Investors are piling back into gold, but silver may be the superior play for those seeking exposure to the precious metals rally. Silver's peak-to-trough surge hit 405%, compared to gold's 170% rise, and it has gained 16% over the past month, outpacing gold's 10% rebound.
Half of silver's annual demand is industrial, spanning solar panel manufacturing, AI infrastructure, and electronics. Physical silver supply has been in deficit for six consecutive years, with the gap still widening. The VanEck Gold Miners ETF saw net inflows of $419 million this month, with a single-day record of $25 million, signaling renewed investor confidence in precious metals.
Where to begin
Over the past two and a half years, precious metals have consistently proven their value in a portfolio. Gold broke through $2,060 per ounce in December 2023, accelerated in March 2024, and shattered multi-decade resistance levels, launching a historic rally. A confluence of factors—expectations of Federal Reserve rate cuts, massive central bank buying led by China, and rising banking sector risks in spring—drove funds into gold. Such a perfect storm is rare. Gold hit a peak near $5,590 per ounce in late January, an approximate 170% gain from the start of the rally, before retreating to around $4,385. Although still up significantly from its starting point, the pullback from the peak was substantial. Now, gold is rebounding, rising about 10% in the past month. The question for investors is: if you want to position for the precious metals rally, is silver the better choice?
Gold's rebound draws in new capital
The recent gold price rise is not just a chart phenomenon; fund flow data confirms the trend. The VanEck Gold Miners ETF (GDX) recorded $9 million in net retail inflows on Wednesday, marking the sixth day of inflows in the past seven trading sessions. It saw $17 million in net inflows on Monday and a single-day inflow of $25 million on Friday, the highest single-day inflow in at least a year. The previous high for 2026 was $23 million in February. In total, the ETF has attracted $419 million in net inflows this month, on track for its best monthly inflow performance since February. Investors chasing these inflows are essentially betting on two things: the Federal Reserve's interest rate path and continued central bank gold purchases, which should sustain support for gold. Admittedly, a 20% pullback from the all-time high is significant. But gold prices have still doubled from their starting point at the end of 2023, and the recent month's rally shows buying interest hasn't faded.
Why just silver?
Gold has made new records, but silver has performed even better, thanks to tech industry tailwinds, with a maximum gain of 405%. Silver's actual performance has significantly outpaced gold. Few news reports highlight that over this roughly 26-month cycle, silver hasn't just kept pace with gold; its gains have been far superior. Silver started at around $24 per ounce, peaked above $121, and is currently trading at about $65. From the low to the peak, the gain was 405%. In comparison, gold's rise from its late 2023 starting point to its January peak was 170%. Silver has risen 16% in the past month, consistently outperforming gold. The key point is that silver's rally isn't just about being a safe-haven monetary metal. About half of silver's annual demand comes from industrial applications: solar manufacturing, AI infrastructure, and electronics production all directly consume silver. Supply and demand data supports this: the latest ISM Manufacturing Index rose to 55.6, a four-year high, with the manufacturing sector expanding for seven consecutive months. Gold does not share this industrial demand advantage. Meanwhile, physical silver supply is in a severe deficit, a gap that has persisted for six years and is widening.
SLV silver ETF vs. GDX gold miners ETF: How to choose
Two mainstream investment vehicles differ in their approach. The iShares Silver Trust (SLV) directly tracks the spot price of silver. The VanEck Gold Miners ETF (GDX) invests in gold mining companies, whose stock prices have a leveraged relationship with the gold price. However, leverage is a double-edged sword: it can amplify gains but also introduces stock-specific risks. Beyond commodity price fluctuations, investors must also contend with company-level risks like labor costs, mine production, and balance sheets. The iShares Silver Trust avoids these complex variables. In a phase where the underlying metal itself is performing strongly, investing directly in silver via an ETF is a more direct and efficient way to capture the rally.
Core takeaway
In short, gold's current rally is impressive, but silver offers higher returns and possesses a structural industrial demand logic that gold lacks. Regardless of which precious metal an investor prefers, the sustained inflows into the gold miners ETF demonstrate renewed market bullishness on the sector. When choosing between the two, the iShares Silver Trust ETF offers direct exposure to silver's stronger momentum and is currently more attractive than the VanEck Gold Miners ETF.
Comments