US equities have fallen for seven straight sessions, and a derivatives trader at Goldman Sachs is warning that the current market is showing striking similarities to the fourth-quarter selloff of 2018, suggesting this correction may not be over yet.
In a report published on Friday, Goldman Sachs derivatives strategist Brian Garrett pointed out that current market price action, technicals and trading structure all bear clear resemblance to 2018. By comparing index declines across the two episodes, he assessed how much further the major stock benchmarks could fall.
Garrett recalled the market crash of December 24, 2018. At the time, a client asked him, "Why has it dropped so much today?" Garrett admitted plainly, "I had absolutely no idea." Even for a seasoned trader, it was hard to say why the market had spiraled out of control in the face of a sudden, violent selloff.
Yet historical parallels do not guarantee a repeat performance. In this adjustment, the credit market has not yet shown obvious deterioration, and the Federal Reserve has not signaled a policy pivot either. Goldman Sachs believes these differences could be key to judging whether this correction is nearing its end.
Is the 2018 script repeating? Goldman Sachs warns the US stock correction may be far from over
In the fourth quarter of 2018, US equities slumped sharply under the combined weight of continued Fed rate hikes, a technical breakdown and systemic selling pressure. The S&P 500 fell nearly 20% from its high and bottomed out on Christmas Eve.
Goldman Sachs compared the decline in major stock indices since their October 6 peak with the comparable move in 2018. As of Thursday's close, the S&P 500 had completed 42% of the 2018 decline over the same period, the Nasdaq 100 stood at 69%, and the Russell 2000 at just 24%.
If the remaining 2018 decline were mapped onto the current market, Goldman Sachs models show that the major indices could still face further adjustment. Among them, the S&P 500 has not yet matched the same-period drop from that year, implying that downside risk has not been fully released.
On the time dimension, the S&P 500 took 65 trading days to move from its stage high to its ultimate bottom in 2018. As of Friday, this correction has lasted about 33 trading days. If it follows a similar rhythm, a market bottom might not appear until the first full trading week of January next year.
Credit market reaction lags, and the Fed has yet to signal a turn
Compared with 2018, stress in the current credit market is noticeably lighter. Goldman Sachs data show that investment-grade credit spreads have widened by only 5 basis points from their recent high, while high-yield spreads have widened by 38 basis points — both well below the changes seen at the same point in 2018.
The rates market has also not shown the same degree of risk aversion. The current 10-year swap rate is down 23 basis points from its recent high, while short-end rates have moved even less. This suggests the market has not yet undertaken a full repricing of the economic and policy outlook the way it did in 2018.
The important catalyst for the 2018 market reversal was then-Fed Chair Powell's "patience" signal on January 4 of the following year. Now, Goldman Sachs economists still expect the Fed to hike again in March next year, and policy expectations have not shifted toward easing. Barclays also noted that investors currently see no possibility of the Fed stepping in to support the market.
Safe-haven assets fail, panic mounts and market dispersion widens
Traditional safe-haven assets did not play their expected role in this correction. Since the recent high, gold has fallen 10.8%, and the yen has weakened about 1% against the dollar. At the same point in 2018, gold rose 5% and the yen appreciated 2.1%. The performance of safe-haven assets is clearly at odds with the historical playbook.
Market panic has continued to intensify. In its report, the Goldman Sachs volatility team rated the current level of market fear at 9 out of 10. The VIX has risen to 30.3, not far from the 36.1 peak seen on the eve of Christmas in 2018, yet the S&P 500's cumulative decline so far is less than half of the comparable 2018 move.
Trading structure is also amplifying market swings. Goldman Sachs estimates that dealers currently hold about US$1 billion in net short gamma positions, which could intensify hedging-related selling when the market falls. Clients have recently begun selling high-premium tail options, reflecting that market participants are adjusting their trading strategies around volatility.
Individual stocks and portfolios are also showing clear dispersion. NVIDIA has fallen about 39% since early October, under heavy selling pressure. Among the 2,258 investment baskets tracked by Goldman Sachs, portfolios that performed well in the first half generally gave back gains in the second half; baskets that more than doubled in the first half posted a median second-half return of about -50%. Previously crowded winning trades are now being unwound en masse.
A rebound may only be a breather, and a bottom still needs confirmation
The market is not without the conditions for a short-term bounce. Positioning has already been significantly flushed out, panic indicators are near extremes, some clients have started selling volatility, and the Nasdaq 100 is approaching oversold territory. In addition, history shows that the S&P 500 has staged short-term rebounds after falling below its 200-day moving average, and a holiday-shortened trading week may also offer the market some relief.
But short-term rebound signals do not mean the market has bottomed. Before the 2018 market truly reversed, credit spreads widened markedly and the Fed signaled a shift in policy stance. Neither of those two key conditions has appeared yet.
Garrett believes that until the credit market deteriorates noticeably or the Fed's policy stance changes, any market rebound may only be "borrowed." Investors still need to wait for clearer signals from credit risk and monetary policy before they can judge whether this correction is truly nearing its end.
Comments