Warsh Issues Turning Point Warning: AI Revolution Is Forcing the Fed to Rethink the Rate Question

Deep News10:45

The AI revolution is pressing into the heart of the economy, and the Federal Reserve has begun preparing for the shock that may follow.

Fed Chair Kevin Warsh convened a meeting in San Francisco on Monday (November 17) to put the impact of AI on productivity, employment, inflation and interest rates squarely on the table.

He judges that the U.S. economy is at a critical turning point, yet there is still no clear answer on when or how the shift will unfold. The gathering exposed both the Fed's sense of urgency toward new technology and Warsh's desire to draw on outside experts to fill in the central bank's understanding of the AI revolution.

Overall, this was not an ordinary discussion but an attempt by the Fed to figure out what AI truly means before it rewrites the economy.

An Unusual Meeting: Outside Experts Enter the Fed's View

Warsh said at the meeting that "we are at a critical turning point for the U.S. economy." The weight of that statement lies in the fact that it came from the Fed Chair, not from a tech company or a think tank.

The AI working group meeting allowed Warsh to publicly raise the questions Americans will ultimately expect him to answer: whether AI will cause mass white-collar unemployment and whether it will change how prices and interest rates operate.

The article said Warsh hinted at the direction of some of his private views but largely left speculation to the panel of experts. With technology advancing rapidly, he can no longer postpone giving his own answers for long.

At the same time, AI lab Anthropic plans to price its initial public offering on Wednesday, which at a $1.4 trillion valuation could raise as much as $64 billion. Massive spending by AI companies is pushing the Fed to consider a rate hike in December to slow price increases as the tech sector heats up the economy.

On the other side, Americans are growing averse to certain aspects of AI. In the November 3 midterm elections, voters passed a series of state-level measures aimed at slowing construction of data centers essential to powering AI.

A Warsh-Led Effort: Bringing Outside Expertise Into the Fed

The event was unusual for the Fed. The central bank employs a small army of PhD economists who can usually weigh in quickly on almost anything.

But Warsh has long criticized the Fed as insular and outdated, so he chose to bring in expertise from outside the institution to help the Fed think about how AI will affect productivity and employment.

Warsh formed an AI working group and also established four other working groups responsible for different aspects of Fed policymaking. On Monday, Warsh chaired three of the four sessions and took part in selecting speakers.

Among the three formal members of the working group, venture capitalist Marc Andreessen spoke in person. He and Warsh's wife were classmates at Stanford University, and the two have been friends for years.

Stanford University economist Chad Jones is currently on leave working at Anthropic and could not speak due to the company's pre-IPO quiet period. Xbox CEO Asha Sharma did not attend the event.

The meeting also brought in Gina Raimondo, one of the few prominent Democrats willing to publicly oppose the anti-data-center trend. She is a former Commerce Secretary and former Rhode Island governor during the Biden era.

Raimondo said that so many anti-data-center measures passing in the midterms is "a very disturbing sign," and that blocking AI "would be very bad for the United States and for the people who voted for these measures."

Warsh did not say whether he agreed with that view, and it is unclear how it would translate into monetary policy.

The AI Version of the "China Shock": Services in the Spotlight

Andreessen is extremely optimistic about AI as a technology but believes the government will not let Americans fully experience its full effects. He said heavy regulation in sectors such as healthcare and education means technology cannot replace people's jobs in those industries.

Andreessen said that for a free-market economy, one might see the extremely rapid job displacement scenario people talk about, "but we have basically made it illegal by law, that kind of occupational transition that both the fantasists and doomsayers talk about."

Warsh, meanwhile, kept returning to an economic scenario drawn from past experience, the so-called "China shock." After China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001 and surged into low-cost manufacturing, Americans saw clothing and furniture prices fall rapidly, but at the cost of severe unemployment.

A widely cited estimate found that in the following years the U.S. lost 1 million manufacturing jobs and a total of 2.4 million jobs. Warsh suggested to participants that widespread adoption of AI could produce its own "China shock," this time concentrated among services workers.

He said he did not want to overstate the case, but if over the past generation or generation and a half the "China shock" pushed down U.S. goods prices, then what might the new technology idea do to services? In other words, AI could complete legal or administrative work at a lower cost than humans, which could lower prices but leave many people without jobs.

Warsh asked participants whether they should expect deflation in the medium term because AI could affect services. Most thought it was possible, which could mean the Fed may ultimately want to lower interest rates over the long run.

From the Meeting Room to Monetary Policy: How Far Away Are the Answers?

Still, there are many steps between the working group's discussions and a change in Fed policy. First, the three working group members need to consolidate their views into a report submitted to Warsh in the coming months.

Then the Fed itself needs to debate those results and decide whether or how to use them to shape monetary policy. But as AI grows stronger, the Fed may need to decide sooner rather than later.

Ultimately, Warsh and his Fed colleagues need to be confident in the answers. That is, the impact of AI on the economy has entered the Fed's field of vision, but there are still institutional procedures and internal consensus thresholds before it truly changes the rate path.

Summary

Overall, the core of this report is not that "AI will definitely make someone unemployed immediately," but that the Fed is being forced to answer a more fundamental question ahead of time: when AI may push down services prices, replace some white-collar jobs, boost investment enthusiasm and trigger social backlash, how should monetary policy judge inflation, employment and interest rates?

Warsh's meeting is a starting point, and the real suspense is whether the Fed can form answers before the AI shock fully manifests.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why did Warsh convene the AI working group meeting at this time? A: Because AI is rapidly entering the economy and could change productivity, employment, prices and the rate path. Warsh said the U.S. economy is at a critical turning point, but the timing, manner and policy implications of the shift remain unclear. He cannot postpone answers for long, so he used the San Francisco meeting to publicly raise the questions and let outside experts fill in the Fed's knowledge.

Q: Why was this meeting described as "unusual"? A: The Fed already has PhD economists who can quickly offer opinions, but Warsh has long criticized it as insular and outdated, so he brought in outside expertise, formed an AI working group, and set up four other working groups responsible for different aspects of policymaking. He personally chaired three of the four sessions and selected speakers, showing he wants to push the AI issue to the forefront of decision-making.

Q: What is the connection between the Anthropic IPO and a December rate hike? A: The article treats massive spending by AI companies as a factor heating up the economy. Anthropic plans to price its IPO on Wednesday at a $1.4 trillion valuation, raising up to $64 billion, showing the enormous scale of the AI investment boom. The Fed is therefore considering a December rate hike to slow price increases. The two are not directly causal, but together they reflect that AI capital spending may overheat the economy.

Q: What do the anti-data-center measures and Raimondo's remarks show? A: In the November 3 midterm elections, voters passed multiple state-level measures to slow construction of data centers that power AI, showing that some Americans are averse to AI's energy and community costs. Raimondo called this "a very disturbing sign" and said blocking AI would be bad for the United States and for voters. Warsh did not say whether he agreed, nor did he explain how it would translate into monetary policy.

Q: What does the AI version of the "China shock" mean? A: Warsh borrowed from the experience of the low-cost manufacturing shock to the U.S. after China joined the WTO in 2001: goods prices fell, but the U.S. lost a large number of manufacturing jobs. He speculated that if AI can complete legal, administrative and other services work at lower cost, it could push down services prices while leaving services workers unemployed, and could bring medium-term deflationary pressure, thereby affecting the Fed's long-term rate choices.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment