On November 9, the National Bureau of Statistics released October price data: the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose 0.7% year-on-year, with the growth rate slowing by 0.2 percentage points from the previous month, while core CPI rose 0.8% year-on-year; the Producer Price Index (PPI) rose 5.7% year-on-year, with the growth rate expanding by 0.7 percentage points from the previous month. The difference between the two year-on-year growth rates reached 5 percentage points, further widening the scissors gap.
Zhang Lin, deputy director of the Far East Credit Research Institute, told reporters that this divergence is essentially a combination of "upstream cost shocks and weak downstream demand," but "it is not sustainable." Looking at October, core CPI, which excludes food and energy prices, remained below 1%, indicating that demand-driven price recovery is still underway. PPI gains were highly concentrated in the energy chain and artificial intelligence-related industrial chains. After October, international oil prices have declined somewhat, and the base effect from the same period last year is gradually rising. PPI year-on-year growth is likely near its peak for this cycle, and next year may show a trend of "declining from a high level with the center shifting downward."
Beneath the aggregate data, three types of price changes present three different signals: data storage equipment prices rose more than 40% year-on-year, automobile manufacturing prices turned flat after three consecutive months of month-on-month declines, and gold jewelry prices saw an expanded month-on-month decline.
Su Jian, a professor at Peking University's School of Economics, told reporters that the decline in gold jewelry prices was mainly affected by international gold price fluctuations, with rising expectations of Federal Reserve rate hikes pushing gold prices lower; the stabilization of automobile manufacturing prices was mainly the result of capacity reduction and some easing of supply-demand contradictions; and the sharp rise in prices of data storage equipment and similar products was driven by a technology boom and strong end-user demand.
PPI Growth May Be Near Its Peak for This Cycle
In October, PPI year-on-year growth hit a new high for the year. At the same time, the difference between CPI and PPI year-on-year growth rates reached 5 percentage points, with diverging trends further widening the scissors gap. Specifically, CPI rose 0.7% year-on-year, with the growth rate slowing by 0.2 percentage points from the previous month. PPI rose 5.7% year-on-year, with the growth rate expanding by 0.7 percentage points from the previous month. Looking back at September, PPI rose 5.0% year-on-year and CPI rose 0.9% year-on-year, with a difference of 4.1 percentage points.
Zhang Lin also noted that this means profitability in upstream industries is improving, while midstream and downstream industries, especially major energy users and consumer goods manufacturers, are facing gross margin pressure. He further mentioned the time-lag issue: the transmission from oil prices to domestic PPI takes about half a month to one month, while the impact on corporate costs takes one to two quarters. Therefore, from the fourth quarter to the first quarter of next year, cost pressure on midstream and downstream enterprises may be at its most pronounced stage.
Looking further at CPI, Zhang Lin noted that year-on-year, gasoline prices rose 22.4%, with the growth rate expanding by 5.8 percentage points from the previous month, contributing about 0.63 percentage points to the CPI increase, driving energy price growth from 7.3% last month to 9.9% this month; food prices fell 2.9%, with the decline expanding by 1.2 percentage points from the previous month, dragging CPI down by about 0.49 percentage points. The two basically offset each other. Core CPI, excluding food and energy prices, rose 0.8% year-on-year, with the growth rate slowing by 0.2 percentage points from the previous month, remaining below 1%, "indicating that demand-driven price recovery is still underway, which also determines that it is not yet time for macro policy to tighten."
External factors dominated October price data. Su Jian analyzed that the relatively low CPI year-on-year growth rate was mainly due to relatively insufficient domestic demand; the continued rise in PPI year-on-year growth was mainly driven by rising international energy prices, with demand-side effects playing a relatively smaller role. Dong Lijuan, chief statistician of the Urban Division of the National Bureau of Statistics, said that rising international energy prices drove domestic oil and natural gas extraction and coal mining and washing prices up 6.0% and 2.7% respectively; affected by the transmission of upstream basic energy prices and the release of demand for thermal coal and gas during the critical preparation period for peak winter demand, downstream refined petroleum product manufacturing, organic chemical raw material manufacturing, coal processing, and gas production and supply prices rose 6.8%, 6.8%, 3.2%, and 1.5% respectively. The six industries together contributed about 0.61 percentage points to the month-on-month PPI increase, exceeding 80% of the total gain.
Regarding the outlook for this divergence, Zhang Lin believes it "is not sustainable": after October, international oil prices have declined somewhat, and the base effect from the same period last year is gradually rising. PPI year-on-year growth is likely near its peak for this cycle and may show a trend of "declining from a high level with the center shifting downward" next year; CPI will recover moderately as service consumption recovers and base effects change.
Three Signals
Storage equipment, automobiles, and gold are three areas that have attracted considerable attention recently. Regarding price changes in these three areas, Zhang Lin summarized them as: "Storage is an industrial price, automobiles are a competitive price, and gold is a financial price."
First, storage. Year-on-year, in October, prices of data storage equipment, tablet computers, computers, and mobile phones rose 45.4%, 29.3%, 23.0%, and 16.7% respectively, with the four items together contributing about 0.26 percentage points to the CPI increase. From the demand side, Su Jian pointed out that the sharp price increases in data storage equipment and similar products were driven by a technology boom and strong end-user demand. Zhang Lin categorized this as an industrial cycle signal, considering it a "structural price increase driven by both cost-push and demand-pull." He broke down the transmission chain: rigid demand for high-bandwidth memory and server DRAM from artificial intelligence servers has squeezed traditional production capacity, storage contract prices saw historic increases this year, and price increases transmitted along the industrial chain to finished products. Dong Lijuan also mentioned that month-on-month, the continued empowerment of industrial transformation by artificial intelligence drove increased demand and higher prices in related industries, with prices in the electrical machinery and equipment manufacturing and computer, communication, and other electronic equipment manufacturing industries both rising 0.1%; year-on-year, prices in the computer, communication, and other electronic equipment manufacturing industry rose 5.9%, with the growth rate expanding from the previous month.
This differs fundamentally from a pure imported cost shock. Zhang Lin emphasized that this type of price increase has support from orders, shipments, and profitability, and is of relatively high quality; however, it will also raise end-product costs and suppress some consumer demand, and as new capacity is released, there is pressure for a cyclical decline.
Next, automobiles. Month-on-month, Dong Lijuan pointed out that production capacity in some industries was adjusted in an orderly manner, supply-demand relationships improved somewhat, prices in the non-metallic mineral products industry rose 0.8%, and automobile manufacturing prices turned flat after three consecutive months of decline. It is worth noting that automobile manufacturing is also among the five industries with the largest downward pull on PPI year-on-year prices, with declines ranging from 1.6% to 5.2%. It is evident that the industry's month-on-month decline has stopped, but year-on-year it remains in negative territory. The price change in automobile manufacturing carries implications for the supply side rather than the demand side.
Su Jian pointed out that the stabilization of automobile manufacturing prices was mainly the result of capacity reduction and some easing of supply-demand contradictions. Zhang Lin also said this is a signal of the industry's competitive landscape, reflecting a marginal easing of the price war under capacity governance and "anti-involution" policies, with the supply side actively adjusting; however, demand has not strengthened significantly, and automobile retail sales are still declining, so it "looks more like the decline has stopped, not that prices are recovering."
Finally, gold. Month-on-month, in October, gold jewelry prices fell 5.9%, with the decline expanding by 3.8 percentage points from the previous month, dragging CPI down by about 0.03 percentage points. Year-on-year, gold jewelry prices rose 4.5%, with the growth rate slowing by 18.0 percentage points from the previous month, contributing about 0.02 percentage points to the CPI increase. Zhang Lin pointed out that the month-on-month decline in gold jewelry is an asset price signal, not a consumer demand signal. How does this signal relate to the macroeconomy? Zhang Lin's explanation is that it affects CPI, but is more a reflection of fluctuations in the "other goods and services" category, "and does not mean household consumption is weakening, nor does it imply a change in the inflation trend."
Comments