean that after Israel's parliamentary restructuring is completed, Israel's military action plans could once again have a significant impact on the Middle East geopolitical situation.

Moreover, the Houthi armed group's control over the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait had also escalated further earlier. With the withdrawal of Yemen's southern government, the entire Bab-el-Mandeb Strait is now fully under Houthi control. This means that Saudi Arabia's east-west pipeline transportation route has once again been gripped by the throat, producing an outcome clearly consistent with Iran's blockade of the Strait of Hormuz. Considering that the dispute between Saudi Arabia and the Houthi armed group shows no sign of cooling, this may mean that even if strait passage is gradually restored later, Saudi Arabia's export situation could still be hindered, which would further support the center of gravity for oil prices.

On the whole, even though the geopolitical situation's impact on oil prices has clearly cooled recently and the market's sensitivity to war news has become blunted, the political attribute remains a stronger force on oil prices than the financial and commodity attributes. In particular, considering that the ceasefire agreement between the U.S. and Iran has yet to see effective progress and that the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait has come under further Houthi control, this may mean that even if the geopolitical factor is expected to cool in the near term, the market may need to remain more cautiously vigilant about downside support for oil prices. However, given the U.S.'s public statements and the official positions of major economic and political bodies, the possibility of another large-scale escalation of the Middle East war has also clearly diminished. Even if small-scale conflicts erupt again, their impact on crude oil prices is expected to weaken at the margin.

Therefore, oil prices in the near term may continue to run in a wide range, with the center of gravity possibly gradually declining as the geopolitical narrative cools, but there may be certain supporting forces beneath. On the futures side, it is advisable to focus on range-trading strategies; previous bearish positions can continue to be held but position sizing should be controlled to avoid chasing shorts when news flow fluctuates repeatedly. On the options side, the strategy of buying out-of-the-money options on both sides can be continued to address the risk of amplified volatility caused by repeated news swings. For reference only.

Author bio: Fan Lei, analyst at Chang'an Futures, master's degree, futures trading consulting certificate number: Z0021225, with solid theoretical foundations and an international perspective; since entering the futures industry, has been dedicated to research and analysis of the macro and crude oil-related energy and chemicals sector and options, skilled at starting from fundamental analysis, combining policy-oriented theory to build analytical frameworks for making judgments on market conditions, and insisting on creating value for clients with professional knowledge and a sincere attitude.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment