Asian financial markets are displaying sharply divergent trends, creating a scenario reminiscent of parallel economic universes. South Asian and Southeast Asian markets are facing pressure due to rising oil prices, which are negatively impacting trade balances, leading to declines in the stock markets of India, Indonesia, and the Philippines. Conversely, East Asian markets are enthusiastically embracing semiconductor and artificial intelligence (AI) companies, with stock indices in South Korea and Taiwan repeatedly reaching new all-time highs, largely disregarding the impact of Middle Eastern geopolitical conflicts. This stark divergence reflects two distinct global investment narratives: capital is being aggressively sold off from economies hit by high energy costs, while simultaneously flowing into future core growth sectors, ignoring short-term geopolitical risks.
With little progress in U.S.-Iran negotiations and the unresolved dispute over control of the Strait of Hormuz, the risk of prolonged energy supply disruptions persists, potentially widening the performance gap between Asian regional markets further. Strategist Marvin Chen pointed out that a key reason for the significant underperformance of South Asian markets compared to tech-driven East Asian economies is their pronounced weakness in the technology sector and lack of exposure to core AI industries. "While South Korea, Taiwan, and Japan share similar dependencies on energy imports, South Asia faces structural developmental shortcomings and urgently needs to actively integrate into regional technology supply chains to overcome its challenges."
When the Iran conflict initially escalated in late February, Asian markets experienced a synchronized sell-off, as soaring oil prices severely impacted energy-importing economies. However, as the conflict has persisted, market risk aversion has gradually subsided, with capital flowing back to the pre-conflict market narrative, concentrating heavily in AI-related assets. Currently, East Asian markets have largely recovered all losses incurred after the conflict began. Taiwan's benchmark index has gained nearly 10% since the conflict started, leading gains among major Asian markets. South Korea's composite index has risen about 4% over the same period, while China's CSI 300 Index and Japan's Nikkei 225 have also posted steady, modest gains.
In contrast, performance in other regions remains weak. India's Nifty 50 index has fallen approximately 5%, the MSCI ASEAN Index has declined around 7%, and benchmark indices in the Philippines and Indonesia have both dropped more than 10%.
The resilience of East Asian markets is rooted in the region's core industrial advantages. Local leading companies are deeply embedded in the global semiconductor supply chain, which forms the fundamental bedrock of the current AI industry boom. Surging order demand for industry leaders such as Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, Samsung Electronics, and SK Hynix means the sector's prosperity is largely insulated from geopolitical turbulence in the short term, allowing it to fully capitalize on the thematic tailwinds.
This stands in stark contrast to the predicament faced by South and Southeast Asia, which are mired in the challenges of high oil prices. Rising crude costs are fueling inflation, eroding current account surpluses, leading to persistent weakness in local currencies, and severely constraining policy flexibility. Lacking the empowerment of a strong tech sector and struggling to attract cross-border capital inflows, markets in this region continue to underperform.
The foreign exchange market mirrors the divergence seen in equities. The New Taiwan dollar has shown relative stability, while the Indian rupee and most Southeast Asian currencies face significant pressure, with high depreciation pressures.
According to Sonal Varma, Chief Economist for Asia ex-Japan at Nomura Holdings, three core factors are driving this Asian market divergence. First, India and Southeast Asia have higher external energy dependencies and weaker risk buffers, making them highly vulnerable to energy shocks. Second, East Asian economies possess more robust fiscal fundamentals. Third, the powerful tailwind from the AI industry wave is bolstering East Asian economies and capital markets but offers little benefit to South and Southeast Asia.
However, there are nuances within this regional split. Malaysia, as a net oil exporter, has somewhat mitigated the impact of the energy crisis, with its currency performing significantly better than its ASEAN peers. Singapore, benefiting from safe-haven capital inflows, demonstrates stronger resilience in its bond, currency, and stock markets compared to the rest of Southeast Asia. Although the South Korean stock market has performed well, its bond market and currency remain weak due to energy shock impacts. To curb inflation and stabilize living costs, the South Korean government has implemented its first fuel price cap policy in nearly three decades, alongside expanding fuel tax cuts and increasing fiscal support measures to counter the effects of rising energy prices.
Varma indicated that Nomura is currently focusing on several regional divergence trading strategies, including long positions on the Euro paired with short positions on the Indian Rupee, long Singapore Dollar/short Indonesian Rupiah positions, and carry trades in Thailand and South Korea.
Notably, China, the world's largest oil importer, has demonstrated remarkable resilience against the current geopolitical shock from Iran. The scale advantages of its domestic new energy industry and the accelerating adoption of new energy vehicles have effectively offset imported inflationary pressures from rising fuel costs.
Looking ahead, the AI thematic faces a critical test. Christopher Wood, Global Head of Equity Strategy at Jefferies Financial Group, noted in a report that global tech giants like Meta Platforms and Microsoft are set to report earnings this week, with market focus squarely on their capital expenditure plans. There is widespread market skepticism about whether the capital-intensive model of large-scale AI investment can be sustainably supported by corporate cash flows over the long term.
Gary Tan, a Portfolio Manager at Allspring Global Investments, believes that as long as international oil prices remain elevated and capital continues to favor tech-oriented economies with stronger risk resilience, the divergence in Asian markets will persist. Present-day Asia has become the central arena for the contest between two major macro narratives: one driven by the long-term industrial transformation powered by AI, and the other by the short-term macroeconomic pressures stemming from geopolitical conflict.
Comments