Fed Chair Warsh said on Monday that the rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology could deliver a productivity surge and sustained growth for the U.S. economy, but it could also trigger mass unemployment, or even lead to a stock market decline and an economic slowdown if investment returns fall short of expectations.
He stressed that the economic impact of AI remains highly uncertain, and the Federal Reserve must prepare for different scenarios while assessing their potential implications for future monetary policy. Notably, Warsh's remarks did not directly address recent monetary policy, nor did they send any new signals about the Fed's future rate path. The three major U.S. stock indexes extended their intraday losses, with the Nasdaq ending down 2.49% and the S&P 500 closing 1.92% lower.
Warsh delivered the speech at a productivity and employment conference hosted by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, where he outlined three AI development scenarios currently being studied by Fed staff. He noted that AI could become an entirely new economic and social force, with effects unlike previous technological revolutions, particularly in its unique potential to accelerate knowledge creation and the formation of new ideas. He used the term "Super Intelligence" rather than the traditional "artificial intelligence." This phrasing aligns with an executive order signed by U.S. President Trump in September, which requires federal agencies to use "Super Intelligence" and its abbreviation "SI" in official communications.
In the most optimistic scenario, Warsh believes widespread adoption of AI technology will significantly boost labor productivity, allowing businesses and workers to share the fruits of economic growth, thereby pushing U.S. real gross domestic product (GDP) growth sustainably above its long-term average while maintaining near-full employment. This scenario is consistent with Warsh's previous optimistic assessments of AI. He has repeatedly said that AI-driven productivity gains could ease inflationary pressure while promoting economic growth, creating a more favorable long-term environment for the U.S. economy.
However, Warsh also warned that AI-driven productivity gains may not translate into broad employment growth. In the second scenario, companies could sharply reduce their need for human labor through automation technology, displacing a large number of jobs. Even if overall economic activity increases, the unemployment rate could still rise markedly.
The third scenario is even more alarming for financial markets: AI technology ultimately fails to deliver the high growth expectations that investors and companies have placed in it. Warsh pointed out that with companies already committing enormous capital and stock markets having surged on the AI investment boom, if the expected returns on related projects begin to decline, stock valuations could fall in turn, triggering an economic slowdown and a significant rise in unemployment. He said: "After massive capital investment and a stock market rally, expected returns may decline, and stock valuations may also fall, leading to an economic slowdown and a more pronounced rise in unemployment." Warsh added that in such a case, the economy would eventually recover, but the previously anticipated productivity gains might not materialize.
In recent years, the development prospects of AI technology have driven technology stock valuations ever higher and prompted companies to raise funds through equity and debt financing to support data centers, computing infrastructure and related technology research and development. The third scenario raised by Warsh highlights the market's potential concerns about the sustainability of AI investment returns and valuations. However, he emphasized that the three scenarios are not the Fed's formal forecasts for the future economic trajectory, but rather tools to help policymakers understand the different outcomes technological change might bring. "Our job is to be prepared for whatever may happen in the future," Warsh said, noting that the Fed's role on this issue is neither advocate nor opponent, but rather to recognize that the widespread adoption of new technology will have a major impact on the economy and could significantly influence future monetary policy. He pointed out that the most critical question now is the degree, scope and timing of AI's impact on the economy.
In fact, the economic impact of the AI boom is already beginning to show, but short-term effects may differ from long-term expectations. Warsh previously believed that AI-driven productivity growth could boost economic expansion while curbing inflation. However, at an International Monetary Fund event in Bangkok in October, he acknowledged that sharp price increases for materials and other inputs needed for AI infrastructure construction were putting pressure on overall inflation. He noted at the time that the AI investment boom clearly stimulated economic demand first, while its positive supply-side effects would take longer to emerge.
The latest data show that U.S. labor productivity grew at an annualized rate of 3.6% in the third quarter, the fastest pace in a year. However, economists believe AI's direct contribution to productivity improvement is still relatively limited at present. This means that although AI may improve economic efficiency over the long term, before large-scale technology investment translates into actual productivity growth, related capital spending could also drive up resource demand and prices, making monetary policy formulation more complicated.
To study these issues in depth, Warsh announced after becoming Fed Chair in June the creation of five working groups led by external experts to examine productivity and employment, the Fed's communication approach, data dependence, balance sheet policy and the inflation framework. Among them, the working group responsible for studying AI's impact on productivity and employment is led by well-known venture capitalist and Andreessen Horowitz co-founder Marc Andreessen. Members also include Microsoft (MSFT.US) Xbox CEO Asha Sharma and Stanford University scholar Charles Jones.
Monday's conference brought together technology executives, economists, academics and Fed officials to discuss AI's potential impact on U.S. economic growth, the labor market and productivity. Attendees included Fed Governor Cook, Stanford University economist Nick Bloom, and Palo Alto Networks (PANW.US) Chairman and CEO Nikesh Arora. Some participants argued that the United States' speed advantage in adopting new technology could help its economy continue to lead other countries. However, some experts worried that students' overreliance on AI tools could weaken their ability to learn independently.
Warsh previously said the working groups are expected to put forward policy recommendations by the end of this year, which will then be studied by the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the body responsible for monetary policy decisions. He said AI is pushing the economy into a new stage of development, but whether it will ultimately bring stronger growth, a more severe employment shock, or a market correction after a wave of unmet investment expectations remains uncertain. For the Fed, how to identify the true impact of this technological transformation on economic growth, employment and inflation will become a major challenge in formulating monetary policy going forward.
Comments