The crisis in the U.S. commercial real estate market, particularly in office properties, is intensifying at a faster-than-expected pace. The latest data reveals that the default rate for office loans within commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS)—a key barometer of market stress—has reached a historic high.
According to asset analytics firm Trepp, the U.S. office CMBS default rate soared to 11.8% in October 2023. This figure not only marks an all-time high but also surpasses the 10.7% peak recorded during the 2008 global financial crisis.
More concerning is the contagion effect of the crisis. Stress is no longer confined to the office sector—the CMBS default rate for multifamily properties also surged by 53 basis points in October to 7.1%, the worst level since 2015.
The speed of this downturn is staggering. In just three years, the office CMBS default rate has skyrocketed by 10 percentage points from 1.8% in October 2022. During this period, the Federal Reserve's aggressive interest rate hikes tightened credit conditions, while borrowers increasingly recognized that their office properties had become obsolete in the new economic reality. Once these mortgages were securitized and sold, the risks were transferred to institutional investors worldwide.
**Structural Shift and the "Refinancing Wall"** The core issue plaguing the U.S. office market is not a cyclical downturn but a fundamental transformation. Remote work, now accounting for 28% of full-time work hours—nearly six times pre-pandemic levels—has become entrenched. Companies are downsizing office footprints, driving the national vacancy rate to 20%. In markets like San Francisco’s downtown (36.9%) and Austin (27.2%), vacancies are even more severe. With such a structural demand decline, refinancing alone cannot resolve the crisis.
The looming "maturity wall" exacerbates the situation. In 2025 alone, $957 billion in commercial real estate debt will come due, including $230 billion in office loans. Many loans originally maturing in 2024 were extended to 2025, as lenders bet on lower rates and rebounding property values—a gamble that has clearly failed. More debt will mature in 2026 and 2027. With higher interest rates and declining valuations, refinancing is no longer viable, making defaults inevitable.
**High-Profile Defaults Mount** Notable defaults are emerging nationwide. The Bravern Office Commons in Bellevue, Washington—a landmark property once leased by Microsoft—saw its $304 million mortgage enter default in October. The property’s value has plummeted 56% from $605 million in early 2020 to $268 million as of two months ago, per Morningstar.
Other defaults include The Factory in Long Island City ($300 million loan) and Washington D.C.’s Federal Center Plaza (balloon payment default). Some loans, like Houston’s HP Plaza, have been temporarily "cured" through extensions, but this merely delays the reckoning.
**Contagion Risk: Who Bears the Losses?** The fallout is spreading to regional banks with outsized commercial real estate exposure. Among the top 158 U.S. banks, 59 have CRE loans exceeding 300% of their capital. New York Community Bancorp already booked $2.7 billion in losses in late 2023. If loan extensions fail, smaller banks face severe capital shortfalls.
Municipal budgets are also at risk. Plummeting office values threaten property tax revenues. New Orleans, for example, projects a $1.4 billion budget gap by 2027 due to downtown office defaults and vacancies. Tax shortfalls could trigger service cuts, further eroding urban appeal and accelerating tenant departures—a vicious cycle.
Under CMBS structures, losses ultimately fall on global institutional investors—bond funds, insurers, pension funds, and REITs—who purchased securitized mortgages. As defaults rise and collateral values shrink, these investors must absorb mounting losses.
Comments