Marvell's Acquisition of Lumentum: The First Deep Closed Loop of "Chip + Optics," the Dual Role of Referee and Player, and the Winner-Takes-All Dynamic in Optical Communications

Deep News10-31

On October 28, Bloomberg reported that Marvell Technology was in advanced talks to acquire optical component manufacturer Lumentum in an all-stock deal. At the time, the report valued Lumentum at approximately $83 billion and Marvell Technology at around $221 billion.

The potential deal raises a compelling question: why would a company known for custom chips and high-speed interconnects make a major push into the manufacturing of lasers and optical components?

On October 30, the semiconductor industry podcast Semi Doped invited two analysts from market research firm Cignal AI, Andrew Schmitt and Scott Wilkinson, to discuss the deal. Their conclusion was that Marvell Technology hopes to achieve vertical integration by combining DSPs, lasers, and optical components into a more complete product system.

If the deal closes, Marvell Technology could become one of the few companies covering multiple segments simultaneously, including DSPs, lasers, and optical modules. But it would also create new competitive dynamics: the company would supply chips to optical module makers while potentially entering the very markets those customers serve.

From DSP to Lasers and Optical Modules: Marvell Wants to Connect the Entire Chain

The host suggested that after acquiring Lumentum, Marvell Technology could become a company with DSP, laser, and optical module businesses all under one roof. Andrew Schmitt argued that the closest precedent to this model is Acacia, but the combination of Marvell Technology and Lumentum could go further in terms of business scale and coverage.

He first clarified that Marvell Technology does not lack laser supply. The company currently primarily purchases tunable lasers for ZR coherent modules and maintains good relationships with multiple suppliers. The core driver behind acquiring Lumentum is vertical integration.

Andrew believes that in a market where technology changes rapidly, companies need to master both chip and optical technologies to better control product development and supply chains. Having both types of technology within the same company enables collaborative design, better-performing products, and higher gross margins through selling more complete solutions.

Lumentum itself already has a similar business combination. Andrew noted that the company previously acquired Cloud Light to enter the silicon photonics-based datacom optical module market. Optical modules produced by Cloud Light use Lumentum's own lasers while also requiring PAM4 DSPs purchased from companies like Marvell Technology and Broadcom.

In a single optical module, the laser and DSP account for nearly the most significant portion of value, with the remaining steps mainly involving assembly.

This means that Marvell Technology and Lumentum already had upstream and downstream connections in their businesses. After the acquisition, Marvell Technology would have the opportunity to bring key components that previously required external procurement into its internal system, further integrating DSPs, lasers, and optical engines.

Andrew believes the value of this model is also reflected in profits.

In the past, chip companies might achieve gross margins of 50%, while optical component manufacturers had only 25% to 30%. Chip companies were naturally reluctant to acquire a lower-margin business for fear of dragging down their own profit margins.

However, he noted that gross margins in the optical component industry have risen from about 25% to nearly 50%. Lumentum possesses scarce technologies in products such as 200G EML, optical circuit switching (OCS), and high-power lasers, and its bargaining power has clearly strengthened.

"If you can make more money, does it really matter that it represents a smaller percentage of total revenue?"

Andrew believes investors have historically placed too much emphasis on gross margin percentages while overlooking the absolute gross profit a company can generate. Integrating components into more complete products could generate more profit even if the combined gross margin percentage changes.

He also mentioned that six or seven years ago, Marvell Technology might have been able to acquire Lumentum for only about $3 billion, and now the potential deal size could be 30 times that amount. This is his recollection and estimate, but it also reflects the changing value of optical components in the AI era.

Both Referee and Player: Marvell May Compete with Its Own Customers

Vertical integration would give Marvell Technology a more complete product line, but it would also change its relationships with customers.

Scott Wilkinson pointed out that Marvell Technology's coherent DSPs are currently widely adopted by optical module manufacturers. Taking 400G coherent modules as an example, aside from Acacia, Ciena, Nokia, and some Chinese manufacturers, many companies purchase Marvell Technology's DSPs.

If Marvell Technology acquires Lumentum and further enters the optical engine and module market, it could find itself in direct competition with these existing customers.

This is precisely the delicate aspect of the deal: Marvell Technology is both an upstream chip supplier in the industry chain and potentially a participant in downstream products. Customers will inevitably consider whether they should continue relying on a company that competes with them to supply critical chips.

The host Austin posed a direct question: if customers turn to other DSP suppliers like Broadcom or Credo as a result, would Marvell Technology be willing to sacrifice some chip market share in exchange for the optical module business?

Andrew believes this is a calculable business equation:

"Through vertical integration, I can capture more value than selling components separately, even if it means I might sell fewer components."

Scott also cautioned that what really needs to be observed is how Marvell Technology manages the business after the acquisition. Lumentum already sells lasers to external customers and operates some optical module business. After the acquisition, Marvell Technology may not necessarily keep all of that capacity for itself.

Andrew believes that whether customers defect depends on whether Marvell Technology can give enough confidence to its existing DSP customers and Lumentum's optical customers that their existing supply relationships will not be affected.

This is also the cost of vertical integration: companies gain more control over the industry chain while potentially prompting customers to look for alternative suppliers.

Winner-Takes-All in Optical Communications: First-Mover Advantage Matters Less Than Million-Unit Delivery

Beyond vertical integration, the two analysts also discussed another striking competitive pattern in the optical communications industry: the market for new technology standards ultimately tends to be dominated by a small number of vendors.

Andrew calls this phenomenon the "IEEE lottery."

Whenever the industry introduces a new standard, typically five or six companies develop products simultaneously. A few years later, only two companies tend to capture the majority of shipments, together accounting for 80% to 90% of market share.

Therefore, being first to market is important, but whether a company can seize the opportunity during the early market formation phase determines whether it becomes the ultimate winner.

Scott further pointed out that competition in the current AI optical communications market places particular emphasis on production capacity.

"If you're first to market but can only produce ten thousand units, it doesn't really mean much. If you're second to market but can produce one million units, then the orders will come to you."

He cited Chinese manufacturer Eoptolink as an example. The company entered the 800G Ethernet optical module market slightly later than some competitors but became one of the world's leading suppliers through its production capacity advantage. Scott believes a similar competitive dynamic is emerging in 1.6T products.

This is also why Lumentum has attracted attention. Scott noted that the company has continuously expanded its indium phosphide (InP) manufacturing capacity over the past few years, with capacity undergoing multiple rounds of doubling, yet demand has grown even faster, making it difficult to satisfy all customer needs.

Lumentum's advantage also lies in having products that competitors cannot quickly replicate. Andrew specifically mentioned 200G EML, OCS, and high-power lasers.

He cautioned that many companies can claim they can develop similar products, but the real test is whether they can scale from producing a few hundred units to fifty thousand or even one million units. "Making one hundred and making one million are completely different things."

In the AI era, this scale advantage is further amplified. Andrew believes the value of optical components has also changed: in traditional telecommunications networks, lasers mainly help operators increase transmission capacity; in AI data centers, 1.6T interconnects could increase AI cluster training speed by two to three times.

When an optical technology can significantly improve the efficiency of an entire computing cluster, the price customers are willing to pay for it naturally changes.

Will Nvidia Join the Bidding?

At the end of the interview, the two analysts discussed whether Nvidia could be a potential buyer.

Nvidia has previously invested $2 billion each in Lumentum and Coherent, and established strategic partnerships with both companies. Andrew believes Nvidia also has incentives for vertical integration: its earlier acquisition of Mellanox was aimed at incorporating networking technology into its GPU systems. Extending further into optical components and OCS would be consistent with that approach.

Andrew also raised a possibility: if the news of Marvell Technology's negotiations with Lumentum was intentionally leaked, it might be a signal to other potential buyers, ultimately triggering a bidding war.

However, he explicitly stated that he has no insider knowledge of the deal and that this is purely his personal speculation. Nvidia's previous investments and procurement partnerships do not prove it intends to participate in an acquisition.

For Marvell Technology, the core challenge of this deal ultimately remains how to balance two things: gaining higher overall value through integrating chip and optical technologies, while preventing existing customers from turning to other suppliers due to competitive concerns.

Andrew Schmitt's judgment is that optical components have become a higher-value segment of AI infrastructure, and the economic logic for chip companies acquiring optical businesses is changing. Scott Wilkinson cautions that in the optical communications market, which is prone to winner-takes-all outcomes, production capacity and scale determine the final market share.

Marvell Technology wants to connect the industry chain from chips to optics. Whether it can simultaneously retain customers, technology, and market share will determine how much value this integration can ultimately create.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment