Huatai Futures: China's Crude Oil Overbuying Cannot Last, Fundamentals Set to Weaken Further

Deep News11-16

Market Analysis — Prices and Spreads: On absolute prices, crude rebounded after a selloff, with front-month Brent (January) settling at $95.84 a barrel, front-month WTI (December) at $88.56 a barrel, and front-month Dubai (January) at $92.04 a barrel as of Friday's close.

On monthly spreads, the three benchmark crude contracts were relatively steady in their M1-M2 structure, with the Brent spread holding at $2.81 a barrel, the WTI spread holding at $1.27 a barrel, and the Dubai spread staying at a near-month discount of $0.12 a barrel.

Looking at Brent CFDs, the front four weeks have already flipped to a near-month discount, but the Brent monthly spread remains relatively firm. Given that physical demand is still weakening at the margin, the monthly spread could weaken further, Brent's near month remains overvalued, and the geopolitical premium has yet to be fully squeezed out.

On regional spreads, the front-month Brent-Dubai EFS continued to compress to $4.24 a barrel, and the front-month WTI-Brent spread narrowed to $8.73 a barrel. In the near term, falling freight rates should help improve arbitrage relationships between regions, with independent refiners stepping up purchases of West African, Latin American and other Western crudes.

On physical premiums, North Sea premiums stabilized after a sharp slide to year-end lows, with the North Sea market showing weakness. West African and Latin American grades that had corrected more heavily continued to rebound, while Middle Eastern premiums stayed weak, hovering around zero, and ESPO premiums fell to $11 a barrel. Overall, Chinese buying interest shifted from ESPO and Middle Eastern grades toward West African and Latin American grades, lifting those premiums. Lower freight rates improved refiner costs, but overall costs remain elevated. With domestic diesel exports restricted, and as previously purchased high-priced crude arrives in China, both refinery run rates and purchasing appetite will struggle to stay high.

On product cracks, diesel cracks have largely stabilized while gasoline cracks remain weak. China recently added product export quotas; sustained high gasoline exports will suppress Singapore gasoline cracks, but diesel exports have already fallen sharply. As a clear domestic diesel shortage has emerged, restricted diesel exports from the Middle East, Russia and China will keep global diesel cracks high or even drive another rebound.

Inventories: According to Kpler high-frequency inventory data, total global onshore and offshore crude inventories stood at 4.7 billion barrels, edging down over the past two weeks. Global onshore crude inventories were 3.44 billion barrels, rising for several weeks. Global onshore and offshore crude inventories excluding China and excluding U.S. SPR recently fell to 3.06 billion barrels, an absolute level that is historically high, while global onshore crude inventories excluding China and the U.S. SPR held near 1.83 billion barrels and rose notably over the past two weeks.

On floating storage, crude in transit at sea (including floating storage) fell to 1.276 billion barrels, still at a historically high level. Recent cargoes have been arriving in China, reducing volumes in transit at sea and converting them into onshore tank inventories.

China's onshore crude inventories recently rose to about 1.17 billion barrels (satellite floating-roof tank inventories excluding underground SPR), mainly because the rebound in imports significantly exceeded expectations. This round of restocking was stronger than expected, which we believe reflects not only improved refinery margins but also some overbuying driven by feedstock security concerns. Due to export policy adjustments, product price caps and rising feedstock costs, the short-term overbuying cannot last. The midterm election results reduced the likelihood of geopolitical escalation, and refiner purchasing is expected to slow markedly.

Crude Tanker Schedules: On the Strait of Hormuz, Middle Eastern loadings fell from prior weeks to a total of 15.2 million barrels a day, with Saudi crude loadings dropping to 5.5 million barrels a day, mainly on lower East Coast loadings, while Yanbu port exports held at 2.4 million barrels a day, not yet back to the 4 million barrel a day peak. Iraqi crude loadings via the Turkish pipeline rose significantly, with Turkey's Ceyhan loadings rebounding to 500,000 barrels a day.

On Russia, crude loadings recently held at 4 million barrels a day, while product exports recovered to 1.4 million barrels a day. With Ukraine resuming strikes on Russian refineries, a recovery in product exports faces major challenges. On Latin America, crude loadings held at a high of 7 million barrels a day. On the United States, crude loadings rose slightly to 4 million barrels a day, while product loadings held at 3.3 million barrels a day. On China, crude arrivals continued to rebound to 10 million barrels a day, but judging by inventories, the country has clearly overbought, with onshore inventories even building. We believe this round of Chinese restocking included opportunistic purchases based on rising geopolitical tensions. After the midterm elections, the urgency of Chinese crude purchases has fallen significantly. As high-priced cargoes arrive one after another, domestic refiners face significant operating pressure, diesel exports are already significantly restricted, and domestic product prices are capped.

Refinery Maintenance and Margins: Global refinery offline capacity rose to 10.7 million barrels a day this week, mainly driven by another wave of Ukrainian drone attacks on Russian refineries, which added about 1 million barrels a day of offline capacity. New maintenance activity across Europe and higher U.S. outages from unplanned operational disruptions pushed the figure up further, though continued restarts in East Asia (especially China) partly offset the increase. For the week ending Nov. 20, global offline capacity is expected to reach 11.3 million barrels a day, as expected capacity restarts in East Asia (especially Japan) and the United States are largely offset by the growing impact of recent Russian attacks and additional maintenance in Northwest Europe and the Mediterranean.

For the week ending Nov. 13, offline refining capacity in the former Soviet Union was estimated to average 3.5 million barrels a day, as a fresh wave of Ukrainian drone attacks disrupted Russian refining operations, partly offsetting recent restarts. The latest attacks targeted Volgograd on Nov. 12 and Omsk on Nov. 11, both sparking fires. The Kirishi refinery suffered damage to crude distillation and primary processing units after an attack on Nov. 9. The Saratov refinery halted operations after its AVT-6 crude unit and hydrotreating unit were damaged on Nov. 7. Other attacks affected Ust-Luga, Afipsky, Ryazan, Yanos and NORSI, with varying operational impacts across facilities. Meanwhile, Tuapse, Slavyansk, Kuibyshev and Syzran remained offline, and Salavat continued operating at reduced rates. Restarts at other facilities and the completion of maintenance at Belarus's Naftan refinery helped limit the further rise in offline capacity.

For the week ending Nov. 20, offline refining capacity in the former Soviet Union is expected to rise to about 4.3 million barrels a day, as recent disruptions increasingly outweigh continued restarts. Middle Eastern refineries averaged about 1.6 million barrels a day of offline capacity this week, a level expected to persist through Nov. 20. Ras Tanura was hit by a missile on Oct. 27, and a pipeline attack in Syria led to shutdowns and emergency repairs. Riyadh is operating at reduced capacity after recent incidents. Bazan Haifa suspended aromatics operations for maintenance, and Shuaiba's fluid catalytic cracking unit remains under maintenance. Jizan is offline, Banias is undergoing upgrades, and several Kuwaiti refineries are operating at reduced rates. Iran's Lavan is at half capacity, while SATORP and Mesaieed are running at full rates. Vitol Fujairah in the UAE has restarted.

Geopolitics: The U.S.-Iran standoff is expected to persist in the near term; Trump denied plans to strike Iran again, and Democrats said they would legislate to stop a war with Iran. On Russia-Ukraine, Ukraine resumed strikes on Russian refineries and oil terminals. The market will watch whether the outcome of China-U.S.-Russia APEC talks has a clear impact on the geopolitical direction.

Overall Assessment: Even as China has continuously increased imports and overbought since September, the physical crude market still shows a surplus. As Chinese purchasing slows, the near-term deterioration in fundamentals has yet to show signs of easing, and the geopolitical premium has not been fully squeezed out, so we maintain a short-term bearish view.

Strategy: The logic of an escalation in the U.S.-Iran conflict has been disproved, the geopolitical premium is being squeezed out quickly, and crude is returning to a fundamentals-driven framework. Continue to hold previous short positions.

Downside risks: Easing Middle East tensions, restored navigation through the strait, a global economic crisis. Upside risks: Stronger-than-expected Chinese demand recovery, further deterioration in the Red Sea and Middle East situation.

Investment advisory business qualification: CSRC License [2011] No. 1289. Disclaimer: This report is based on publicly available information the company believes to be reliable, but the company makes no guarantee as to its accuracy or completeness. The opinions, conclusions and forecasts contained in this report reflect only the views and judgments as of the date of publication. At different times, the company may issue research reports inconsistent with the opinions, assessments and forecasts contained in this report. The company does not guarantee that the information contained in this report remains up to date. The company may modify the information contained in this report without notice, and investors should pay attention to relevant updates or modifications on their own. The company strives to make the report objective and fair, but the views, conclusions and recommendations contained in this report are for reference only, and investors cannot rely on this report to replace the exercise of independent judgment. The company and the authors assume no legal liability for any consequences arising from investors' reliance on or use of this report. The copyright of this report belongs solely to the company. Without the company's written permission, no institution or individual may infringe the company's copyright in any form, including reprinting, copying, publishing, citing or redistributing to others. If citing or publishing with the company's consent, it must be used within the permitted scope, with the source noted as the Huatai Futures Research Institute, and no citation, abridgement or modification contrary to the original meaning may be made. The company reserves the right to pursue relevant liability. All trademarks, service marks and logos used in this report are trademarks, service marks and logos of the company. Huatai Futures Co., Ltd. owns the copyright and reserves all rights. Choose Huatai for futures account opening — professional and trustworthy.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment