BlackRock's (BLK.US) fund holdings in Strategy (MSTR.US) face uncertainty as MSCI prepares to remove the company from multiple indices after the close on November 30.
According to Woofun AI, funds tracking these indices must rebalance their portfolios, but the 123,000 Strategy shares held by BlackRock will not necessarily translate into market sell orders, as the final outcome depends on the operational mechanisms of different funds.
Under the MSCI USA Index framework, Strategy's Class A shares are classified as a "non-operating company," making them subject to removal effective December 1.
BlackRock's iShares MSCI USA ETF (ticker MLRG) directly tracks this index, and its public holdings show that as of November 13, the fund held 5,227 Strategy shares valued at approximately $583,000.
MLRG employs a representative sampling strategy, meaning the manager is not required to hold every stock in the index but instead selects a portfolio that closely tracks index performance.
The prospectus allows the manager to hold investments outside the index when it helps track the benchmark, including arrangements made in anticipation of constituent changes.
Therefore, while Strategy's exit constitutes grounds for adjustment, the documents do not mandate a one-time sale of all 5,227 shares at the November 30 close, giving the manager considerable operational flexibility.
In contrast, another BlackRock fund, the iShares MSCI USA Swap UCITS ETF (traded in Europe under ticker MUSD), tracks the same MSCI USA Index but operates under a completely different mechanism.
MUSD does not directly replicate index constituents but instead obtains index performance through total return swap contracts with financial institutions.
The fund uses a basket of developed market equities as collateral, exchanging them with a counterparty for MSCI USA Index returns.
Once Strategy is removed from the index, it no longer contributes to the index performance delivered under the contract, but this does not mean MUSD must sell any Strategy shares it may hold.
Since contract details and counterparty risk adjustments are not disclosed in fund documents, it is impossible to calculate the exact number of shares the fund must sell based solely on MUSD's asset size and Strategy's weight in the index, and this opacity makes it difficult for the market to accurately assess potential selling pressure.
Woofun AI data shows that the holdings of BlackRock's three main funds are clearer.
The iShares MSCI World ETF (URTH) tracks developed market companies and reported holding 29,300 Strategy shares valued at approximately $3.3 million as of November 13; the iShares MSCI ACWI ETF tracks developed and emerging market companies and reported holding 88,500 shares valued at approximately $9.9 million on the same date.
Since these broad-based indices include U.S. components, Strategy's removal from the MSCI USA Index will also affect them.
Combined with MLRG's 5,227 shares, these three funds collectively hold 123,000 Strategy shares with a total value of $13.74 million.
Both URTH and ACWI employ representative sampling, giving managers some discretion in matching the index, so the adjustment of these 123,000 shares is not a simple linear selling process but a complex adjustment spread across different fund strategies.
Additionally, edge cases and macro data further reveal the complexity of the issue.
The iShares ESG Advanced MSCI USA ETF (USXF) tracks an MSCI USA version with additional screening rules and reported holding 16,100 Strategy shares as of November 13, but as of November 17, the standard index announcement had not clarified how this specialized version would be adjusted; MSCI's announcement for specialized indices is scheduled for November 18, so USXF is not included in the aforementioned total.
On the other hand, Invesco QQQ, which tracks the Nasdaq-100, is not affected by MSCI rules as its inclusion criteria are independent.
Strategy's official data shows that funds tracking MSCI global investable indices collectively hold approximately 13 million of its shares, equivalent to 3.1% of basic shares outstanding, a figure far larger than the sample of BlackRock's three funds, but the specific holding dates and fund lists are not public, adding to the uncertainty of market predictions.
A decrease in reported holdings does not equate to someone selling in the secondary market.
ETF size fluctuates due to investor subscriptions or redemptions, and when a fund shrinks, some shares may leave through the redemption process, where financial institutions return fund shares to the ETF in exchange for underlying securities, allowing Strategy shares to transfer to other institutions without the fund selling on an exchange.
The next holdings filing will only record a smaller position without revealing where those shares ultimately went.
MUSD's contract structure further limits observability, as counterparty adjustments cannot be directly reflected through fund holdings.
Even if holdings changes are visible, it is difficult to distinguish how much of the stock price movement is driven by MSCI, especially when investors can trade ahead of time.
Strategy will ultimately lose its place in these funds' performance objectives, which could weaken demand for its shares and affect the financing appeal of the company led by Michael Saylor that issues securities to buy Bitcoin, but index removal itself does not require Strategy to sell any Bitcoin.
For more major Hong Kong stock news, download the Zhitong Finance app. For more Hong Kong and overseas wealth management information, please visit www.zhitongcaijing.com (search "Zhitong Finance"); to join the Zhitong Hong Kong stock investment group, please add Zhitong customer service WeChat (ztcjkf).
Comments