Recently, the Japanese stock market has experienced significant volatility, particularly following the unexpected interest rate hike by the Bank of Japan (BoJ).
Recent comments by BoJ Deputy Governor Shinichi Uchida provided some stability to the market. Uchida stated that the BoJ will not raise interest rates further when financial and capital markets are unstable. This statement aimed to alleviate market anxiety and suggested that the central bank would pause further rate hikes until market conditions improved. This move has had a significant impact on the Japanese market and related investment tools, particularly two major Japanese ETFs: WisdomTree Japan Hedged Equity Fund (DXJ) and iShares MSCI Japan ETF (EWJ).
Source: VettaFi, data as of August 8, 2024
Source: VettaFi, data as of August 8, 2024
DXJ vs. EWJ: Investment Strategies and Market Performance
1. Investment Strategies
DXJ (WisdomTree Japan Hedged Equity Fund)
Hedging Currency Risk: DXJ primarily protects investors by hedging against yen currency risk, meaning its performance is not directly affected by yen exchange rate fluctuations. This strategy has worked well for DXJ during periods of yen depreciation, but the recent rapid appreciation of the yen has negatively impacted its performance.
Market Performance: DXJ has fallen 13% in the past month, exceeding the 9% decline of the unhedged EWJ. This indicates that DXJ's currency hedging strategy has had a negative impact on its investment returns in the context of yen appreciation. However, DXJ performed exceptionally well earlier this year, gaining nearly 35% during yen depreciation.
EWJ (iShares MSCI Japan ETF)
Unhedged Currency Risk: EWJ holds yen-denominated stocks, so its returns are directly affected by fluctuations in the yen exchange rate. When the yen depreciates, EWJ benefits from this trend.
Market Performance: Although EWJ has also experienced declines recently, its performance has been more stable compared to DXJ due to the lack of currency hedging. EWJ's smaller decline during yen appreciation reflects its sensitivity to currency risk.
2. Market Response
Against the backdrop of the BoJ's interest rate hike, the financial markets have seen significant turbulence. Uchida’s comments helped stabilize market sentiment by indicating that the BoJ would not continue raising rates until stability returned. This statement eased market concerns and contributed to a short-term rebound in the Japanese stock market. DXJ and EWJ, with their different currency exposure strategies, have shown varying investment risks and returns during this period.
Investment Recommendations
For DXJ Investors: If investors wish to avoid currency fluctuation risks and hold a positive long-term view on the Japanese market, DXJ may be a suitable choice. However, in the case of yen appreciation, DXJ’s hedging strategy could impact its investment returns.
For EWJ Investors: For those looking to benefit from yen currency fluctuations, EWJ might be more attractive. Despite the potential currency risk of an unhedged strategy, EWJ can offer higher returns during yen depreciation.
Overall, DXJ and EWJ represent two different investment strategies that cater to various market conditions and investor needs. Understanding the market dynamics and central bank policies affecting these ETFs will help investors make more informed investment decisions.
Comments