Indonesian Stocks Plunge 5% to Six-Year Low as MSCI Downgrade Warning Triggers Foreign Capital Exodus

Deep News10-19

Indonesia's stock market has suffered a severe blow, with MSCI's proposal to reclassify the country directly from Emerging Market to "Standalone" status pushing Southeast Asia's largest economy to the brink of removal from major global equity indices.

The Jakarta Composite Index fell more than 5% on Monday, hitting its lowest level since October 2020, extending Friday's crash triggered by MSCI's announcement 鈥?the steepest single-day decline since 1998, which wiped out approximately US$65 billion in market value in a single session. The Indonesia Stock Exchange has urgently halved the daily downside limit to 7% in an attempt to contain market panic. Goldman Sachs warned that if MSCI ultimately completes the downgrade, passive funds could face approximately US$5.6 billion in forced selling pressure.

Indonesia Stock Exchange CEO Jeffrey Hendrik stated that exchange management would hold an online meeting with MSCI on Monday to seek clarification. He described the MSCI announcement as unexpected, noting that "the exchange, the Financial Services Authority, and most market participants did not anticipate this," and emphasized that Indonesia meets all criteria for maintaining Emerging Market status. MSCI is expected to make a final decision by June next year, with the outcome depending on whether Indonesian authorities can deliver substantive improvements in market governance and transparency.

MSCI Warning: Coordinated Trading and Weak Regulatory Enforcement Trigger Downgrade Proposal

MSCI issued an announcement on Friday proposing to reclassify Indonesia directly from Emerging Market to "Standalone" status, bypassing the usual intermediate "Frontier Market" tier 鈥?a deeper cut than previously anticipated by the market. In its announcement, MSCI cited "significant concerns" about market dysfunction, including coordinated trading practices and the failure to effectively enforce regulatory rules.

The "Standalone" category is not included in MSCI's Emerging Market index framework, meaning Indonesian stocks would disappear from the major indices tracked by billions of dollars in passive global funds. For Indonesia's capital markets, which rely on foreign participation, the implications are profound.

Goldman Sachs Estimates: Passive Fund Outflows Could Reach US$5.6 Billion

According to a Goldman Sachs research note released on Sunday, if Indonesia is fully removed from the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, it would trigger approximately US$5.6 billion in passive fund outflows, equivalent to about 18 trading days of average volume for constituents of the MSCI Indonesia Investable Market Index.

If FTSE Russell subsequently takes similar action, an additional approximately US$2.7 billion could face outflow risk, though Goldman Sachs emphasized this is a separate scenario. Additionally, active funds benchmarked to MSCI and FTSE indices currently hold over US$8 billion in Indonesian equities, but any reduction of this portion would be an active decision, not automatically triggered by the downgrade.

Goldman Sachs maintained its underweight rating on Indonesian equities, citing persistent index uncertainty, weak corporate earnings, and a challenging macroeconomic environment. Strategists led by Alvin So wrote:

"Valuations have compressed significantly, but remain above historical troughs; index, earnings, and macro risks constrain the room for re-rating."

Foreign Capital Continues to Exit, Valuations Fall to Lowest Since Financial Crisis

Foreign capital has been accelerating its withdrawal from Indonesian capital markets this year. According to Goldman Sachs data, as of Friday, the MSCI Indonesia Index had fallen 47% year-to-date, with cumulative net foreign outflows of US$5.1 billion during the period. Foreign ownership of Indonesian stocks has declined from 27% in January to 25% in October, while the market value of foreign holdings has nearly halved from approximately US$250 billion to about US$130 billion.

Despite the sharp decline, Goldman Sachs warned that Indonesian stocks may not have bottomed yet. The MSCI Indonesia Index's 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio has dropped to 7.3 times, the lowest since the global financial crisis, but still above historical extreme lows. Goldman Sachs strategists also expect Indonesia's central bank to raise interest rates by 25 basis points each in the fourth quarter of 2026 and the first quarter of 2027, potentially putting further pressure on economic growth and equity valuations.

Exchange Steps In to Stabilize Market, Awaiting MSCI's Next Signal

Facing severe market volatility, the Indonesia Stock Exchange announced on Monday that it would halve the daily downside limit for individual stocks from the previous 14% to 7%. Jeffrey Hendrik stated that this measure is an effective means of reducing market volatility.

The online meeting between the Indonesia Stock Exchange and MSCI will be the first public signal of direct dialogue between the two parties regarding the downgrade proposal. Indonesian authorities need to demonstrate tangible improvements in market governance before MSCI's final ruling in June next year, otherwise the risk of removal from mainstream global indices will further intensify foreign outflow pressure, dealing another blow to Indonesia's already struggling stock market.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment