Lumentum (LITE.US) CEO Michael Hurlston on Thursday publicly defended the company's merger plan with chipmaker Marvell Technology (MRVL.US), acknowledging that the market's reaction to the deal has been disappointing.
"They have an outstanding business, we have an outstanding business, and we believe the combined company will be stronger," Hurlston said. But he also admitted: "Shareholders are not happy... the past few weeks have been very difficult."
A Merger That Triggered a Selloff
Since the close on October 28, Marvell and Lumentum shares have fallen 45% and 42%, respectively. On the evening of October 28, reports emerged that Marvell was close to striking a massive deal to acquire Lumentum, sending shockwaves through the market and triggering wild swings in both stocks. On the morning of November 2, the two sides officially announced the transaction, which is expected to close in the first half of 2028. At the time, the all-stock deal valued Lumentum at approximately $115 billion.
Starting October 29, Marvell shares posted double-digit percentage declines for three consecutive trading sessions, and have since recorded only three up days in total. Lumentum, meanwhile, edged slightly higher on October 29 as acquisition rumors circulated, before selling pressure set in — investors began questioning the value of the deal. Since merger news broke, the stock has closed higher on only five trading days.
Deal Rationale: AI Data Centers Shifting from Copper to Fiber
The merger would combine Marvell's semiconductor and networking technology with Lumentum's optical components business, against the backdrop of AI data centers increasingly shifting from copper cabling to fiber-optic connections to meet demand for faster data transmission. Hurlston said this technology transition — not merely an increase in the number of data centers — will be the primary growth engine for the combined entity.
Turning Shareholder Sentiment Around: Three Catalysts Ahead
"We still need to communicate with shareholders," Hurlston said, though he sees catalysts that could shift investor attitudes: first, Marvell's earnings report scheduled for December 1; second, the upcoming S-4 securities registration filing required for the merger process, along with the company's own financial results.
"Once everyone sees the earnings that (Marvell CEO Matt Murphy) will release in early December, sees the upcoming S-4 filing — which will detail the operating conditions of both companies — plus our own results... I think together these will convince shareholders that there's nothing wrong here, that these businesses are excellent on their own and only better together," he said. Hurlston has led Lumentum since February 2025.
The Other Side of the Plunge: A Broader AI Trade Retreat
It should be noted that the sharp declines in Marvell and Lumentum shares are not entirely attributable to investor resistance to the deal. In recent weeks, the market's sentiment toward the AI trade has cooled overall — rising borrowing costs have raised questions about the sustainability of AI infrastructure buildout, data center construction has encountered political headwinds, and the midterm election results are evidence of this political backlash. Hurlston acknowledged that these external factors are weighing on both stocks' valuation multiples, but stressed that he has much work to do to win shareholder support.
Despite macroeconomic concerns about AI buildout, Hurlston said Lumentum's demand has shown no signs of slowing. On the day the merger was announced, the company reported quarterly results that beat expectations, with revenue more than doubling year-over-year. "Once we report our results and demonstrate how strong both businesses are, I believe the valuation multiples will come back," he said.
Comments