Epic Drawdown: What Exactly Happened?

Deep News11-20 18:50

From 2022 to now, over the course of four years, gold and silver have traced an extreme cycle from an epic surge to an epic collapse. The volatility has been so violent that it exceeded everyone's expectations.

In the futures market: gold rose from 370 yuan per gram at the start of 2022 to 1,258 yuan per gram by the end of January this year, a gain of 2.4 times, and then fell to around 760 yuan per gram now, a drop of more than 40%; silver rose from 48 yuan per gram at the start of 2022 to 320 yuan per gram by the end of January this year, a gain of 5.6 times, and then fell to around 100 yuan per gram now, a drop of more than 70%; prices in the spot market moved by roughly similar magnitudes.

If you had been holding gold or silver continuously for the past four years, then although you missed the peak exit, you would still have at least a 1x gain, which is still quite good. But in reality, how many such people are there? The vast majority exit early on the way up and certainly do not capture that much of the gain. What is even more terrifying are those who entered too early during the decline, or even used several times leverage; for those who leveraged long gold and silver, blow-ups and forced liquidations were almost unavoidable outcomes. In recent months, related news in the circles has never stopped.

This round of market action has truly taught everyone a lesson: the capital markets never have a fixed script, and human calculation ultimately cannot defeat a turn in the cycle.

Three narratives drove the precious metals bull market from 2022 to its peak

The major precious metals bull market that ran from 2022 all the way to its high was supported by the resonance of three narratives. Central banks' continued gold purchases and reserve diversification were slow variables that supported the bottom and did not drive the main upward move; the main line that truly drove elasticity was expectations of Federal Reserve rate cuts pushing down real interest rates; silver was able to generate stronger excess returns because it additionally benefited from incremental industrial demand from photovoltaic and AI computing power expansion, which was also the core reason silver significantly outperformed gold in the previous two years.

But central bank gold buying can only support the bottom; it cannot stop a trend move dominated by interest rates. The sharp drop in gold prices during the Federal Reserve's aggressive rate hikes in 2022 is a ready example: even though global central banks continued to increase holdings, once real rates rose, gold still saw its valuation cut. The seeds of the turning point were actually planted during the Middle East conflict in February this year. In traditional understanding, geopolitical conflict equals safe-haven buying of gold. But this round's transmission chain changed completely: conflict first pushed oil prices higher, higher oil prices increased inflation stickiness, and inflation stickiness forced the Federal Reserve to delay rate cuts and even reprice the possibility of rate hikes. After that, geopolitics was no longer a positive for gold, but instead became a transmission channel that turned into a negative for precious metals, what the market calls safe-haven blowback.

The shift in expectations happened slowly. In the first half of the year, the market was still betting that rate cuts would merely be delayed. The real watershed came in the third quarter, when pricing completely switched from waiting for rate cuts to expecting higher rates to remain for longer, while also pricing in the risk of another round of hikes. The direct trigger for the market move was the stronger-than-expected September CPI, with a 3.7% year-on-year increase and a 0.6% month-on-month increase. Gasoline and commodity prices pushed inflation back up, oil prices rose for four consecutive months, and inflation stickiness caused more and more Federal Reserve officials to rapidly turn hawkish.

On November 18, Waller, who had long been dovish, publicly turned hawkish, saying that if inflation continued to worsen, a single 50bp hike in December would even be worth considering; the subsequently released October meeting minutes had an even tougher tone, with the vast majority of officials acknowledging that there was still room for further tightening, and some officials believing that a December hike of more than 25bp was reasonable. As a result, funding pricing deteriorated further, with the probability of a 25bp hike in December rising above 95%, tail risk of 50bp being priced in, and traders beginning to bet on another 50bp hike in January next year. The dollar index also rushed above 103 again, a 19-month high, while the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield held above 5.1% and the two-year yield stood at 4.80%.

On one side was a risk-free return above 5% for a longer period, combined with a stronger dollar suppressing pricing; on the other side were non-yielding precious metals. Capital simply chose to leave.

