Amid persistently high U.S. inflation and rising expectations for further Federal Reserve rate hikes, Philadelphia Fed President Anna Paulson stressed that the key to central bank policy communication is not telling markets in advance how rates will move, but helping the public understand how policymakers will act as the economy changes.
Speaking in New York on Thursday, Paulson said that if the Fed and the public can build sufficient mutual understanding, interest rate policy can more effectively guide consumption and investment while reducing unnecessary volatility in financial markets.
She noted that good policy communication can also allow the Fed to temporarily look through short-term shocks without damaging its credibility, and to adjust policy flexibly based on newly released economic data.
No need to pre-commit to a rate path; the key is explaining the decision logic
Paulson believes that in a normal economic environment, the Fed does not necessarily need to clearly forecast the direction of rate adjustments at upcoming meetings.
Rather than directly telling the market whether the next step will be a hike or a cut, it is more important to let investors and the public understand how the central bank makes decisions based on inflation, employment and economic growth.
This decision-making mechanism is known in monetary policy circles as the "reaction function."
When markets fully understand the Fed's policy reaction function, investors can infer how policy may change based on economic data even if officials do not explicitly state the future rate path.
Paulson said such mutual understanding helps make policy adjustments smoother and more predictable.
She also emphasized that policy communication must be built on credibility, because the public will only adjust economic behavior based on the central bank's messages if they believe them.
Paulson's remarks come as Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh pushes internal communication reforms.
Warsh tends to reduce explicit guidance on the future path of interest rates, arguing that the central bank should not rely excessively on forward guidance to manage financial market expectations.
However, that stance has prompted questions from some market participants, who argue that if the Fed lacks sufficient explanation, investors may find it difficult to judge how policymakers assess the economic situation.
Although Paulson did not directly criticize Warsh, she stressed that the Fed should provide enough information for the public to understand the economic conditions underpinning future policy adjustments.
October rate pause is not a pivot; communication helps avoid market misjudgment
Paulson also used the Fed's October policy meeting as an example to illustrate how policy communication can help markets correctly understand rate decisions.
The Fed raised rates by 25 basis points in September, then decided at its October 27-28 meeting to keep rates unchanged, holding the federal funds rate target range at 3.75% to 4.00%.
Paulson said she supported the decision to pause in October.
She believes an important reason the decision was implemented smoothly was that the market already understood the Fed might still tighten further.
As a result, holding rates steady in October was not widely interpreted as the end of the hiking cycle.
In her view, when the market fully understands the policy direction, the Fed can adjust rates more prudently and give households and businesses time to adapt to changes in financial conditions.
The minutes of the Fed's October meeting released on November 18 also reflected this judgment.
The minutes showed that almost all participating officials believed that if inflation and the job market develop as expected, further rate increases would still be needed in the coming months to bring inflation back to the 2% target in a timely manner.
Some officials even said that as long as the market clearly understood rates would still rise, they could have accepted holding steady temporarily in October.
Warsh reforms communication mechanism; December rate hike size still disputed
Since Warsh became Fed chairman, the central bank has begun adjusting its external communication, including shortening FOMC policy statements and setting up five special working groups to study internal reforms such as the balance sheet and policy communication.
Warsh did not submit a personal rate projection for the quarterly dot plot and has not yet committed to continuing post-meeting press conferences after every scheduled policy meeting beyond this year.
These changes have sparked discussion about the transparency of Fed policy.
In response, Paulson said the Fed should retain multiple communication channels, including the quarterly dot plot.
She said the dot plot is very helpful in some periods and of limited use in others, so different communication tools should complement each other rather than relying entirely on one format.
Meanwhile, inflation pressure is further intensifying internal debate at the Fed over the size of a December rate hike.
Fed Governor Waller previously said that given the risk of inflation spreading to more parts of the economy, the Fed needs to act more aggressively.
He suggested the December meeting could consider a 50 basis point hike, or use clearer policy communication to signal to the market that rate hikes will accelerate in 2027.
Paulson had previously favored gradual monetary tightening and emphasized that the specific path should depend on economic data.
In Thursday's speech, she did not make a new explicit forecast for the December meeting's rate decision.
Currently, the market widely expects the Fed to raise rates by 25 basis points at its December 8-9 meeting, lifting the federal funds rate target range to 4.00% to 4.25%.
Some interest rate futures pricing also reflects investor expectations for further rate hikes in January and April next year.
Comments