Recent international precious metals markets have experienced historic volatility, with gold and silver prices plummeting dramatically within just a few days. Under such extreme market conditions, some exchange-traded funds (ETFs) related to the precious metals sector have exhibited significant deviations between their market prices and net asset values. This analysis will delve into the distinctions between ETF discounts during sharp sell-offs, starting from the fund's pricing mechanisms and arbitrage logic.
Sharp price corrections have shifted market sentiment from extreme exuberance to panic. When this sentiment transmits to the ETF market, it can cause a notable divergence between the secondary market trading price and the fund's indicative optimized portfolio value (IOPV). A discount refers to the scenario where: The secondary market trading price of an ETF is less than its current net asset value per share (IOPV). In theory, buying a discounted ETF is akin to "purchasing assets at a low price," with potential profits realized once the price converges back to the net asset value. However, during periods of extreme volatility, the causes of a discount are complex and can be primarily categorized into two types: 01 Liquidity Discount (Panic Selling) Panic selling, where investors sell regardless of cost, causes the ETF's price to fall more sharply than the actual decline of its underlying assets. 02 Mechanical/Passive Discount (Artificial Discount) A "paper discount" caused by factors such as price limits, trading hour mismatches, or futures contract structures.
In high-volatility environments, discounts in the following three types of ETFs often conceal significant risks, and retail investors should avoid blindly "buying the dip." 01 Passive Discount Caused by "Daily Limit Down" (Liquidity Trap) For example, if an ETF hits its daily downside limit, but only some of its underlying constituent stocks are restricted by price limits and are at their "limit-down" price, the ETF's overall reference net asset value decline might be less than 10%. While the ETF price appears discounted relative to its NAV, this discount essentially represents the market pricing in an expected further decline for the constituent stocks the next day. Buying the ETF in this situation does not constitute a genuine arbitrage opportunity. 02 "Time Zone Discount" in Cross-Border/QDII ETFs Periods of high volatility for major overseas assets often occur during European and American trading hours (after the A-share market has closed). Due to trading hour mismatches and exchange rate fluctuations, the calculation of the IOPV may lag. An apparent "discount" you see on an ETF tracking overseas assets might simply be because the IOPV has not yet fully reflected the latest overnight plunge in foreign markets. 03 "Structural Discount" in Futures-based ETFs Domestic silver ETFs and some commodity ETFs do not hold physical assets directly but instead hold futures contracts (e.g., silver futures, soybean meal futures). When commodity markets are characterized by "high volatility and high open interest," futures contracts for distant months are typically more expensive than near-month contracts. To maintain its positions, the ETF manager must continuously engage in a "sell low, buy high" rollover process, which naturally erodes the fund's net asset value over time.
During the volatile consolidation and recovery phase following a sharp decline, discounts on ETFs with physical backing and transparent mechanisms represent genuine arbitrage or allocation opportunities. For instance, some ETFs support T+0 trading and cash/physical creation/redemption. If panic selling during the trading day causes the price to fall significantly below the IOPV, arbitrage capital can execute a near-risk-free arbitrage. This mechanism ensures that such discounts are typically corrected rapidly. When market panic leads retail investors to sell ETFs indiscriminately, momentarily driving the price below net asset value, it may present opportunities for short-term rebounds or arbitrage.
Disclaimer Investors are advised to pay close attention to the risk-return characteristics of their investment targets and make prudent investment decisions based on an appropriate match with their own risk tolerance. All investments carry risk, and caution is required when entering the market! The content contained herein is for reference use only by clients of Tianfeng Securities Co., Ltd. Tianfeng Securities will not regard recipients of this content as clients by virtue of their receipt thereof. If this content is an abstract of a report issued by Tianfeng Research, it merely represents a brief summary of the research views, and clients should still refer to the formally released full report by Tianfeng and the interpretations provided by professional investment advisors for conclusive guidance. Under no circumstances does the information contained herein or the opinions expressed constitute investment advice to any person. Tianfeng Securities assumes no legal liability for any consequences or losses arising from the direct or indirect use of this content or investments made based thereon. Anyone wishing to quote or reprint this content must clearly cite the source and must not make references or alterations that distort the original intent.
Comments