The second-hand trendy toys trading platform Qiandao is facing controversy over its "Lucky Bag" feature. Similar to card-unpacking activities in live streams, Lucky Bags are probabilistic games where players wager small amounts for a chance at high-value returns, with profitability relying solely on luck. One player shared records indicating losses exceeding 650,000 yuan across four accounts used for the feature, describing the experience as increasingly addictive and financially damaging.
This player's situation is not unique. On social media platforms, numerous users have posted their loss records, expressing that after trying Qiandao's Lucky Bags, they became obsessed with recouping losses, leading to deficits totaling tens of thousands of yuan. Many players question the fairness of the probability mechanics, suggesting the feature closely resembles gambling.
In response, Qiandao's customer service stated that Lucky Bag draws are entirely random, assured the reliability of their randomization service, and emphasized regular rigorous testing. The platform firmly denied adjusting probabilities or manipulating outcomes.
Legal experts commented that the described activities, involving substantial monetary amounts and occurring outside casual entertainment among relatives or friends, exhibit characteristics of gambling.
While users incur losses, the platform generates steady revenue. Founder Shen Zhenyu has previously described Qiandao's trading functions as a means to build an interest-based community, aspiring for the platform to become a "spiritual home" for enthusiasts. However, for many consumers engrossed in Lucky Bags, the platform feels less like a home and more like a trap consuming their time and money.
Months after initial allegations that the Lucky Bag feature involved gambling, it remains accessible via the platform's homepage search. The feature operates under Qiandao's "Flash Purchase" system, allowing users to combine items from their platform storage into bundles with set rules. Lucky Bags function as blind-box style draws, with each card corresponding to a second-hand item consigned by a user. Previewed items show significant value disparities, ranging from limited-edition trendy toys and cards worth thousands of yuan to ordinary items far below the Lucky Bag's price.
For example, one user's Lucky Bag contained 20 items with a draw price of 49.33 yuan each, and an initial promotional price of 44.4 yuan for the first five draws. The total cost to draw all items would be 961.95 yuan, whereas the combined market price of the items is only 739 yuan, indicating players often pay more than the actual value.
Additionally, platform rules require buyers to pay shipping fees to receive physical items from Qiandao's storage or wait six hours to resell drawn items. The platform collects a 2% service fee and a 0.6% payment processing fee on all transactions, ensuring revenue regardless of user outcomes.
To attract users, high-value items are included in Lucky Bags, with higher-priced bundles offering better potential returns. Promotional discounts on initial draws also serve as enticements. One blind box example featured a top prize valued at 4,659 yuan, offering a potential 25-fold return if drawn at the promotional price of 180 yuan, while lower-value items result in immediate losses.
One seasoned player reported 761 transactions with over 15,000 yuan invested in Lucky Bags but only approximately 13,000 yuan in returns, resulting in a 2,000 yuan deficit. Another user described a cycle of addiction, repeatedly returning to the feature despite intentions to quit, losing 15,000 yuan over two days in one instance and nearly 7,000 yuan in another.
Beyond gambling concerns, counterfeit goods have become a major issue for consumers. One buyer reported receiving items with stains and reversed logos, later verified as fake via anti-counterfeit codes, but was unable to resolve the issue with the seller or customer service due to a lack of unboxing video evidence. Another customer discovered a purchased item was counterfeit after a platform authentication check, expressing disappointment over paying a premium for a fake product.
Customer service challenges are prevalent, as Qiandao lacks a phone support channel, relying instead on a queued online system primarily handled by an AI chatbot. The platform's "suggestions" feature requires purchase details and proof for potential human agent access, complicating issue resolution.
According to Tianyancha App, Qiandao's parent company, Shanghai Biyou Huixiang Intelligent Technology, has completed three funding rounds with support from prominent investors like Gaorong Capital, BAI Capital, and Xianfeng Changqing, indicating market confidence. However, as user numbers and transaction volumes grow, the platform's quality control, customer service, and after-sales support infrastructure have not kept pace.
On consumer complaint platforms, Qiandao has accumulated over 10,271 complaints, with users highlighting issues including counterfeit goods, defective products, and poor售后服务. An industry analyst noted the inherent challenges in authenticating second-hand trendy toys, especially with special editions flooding the market. The analyst suggested that platforms must move beyond "safe harbor" principles and implement proactive监管 mechanisms, such as AI visual recognition, to ensure sustainability and user trust amid the growing "Guzi Economy" trend.
Comments