The share price of Mediterranean-inspired fast-casual chain Cava Group Inc. (CAVA.US) has more than doubled over the past five months. However, according to the only Wall Street analyst currently bearish on the stock, this rally has gone too far. Northcoast Research analyst Jim Sanderson initiated coverage on the restaurant operator this week with a "Sell" rating and set a price target of $63, the lowest among all analysts. This came just one day after Cava's stock closed at $97.39, reaching its highest level since May 2025 and marking a rebound of over 120% from its low in late November of last year. Sanderson's price target implies a potential downside of more than 32% from Thursday's closing price. In an interview, Sanderson stated, "Based on the macroeconomic conditions I'm observing, its risk profile is concerning," adding that the stock's rise has made its holding cost expensive. "For me, the red flag is that customer traffic at some mature locations appears quite mediocre. In many cases, these locations have shown negative traffic trends for consecutive months compared to peers." Cava's recent surge has been driven by an optimistic annual outlook released by the company in late February, contrasting sharply with its nearly 50% decline in 2025. Previously, investors had turned bearish on Cava and its competitors, such as Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc. and Sweetgreen Inc., due to concerns about inflation and slowing economic growth. This rebound has resulted in Cava's shares trading at a significant premium compared to both the broader market and its rivals, becoming a major point of contention on Wall Street. Cava's forward price-to-earnings ratio stands at a high 159 times, compared to Chipotle's approximately 28 times and the S&P 500 Index's near 21 times. DA Davidson analyst Matt Curtis, who initiated coverage on Cava in March with a "Neutral" rating and an $80 price target, believes Cava's "spicy" valuation limits the potential for further stock price gains. Compiled data shows that, aside from Sanderson's "Sell" rating, the stock currently holds 17 "Buy" ratings and 13 "Hold" ratings.
Comments