The AI narrative crisis became another straw that broke the camel's back

Another straw that broke the camel's back was the AI narrative crisis. Since July, from controversies over circular financing support among tech giants, to the bursting of the bubble at South Korea's Samsung and SK Hynix, to the Jensen Huang incident and Intel's earnings blow-up, the ongoing controversy over AI capital expenditure accelerated the pullback in global stock markets. It drove a correction in technology stocks and pierced the margin lines of leveraged funds. Investors needed to raise cash to meet margin calls, and gold, as the most liquid and quickest asset to convert into cash, became the priority sale asset: sell gold to save tech stocks. Such selling did not care about price. After a rapid technical breakdown, stop-loss orders flooded out in a chain reaction, further amplifying the sharp decline. Similar scenes have not been rare in the past few years.

Silver suffered an additional blow. Since the start of this year, the market has lowered expectations for global AI capital expenditure and the pace of data center construction, while silver-reduction technology in photovoltaics continued to be deployed, causing both major industrial narratives supporting silver to be revised downward. More than half of silver demand comes from industry, and photovoltaics has been the largest source of incremental demand over the past five years. Silver paste reduction, copper-coated silver, and silver-free paste continued to lower silver consumption per watt. Institutional estimates suggest that photovoltaic silver demand will fall by 21% to 30% in 2026, with total silver demand for the year revised down by about 5%, and the focus of market discussion has shifted from long-term shortage to oversupply. In addition, silver has a small market and crowded speculative longs from earlier, so concentrated stop-losses among crowded longs at high levels triggered a negative feedback loop of decline, stop-loss triggering, and further decline.

Fund flows also confirmed this pattern. In the first half of the year, global gold ETFs continued to reduce holdings by more than a hundred tonnes, and silver ETF holdings by early November were down 4% from the start of the year. Recently, institutions have also cut targets one after another. Goldman Sachs lowered its gold price target for the second time within the month, reducing its end-2027 target from $4,800 to $4,650. Lower sell-side expectations continued to suppress bullish sentiment.

When will gold and silver see a turnaround?

So when will gold and silver finally see a turnaround? The most fundamental anchor remains the U.S. dollar interest rate. And the turning point in rates depends first on inflation: whether CPI, core CPI, and PPI can fall again, and whether oil and energy prices stop rising. That is the precondition for the Federal Reserve to turn dovish. The two most direct indicators are the 10-year U.S. Treasury real yield and the dollar index. As long as real rates continue to rise, the pressure from the holding cost of gold will not ease.

Beyond macro rates, liquidity clearing also matters. Only when the unwinding of leverage in tech stocks ends and the pressure from cross-asset forced selling is fully released will gold stop being continuously treated as a cash machine. For silver, one must also separately watch for the clearing of speculative longs, the return of ETF funds, signs that photovoltaic silver demand expectations are stabilizing, and signals that AI capital expenditure expectations are being revised upward again.

Medium- and long-term bottom support has not disappeared. Central bank gold purchases and credit-hedging demand brought by fiscal deficits are still there, but this slow variable has temporarily lost pricing power in a high real-rate environment. Therefore, in the short term, although the decline in recent days has been terrifying, it is not suitable to rush to bottom-fish. The real turning point should be considered only after rate hike expectations peak, real rates fall back, short positions are cleared out, and expectations stabilize.

Epilogue

This round of surge and collapse in gold and silver teaches us not only whether the precious metals logic has broken, but also a set of disciplinary tests about survival. Using the logic of slow variables to carry the leverage of fast variables was the most expensive mismatch in this market cycle. Keynes said that markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent. So never use leverage to prove a judgment that may be late but correct. Because no matter how solid the long-term logic is, many times it cannot withstand a short-term margin call. Investing is not about proving that you are right, but about always maintaining solvency in a highly uncertain market and waiting until the day the logic is realized. (Full article ends)

▍Past Review

Gelonghui statement: The views in this article are all from the original author and do not represent the views and stance of Gelonghui. Special reminder: Investment decisions should be based on independent thinking. The content of this article is for reference only and should not be used as any actual operational advice. Trading risks are borne by oneself.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment