Federal Judge Allows Antitrust Case Against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to Proceed Over Alleged Memory Supply Conspiracy

Deep News11-16 21:24

A federal judge has ruled that a class action accusing three major memory chipmakers of conspiring to restrict supply can move forward, a decision that will force Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to disclose internal documents and adds a new legal dimension to persistent market concerns over the abnormal surge in memory prices.

Judge Noël Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California on November 14 denied the three defendants' joint motion to dismiss, ruling that the plaintiffs' complaint sufficiently stated a claim for conspiracy in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The three companies must file their answers by December 7, after which the discovery process will begin. This marks the most significant procedural victory the plaintiffs have achieved to date.

The macro significance of this case far exceeds that of an ordinary antitrust lawsuit.

According to Goldman Sachs economist Megan Peters, AI-driven increases in memory, software and electricity prices have already added more than 0.2 percentage points to core PCE, with a cumulative contribution of 0.5 percentage points expected by year-end. Meanwhile, conventional DRAM prices have risen 697% over 18 months, and the three defendants together account for more than 91% of global DRAM revenue.

Judge Finds "Eagles Flying in Formation," Rejects "Repackaged Lawsuit" Defense

The case was filed on June 25, 2025 by 17 plaintiffs under the name Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics. The plaintiffs include 14 consumers and 3 small PC manufacturers, representing all indirect purchasers of devices containing commercial DRAM. Their claims include class certification, injunctive relief and treble damages.

The three defendants' core defense strategy was to invoke precedent.

A similar lawsuit targeting the 2016-2018 price surge was dismissed in 2020, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that ruling in March 2022 on the grounds that simultaneous production cuts by three competitors constituted normal parallel behavior in an oligopolistic market and did not amount to evidence of collusion. At a September hearing, the defendants argued that the new complaint was merely the same conspiracy theory dressed in AI clothing, and that each company's decisions to cut output, shift to high-bandwidth memory (HBM) and exit DDR4 were independent profit-seeking decisions.

Judge Wise did not accept this. In her ruling, she explicitly stated that the circumstances of this case differ materially from those involved in the Ninth Circuit's 2022 decision, and she declined to dismiss the lawsuit.

During the hearing, the defendants cited the late Judge Richard Posner's argument that oligopolistic competitors observing each other constitutes normal behavior. Wise responded that the conduct described by the plaintiffs "more closely resembles eagles flying in formation"—and formation flying is not a natural habit of eagles. The implication is that monitoring competitors' moves is legal, but moving in lockstep over three years while prices rise eightfold requires an explanation.

Seven "Plus Factors," and a Highly Similar Customer Review Questionnaire

Because parallel conduct is itself legal, the plaintiffs must demonstrate "plus factors"—actions that no rational company would take unilaterally unless it knew its competitors would take the same action. The key timeline laid out in the complaint is as follows:

The three companies successively announced production cuts between late 2022 and 2023, with SK Hynix and Micron about three weeks apart and Samsung following afterward; all three subsequently shifted capacity to HBM and signed long-term supply contracts; within the second quarter of 2025, all three announced their exit from mainstream DDR4 in the same quarter; in December 2025, Micron announced the closure of its consumer memory brand Crucial; and in January 2026, the three companies rolled out customer review questionnaires with highly similar content.

Judge Wise scrutinized each of these factors individually. She dismissed the DDR3-related allegations (Micron still produces DDR3), declined to credit investor conference call comments and industry conference statements, and determined that the oligopolistic market structure itself is a neutral factor and that a mere shift to HBM is insufficient to prove collusion, since HBM carries higher margins.

What truly drew the court's attention were the following points: First, despite enormous room for price increases, none of the three companies meaningfully expanded conventional DRAM capacity, and Samsung and Micron reportedly even delayed or suspended new fab construction; second, all three signed multi-year HBM contracts with AI customers, while Samsung and SK Hynix reportedly refused to offer long-term contracts to large conventional DRAM buyers; third, the same-quarter exit from DDR4 and Micron's abandonment of the Crucial brand were never adequately explained by the defendants; and fourth, the highly similar customer review questionnaires introduced in January 2026 were the circumstance that most concerned the court, with Wise finding that this allegation "strongly supports a reasonable inference of collusion."

