A common promotional tactic involves offering "free insurance" as a benefit, but consumers should be cautious of automatic renewal clauses hidden behind these "free" offers.
Attractive slogans such as "Free to claim" or "First month starting at 0.01 yuan" often entice users to click. However, behind these "first month free" or "bargain-price" advertisements often lies an automatic renewal agreement lasting a year or longer. Social media platforms are filled with complaints from users who report being "charged for insurance premiums for several months without explanation" or "unknowingly signed up for insurance."
Investigations reveal that in recent years, misleading insurance sales and hidden fees have become major sources of consumer complaints in the insurance sector. Many complaints originate from promotions that attract clicks with "first month free" or "low initial cost" offers, which then automatically convert to higher-priced plans in subsequent months. Consumers often find themselves charged continuously without clear prior consent. When attempting to seek refunds or file complaints, many discover that proving their lack of awareness is difficult, and the process of recovering fees is lengthy and complicated.
One consumer, Ms. Li, reported discovering three separate deductions of 363 yuan each from her father’s bank account. The payments were made to Taikang Online Property Insurance Co., Ltd. through the JD.com platform, totaling 1,089 yuan. Ms. Li emphasized that her father had never purchased insurance, provided authorization, or signed any agreement. The deductions occurred without even requiring a payment password for confirmation.
After contacting customer service representatives from both JD Finance and Taikang Online, Ms. Li was asked whether her father had clicked on an advertisement link. She argued that even if an ad was clicked, entering a payment password should be required—which did not happen. After persistent follow-up, Taikang Online’s customer service agreed to a full refund but did not clarify what insurance product the deductions were for.
In addition to the 1,089 yuan refund, a small deduction of 0.6 yuan was also observed. Based on similar complaints on social media, this minor charge likely resulted from clicking on a low-cost insurance product link used for customer acquisition.
Similar complaints are frequent on the Black Cat Complaint platform. Many consumers report encountering offers like "free insurance," "first month free," or "first month for 1 yuan" during online shopping or through ads. Many later realize they had inadvertently authorized recurring payments, with insufficient notification before deductions. Only upon reviewing transaction records do they notice regular monthly deductions of tens or even hundreds of yuan from their accounts.
In online insurance marketing, it is not uncommon to use "free" or "first month free" promotions to attract customers. Key terms such as "standard premium rates from the second month onward" and "automatic renewal" are often placed in less visible sections or simplified during the sign-up process. This allows insurance companies to repeatedly deduct premiums from users’ payment accounts through pre-authorized debit agreements, often without clear, recurring confirmation from the consumer.
As early as 2023, regulatory authorities issued a notice to insurance companies titled "Further Regulating Short-Term Health Insurance Business," emphasizing that product pricing must be scientifically sound and based on actuarial data. It strictly prohibited premium structures that clearly violate actuarial principles, such as offering "zero premium" policies.
For example, an insurance product advertised on the JD.com platform as "JD Insurance·Million Medical Coverage with up to 6 million yuan coverage, free trial for 30 days" prominently displays "30-day free trial, cancel anytime without charge." However, on the "Agree and Apply" page, details about post-trial charges are shown in less noticeable gray text, stating that if not canceled after 30 days, automatic premium deductions will begin—23.2 yuan for the first paid month, followed by 12 monthly payments.
Article 10 of the "Implementing Regulations of the Consumer Rights Protection Law" stipulates that businesses using automatic renewal or extension services must clearly notify consumers before service begins and before each renewal date. However, many "free insurance" promotions bury automatic renewal terms in fine print, pre-checked boxes, or lengthy agreements, failing to provide adequate notice and potentially infringing on consumer rights.
On JD.com’s official insurance store, policies labeled as "starting from 0.01 yuan" are available, covering areas such as major medical insurance and pet insurance. During the application process, no payment password is required at the time of enrollment, and no fee is charged initially. If a user chooses monthly payments divided over 12 installments, they must agree to a "Premium Installment Service Agreement." This agreement authorizes JD Insurance Brokerage (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. to instruct NetBank Online (Beijing) Technology Co., Ltd. to deduct premiums from the user’s JD account each month, which are then forwarded to the insurance provider. Thus, enrolling in such "free insurance" requires no immediate payment or password. However, if the user does not manually cancel after the 30-day free period, monthly deductions will begin automatically.
This "frictionless enrollment" model relies on automatic renewal mechanisms that are only compliant under strict conditions. Insurance providers should, in theory, ensure the following throughout the sales process: First, clearly disclose automatic post-trial charges and amounts on each key page using pop-ups or highlighted text. Second, include a separate confirmation step where consumers actively authorize automatic payments, with no pre-checked options. Third, send advance reminders via SMS or app notifications before deductions occur, and provide clear and easy cancellation methods throughout the service period. In practice, however, these conditions are often not fully met, leading to frequent consumer disputes.
Comments