U.S. stock markets witnessed substantial turbulence this week, revealing growing fissures in market sentiment. Early in the week, market capitalization briefly plummeted by over $1.5 trillion, compelling traders to reassess several previously accepted assumptions: Can the U.S. economy sustain another year of double-digit gains? Could the efficiency promised by artificial intelligence end up squeezing the profitability of existing companies? Has retail trading enthusiasm transformed traditionally "safe-haven" assets into highly volatile instruments?
The sell-off was not confined to software stocks. Small-cap equities, precious metals miners, digital asset firms, and professional service providers all displayed vulnerabilities during the same period. The software sector experienced the most pronounced swings, while momentum stocks, largely comprising major tech names, suffered their most significant single-day decline since the pandemic.
Uncertainty continues to spread. Mike Dickson, Head of Research and Quantitative Strategy at Horizon Investments, noted, "When investors get nervous, the most overvalued and over-positioned areas of the global markets are often the first to feel the pain." Even with subsequent rebounds, he cautioned that such "relief rallies after a sharp drop" frequently occur while underlying pressures remain unresolved.
Thomas Thornton, Founder of Hedge Fund Telemetry LLC, stated that the market is fraught with pitfalls, some of which are evolving into traps for specific assets and sectors.
**Small-Cap Stocks Face Dual Pressures** At the start of the year, investors shifted from overvalued tech stocks to companies poised to benefit from economic recovery and lower interest rates, with small-caps being a primary target. This bet soured over the past week, partly due to investors liquidating nearly all positions. The main concern stemmed from a trio of labor market reports indicating troubling weakness in the U.S. economy. This weakness particularly impacts domestically-focused small-caps, which rely heavily on U.S. consumer demand. Combined with AI's potential disruption to jobs and business models, smaller financial and technology firms are especially vulnerable. The Russell 2000 index's 7.6% year-to-date gain suddenly appears overly optimistic.
"The stock market may be sensing increasing pressure on consumers as labor market data continues to cool," said Cameron Dawson, Chief Investment Officer at NewEdge Wealth. An unexpectedly strong consumer confidence report on Friday curbed the selling, but not before the Russell 2000 had fallen more than 5% from its recent high.
**Precious Metals Transform into "Speculative Tools"** Price swings in gold and silver have noticeably deviated from their typical stability, causing related mining company stocks to fluctuate wildly. Shares of Newmont Mining, the largest U.S. gold miner, had doubled by 2025, while smaller miners like Discovery Silver Corp. surged by 1000%. However, this trade is now rapidly unwinding. The VanEck Gold Miners ETF plunged 13% on January 29th, its largest single-day drop in over five years.
"These metals have transformed from boring commodities traded by professionals into stimulating gambling instruments traded by retail investors," wrote Owen Lamont, Senior Vice President and Portfolio Manager at Acadian Asset Management LLC. This is concerning for investors seeking shelter in gold miners during turbulent times. Double-digit daily and weekly volatility is inconsistent with risk-averse characteristics. "Nearly every theme has been pushed to an extreme, and gold and silver are no exception," said Sameer Samana, Global Head of Equity and Real Assets at Wells Fargo Investment Institute.
**Equity Capital Markets Confront AI Disruption** As software companies like Docusign Inc., Salesforce Inc., and Workday Inc. tumbled on fears that AI tools could displace their services, investors began searching for other areas of the economy susceptible to robotic disruption. According to an October report from The Conference Board, 72% of S&P 500 companies have updated disclosures stating AI poses a "significant risk" to their business. Scrutiny has expanded to banks, travel stocks, professional service providers, and the entire small-cap segment.
If AI disruption proves destructive, activity in equity capital markets—from mergers and acquisitions to IPOs and sales of stocks and bonds—could slow. Tech sector M&A grew 77% last year and is expected to again be a major contributor to bank capital markets divisions in 2024, according to a Thursday report by Truist Securities analyst Brian Foran. "A few weeks of poor deals won't necessarily break the trend—but it doesn't help," he said. Beyond banking and financial services, the sell-off in software stocks has impacted the broader professional services sector. Stocks like Thomson Reuters Corp. and Morningstar Inc. fell by double digits this week.
Keith Lerner, Chief Investment Officer and Chief Market Strategist at Truist Advisory Services, framed the issue pragmatically: "Do I continue hiring an outside firm, or do I let AI do part of the job?" He suggested that industries like online education, media and advertising, outsourcing, and market research could see revenues directly pressured by AI.
**Echoes of the Dot-Com Bubble** The tech sector's sharp decline evokes memories of the internet bubble. In fact, the speed at which value stocks are outperforming growth stocks was last seen during the 2022 market crash and the early days of the dot-com bubble. Brian Reynolds, Chief Market Strategist at Reynolds Strategy LLC, pointed out that it took 25 years for darlings of the internet era like Corning Inc. and Cisco Systems Inc. to surpass their previous highs. He views this as a warning for investors still enamored with the largest AI-themed stocks, whose prices have tripled or more in recent years.
"History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes," Reynolds quoted Mark Twain. "In a bubble, you must be very disciplined, you must diversify. If you have a stock that has soared, you should lighten up on it."
Comments