The court also rejected the defendants' argument that the 1998-2002 cartel case was too remote in time to be relevant. That case ended in plea agreements, with multiple executives imprisoned and the three companies collectively paying approximately $731 million in fines, while Micron received immunity for reporting its co-conspirators.

Memory Price Surge Has Become a Macro Variable; Goldman Sachs Expects New Supply Unlikely Before 2028

The reason this case has attracted widespread market attention is that the abnormal trajectory of memory prices has permeated the macroeconomic level.

According to Goldman Sachs' Korea technology team (led by Giuni Lee), South Korea's DRAM export value hit another record in October at $34 billion, up 595% year-over-year, with total memory exports up 359% year-over-year, marking the ninth consecutive month of increases exceeding 200%. TrendForce data shows contract prices rose about 80% in the second quarter, about 40% in the third quarter and about 20% in the fourth quarter, with the latest forecasts for PC DRAM and server DRAM at +13% to 18% and +10% to 15% respectively.

After hosting a TrendForce roadshow on October 27, Goldman Sachs maintained its buy ratings on Samsung and SK Hynix and expects meaningful capacity additions to be difficult to achieve before 2028. This judgment is relevant to both sides of the litigation: the defendants will use it to demonstrate that fab construction cycles are lengthy and cleanroom space is limited; the plaintiffs will ask why, given that prices had already surged in 2024, none of the three companies broke ground at that time.

The demand-side shock is equally significant. Citi expects PC shipments to fall 15% this year and smartphone shipments to decline 12%. According to Goldman Sachs' Korea team, Alibaba, Tencent and ByteDance have sought 10-year server DRAM contracts from Samsung and SK Hynix—a move that itself reflects the severe supply-demand imbalance in the market.

Discovery Begins; Chinese Competitors May Offer Supply-Side Relief Before the Courts Do

As for next steps, the defendants must file their answers by December 7, with the first case management conference scheduled for January 12, 2027. After that will come the discovery phase that the defendants have sought to avoid, involving emails, chat records and the document trail behind the three customer review questionnaires. In the 2000s case, it was internal documents and Micron's cooperation with investigators that ultimately laid the foundation for the allegations.

However, two points warrant cautious expectations. First, the standard of review at the motion-to-dismiss stage is merely "plausibility," and if this case ultimately reaches judgment, the same Ninth Circuit will again intervene in its review. Second, even if the plaintiffs prevail, antitrust proceedings operate on a timescale measured in years and are unlikely to provide immediate relief for current price levels and consumers. In terms of deterrence, the total fines in the 2000s cartel case amounted to $731 million, while SK Hynix's single-quarter operating profit is reportedly around 77 trillion won.

Meaningful supply-side relief may come from outside the courtroom first. The CEO of Acer has said that the supply shortage has eased somewhat as Chinese memory maker ChangXin Technology ramps up production; TSMC is reportedly also exploring entry into the memory sector; and Goldman Sachs expects ChangXin Technology's DRAM output to reach half of SK Hynix's by 2028.

For memory stocks currently trading at 2 to 4 times forward earnings, a federal judge's finding that collusion is "reasonably plausible" provides a new interpretative dimension for market doubts about their excess profitability.

Goldman Sachs TMT specialist Peter Callahan noted that memory stock valuations are extremely low, but the market is increasingly concerned about their "excess profitability," and low P/E ratios for cyclical stocks serve as both a bull argument and a bear argument. The DRAM spot price index has climbed from under $5 at the end of 2024 to about $53, while the forward P/E ratios of Micron, Samsung and SK Hynix have fallen to 3.8 times, 2.6 times and 2.2 times respectively.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment