NVIDIA Earnings Tonight: Morgan Stanley Says Business Remains Strong, but the Real Worry Is the Interim CEO's Debut and the Guidance Outlook

Stock News11-17

NVIDIA (NVDA.US) will report results for the third quarter of fiscal 2027 on Wednesday morning Beijing time.

In its earnings preview, Morgan Stanley offered a straightforward assessment: the focus of this report is not the current quarter's numbers — those are already fully priced in — but rather the first management appearance since Jensen Huang stepped down, along with a guidance outlook for next year that the company "may not even provide." Morgan Stanley maintained its overweight rating and a price target of $267.

The Quarter's Numbers: The Part Without Suspense

Morgan Stanley expects F3Q27 revenue of $108.1 billion, slightly below the consensus of $108.9 billion, with earnings per share of $2.47, in line with consensus. Analysts wrote in the report that channel checks show "business remains strong," and even though some projects in Southeast Asia have slowed, "they still cannot meet demand."

What Really Matters on the Call: Three Things From Interim CEO Colette Kress

The real points worth hearing on the earnings call are three things about interim CEO Colette Kress: her stance on supporting and investing in the AI ecosystem, whether NVIDIA's innovation engine can continue, and an assessment of the risk of further tightening export controls. Jensen Huang typically did not give opening remarks but was extremely active in the Q&A session — Morgan Stanley notes that this portion, filled with "broad enthusiasm about AI's transformative impact," may decline at the margin. The report also directs readers to its November 13 special piece "NVIDIA: Which Way Forward," arguing that the management transition itself deserves more exploration than any single quarter's profit or loss.

The Divergence Beyond This Quarter: Morgan Stanley Sits About $70 Billion Below Consensus

Stretch the timeline out, and the divergence immediately becomes visible. Morgan Stanley forecasts fiscal 2028 revenue of $623 billion and earnings per share of $13.37, versus market consensus of $694.8 billion and $15.75 — a gap of roughly $100 billion, which is precisely the result of "the numbers cut last week": Morgan Stanley estimates next year's revenue growth at 52%, while the company's guidance is about 70% and customer demand growth is 100%. Still, analysts believe this figure has been "fully de-risked," and their checks continue to point to sustained optimism. The real suspense is that, with an interim CEO in place and so many questions outstanding, they are "not sure the company will give guidance next year."

Focus One: Demand — The Gap Between 100% and 70%

NVIDIA previously guided for about 70% revenue growth in fiscal 2028, based on customer demand growth of nearly 100%. But after the midterm elections, concerns about land, power and data center (LPS) constraints have risen markedly: SoftBank, a partner in NVIDIA's PORTS-Pike project, has written down $3.7 billion on related power equipment. Morgan Stanley's judgment is that the midterm elections pose a greater threat to 2028 and 2029 than to 2027 — data centers under construction will not be affected by new bans, and the ecosystem has time to work around bottlenecks; the hyperscalers it has spoken with acknowledge the challenges but are "confident these challenges can be overcome."

Financing is the other side of the same issue. Jensen Huang has historically supported regional neoclouds and used NVIDIA's balance sheet to help customers lock down land and power resources, and whether these commitments continue after the management change will be a focal point. Morgan Stanley gives an example: the three neoclouds CoreWeave, Nebius and IREN together guide to about $100 billion in capital expenditure for 2027, yet their combined market value has evaporated by $38 billion over the past month. If the claim of "100% demand growth" partly depends on financing, then whether that financing keeps coming — especially for long-tail smaller customers in the ACIE segment — needs continuous monitoring.

Morgan Stanley's trump card is that demand from hyperscalers is already enough to support its forecast, with next year's shipments equivalent to roughly "high teens GW," and SpaceX alone planning to deploy 10GW. The report also deliberately flags a more fundamental variable: investors' willingness to put money into AI is "a greater risk to the buildout trajectory than anything NVIDIA can control" — in other words, what really needs to be heard tonight is whether changes in the financing environment have made their way into management's wording.

Focus Two: Supply and Guidance — A Reiteration Is a Positive

Morgan Stanley does not expect any change to the full-year growth guidance, but out of caution it has already cut its revenue forecast by about 10% on its own due to China export control risk. On the supply side, memory in particular "remains very tight," with no sign of easing — "if anything, what we are seeing is tightening."

One intriguing detail: some investors questioned why NVIDIA has been slow to reiterate guidance since the CEO change. Morgan Stanley's read is actually a positive signal — by convention, earnings are often accompanied by an upward revision, and pre-announcing may be "better left for the day of the earnings release."

Focus Three: The Rubin Ramp — First Quarter of Mass Shipments

This is the first quarter of mass shipments for Rubin, and a quarter ago the expectation was that Rubin would account for about 20% of data center revenue (roughly $20 billion). The ramp has not been smooth: key testing partner King Yuan Electronics has cut its 2026 guidance for a second consecutive quarter, partly due to Rubin ramping more slowly than expected. But Morgan Stanley does not believe this will hit NVIDIA's revenue recognition: first, shorter testing times can explain part of the gap; second, its estimate of flat quarter-on-quarter growth in the January quarter "should still be conservative," with the bigger Rubin ramp coming in the January and April quarters.

The Latest Testimony on the Demand Side

In an appendix, Morgan Stanley compiled what cloud providers said about AI capital expenditure on their earnings calls during the Q3 reporting season, which can serve as background for tonight's call: Amazon said it "installs an AI accelerator roughly every 14 seconds," with payback periods still shortening — its 2026 capital expenditure is about $220 billion, 2027 will be significantly more, and it has "a clear line of sight to future returns." Google said AI investment "drove the highest query growth in five years" and believes every dollar of capital expenditure "can support more revenue over time." Oracle said "demand for AI is real and enormous; building capacity and financing are just tasks — tasks may be hard, but they can all be solved." Meta raised the low end of its capital expenditure range from $35 billion to $37 billion. Microsoft said "I would be surprised if we have less than 13GW of compute online before the end of next year." SpaceX said there is a "non-zero possibility" of bringing more than 20GW of in-house compute online next year, and it plans to deploy 440,000 Vera Rubin units by the end of the second quarter to build the strongest training cluster. On the neocloud side, Nebius said "customers are committing to us for longer terms, at higher prices, with more prepayments," while CoreWeave said its existing capacity "can be sold out to buyers waiting in line."

Valuation: Three Scenarios and Option-Implied Probabilities

Morgan Stanley's three scenarios: a bull case of $336 (about 21 times fiscal 2027 earnings per share of $16), with triggers including supply easing that pushes data center revenue above expectations, a revenue-sharing agreement bringing billions of dollars in pure-profit revenue, and GPU-powered AI PCs opening the consumer market; a base case of $267 (about 20 times $13.37, a discount to the broader semiconductor sector and a slight premium to the overall market — Morgan Stanley explains that high market share and high gross margins actually leave the valuation multiple "lacking near-term expansion leverage"); and a bear case of $130 (about 10 times), corresponding to two major debates both turning negative: supply catching up to demand faster than expected, or competitors entering and customers' in-house chips taking share.

Based on option-implied volatility, the probabilities over one year of breaking above the bull price, rising above the base price and falling below the bear price are about 0.9%, 11.2% and 24.2% respectively — the options market is clearly pricing downside scenarios more heavily than upside. The sell-side consensus distribution is 77% overweight, 22% neutral and 2% underweight. In Morgan Stanley's risk-reward theme scoring, the new data era, pricing power and long-term growth are all positive.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment