Recently, McDonald's launched a new "1+1" value combo featuring a mix-and-match deal, and enlisted three celebrities—Silence Wang, Xu Zhisheng, and Li Xueqin—to appear in its advertisements. However, due to issues with the celebrities' public personas and their on-camera performances, the resulting posters and promotional videos were criticized as having "no appetite appeal" and for featuring "stars who clearly would never eat this." The BUG column noted that on platforms such as Xiaohongshu, a single post complaining about McDonald's "appetite-killing ads" has already garnered over 4,600 comments. Some consumers even questioned McDonald's for "spending money on celebrity endorsements while making burgers smaller and smaller," arguing the money should be "spent on the burgers themselves." This is not the first time McDonald's has stumbled over promotional content lacking appetite appeal. In March of this year, McDonald's CEO also sparked widespread controversy when tasting his own burgers, drawing criticism for his stiff expression and for apparently spitting out a bite shortly after taking it.
Silence Wang and Xu Zhisheng Endorsements Spark Controversy, Netizens Say "They Clearly Wouldn't Eat It"
Looking at McDonald's promotional content, in one poster where Silence Wang, Xu Zhisheng, and Li Xueqin sit together at a table, each holds a burger or meat wrap and wears a smile, but their gazes neither land on the food nor share a common focal point, appearing unfocused. Notably, due to the image design, some users got the illusion that "the burgers look Photoshopped in," commenting bluntly that there is "no sense of realism at all." One user even pointed to an image of Xu Zhisheng holding up a burger and said: "Xu Zhisheng is holding a burger with his mouth wide open, his expression like he just discovered this thing is actually edible." This series of problems with the shoot and the celebrities' facial expressions made consumers feel that "the burger is just a prop for the stars, and they clearly would never eat it." Subsequently, many consumers began complaining about the "appetite-killing ads," and some netizens dug up the long-running joke about McDonald's burgers "getting smaller and smaller," urging the brand: "Wasting money on celebrities is worse than making the burgers bigger."
The BUG column noted that most of the criticism currently focuses on three points. First, the celebrities' facial expressions were poorly managed. The photos came out too strange, their eyes never focused on the food, and no appetite was conveyed. One user questioned: "They probably didn't even get a burger or fries during the shoot—how are we supposed to believe they'd eat it?" Second, the celebrities' images did not match their personas. Some felt that having the successfully slimmed-down Li Xueqin and the famously thin Silence Wang endorse high-calorie burgers was inconsistent with their public images—like "asking someone who successfully lost weight to persuade you to eat more." Third, McDonald's should focus on the product rather than marketing. Suggestions were made that McDonald's skip celebrity endorsements altogether and use the saved money to make the burgers bigger. Of course, some users paid no attention to the ad content at all, focusing only on "whether Silence Wang looks handsome" or "whether Xu Zhisheng is funny."
Marketing and Food Safety Controversies Keep Piling Up, Over Ten Thousand Complaints Accumulated
In fact, this is not the first time McDonald's has triggered negative public opinion over marketing and promotion. Earlier this year, a video of McDonald's global CEO Chris Kempczinski tasting the new "Big Arch" burger went viral on social media. In the video, he tried to show his love for this "biggest burger in history," but due to his stiff expression and restrained movements, he only symbolically took a small bite before quickly putting it down, which netizens mocked as "a mere skin wound from one bite," triggering a brand trust crisis. At the time, the Harvard-educated CEO referred to the burger throughout the tasting as a "Product" rather than food, chewed with an unnatural expression and showed no enjoyment, which netizens interpreted as physiological resistance and elite detachment. Some netizens even dug up Kempczinski's previous疑似 "fake eating" behavior when tasting other products, further intensifying the brand's PR crisis.
Regarding the celebrity-endorsed value combo being criticized for "no appetite appeal," McDonald's China customer service, in communication with the BUG column, responded: "Thank you for your attention. This issue requires a specialist to answer. Please follow the company's official channels for disclosures."
Beyond marketing controversies, recent major food safety incidents involving McDonald's have also emerged one after another. In July of this year, a McDonald's store in Zhengzhou, Henan (the Qilihe Meijing Fangfei restaurant) was accused by a customer of spitting into a cola drink. The customer, Ms. Zhou, unknowingly drank most of the beverage and only discovered the abnormality afterward, then gathered evidence to defend her rights. It was later found that a McDonald's employee did indeed appear to make a spitting motion. The employee involved was eventually persuaded to resign, and the store is currently operating normally. In the same month, a consumer reported that their child found a blue foreign object embedded in the meat patty while eating a cheesey ham breakfast at a McDonald's in Wuhan (the Dongfang Yayuan store), and the child had already eaten most of it. The child subsequently developed a fever and vomiting and was diagnosed with a respiratory infection. According to staff at the McDonald's store involved, the blue foreign object was a blue glove worn by employees; the employee on duty accidentally brushed the glove against the oven, and the glove melted from the heat and stuck to the meat patty.
On Black Cat Complaints, as of November 10, McDonald's-related complaints had accumulated to 12,475 cases. The top three key risk issues are: first, foreign objects mixed into food; second, account abnormalities preventing orders; third, food quality failing to meet standards.
Conclusion: Rapid Store Expansion Must Be Matched by Quality Control
According to McDonald's latest third-quarter 2026 financial report, in the third quarter, McDonald's global revenue was $7.157 billion, a slight year-on-year increase of 1%, but performance in the Chinese market weakened noticeably. The report shows that McDonald's International Developmental Licensed Markets segment saw overall same-store sales rise 4.2% year-on-year, but within that segment, comparable same-store sales in China declined, reflecting continued pressure on foot traffic and consumer enthusiasm at existing stores. In stark contrast to the weak single-store performance, McDonald's has maintained an aggressive pace of store expansion. By the end of the third quarter of this year, McDonald's total store count in China had reached 8,395, a net increase of 893 stores compared with a year earlier, making it the core market with the fastest global expansion speed and the largest incremental contribution. Against the backdrop of intensifying consumer competition, McDonald's relies on high-density store openings, penetration into lower-tier markets, and low-price combo strategies to maintain overall scale growth, using "new store increments" to offset "old store weakness," which has become the main growth logic at this stage. But large-scale, fast-paced franchise-style expansion also continuously amplifies the brand's operational risks. As the number of stores surges rapidly, the chains of supply chain distribution, regional supervision, back-of-house standardization, and personnel management are continuously stretched. The recent frequent controversies over food safety and back-of-house operational chaos, combined with this round of advertising and marketing backlash, serve as a concentrated manifestation of the quality control system failing to keep up with the pace of scale expansion under rapid growth.
In this regard, an industry analyst, in communication with the BUG column, pointed out that the core competitiveness of fast-food brands has always been standardization and food safety. Celebrity marketing and traffic-driven endorsements can only boost brand topicality in the short term and cannot cover up shortcomings in terminal operations. For McDonald's, there is an urgent need to balance expansion speed with brand reputation. As sluggish foot traffic and high inflation become the norm in the catering industry, existing consumers' demands for food safety, store service, and brand quality continue to rise. If McDonald's continues to prioritize scale over operations and maintenance, allowing food safety issues and negative public opinion to recur, it will ultimately overdraft the brand trust it has accumulated over the long term.
Comments